weskimad
Tuesday, February 27, 2007 6:13:00 PM
Just wanted to express some gratitude for your assistance. Like many, I've noticed the humidity dropping in my humidor, and decided to give the kitty liter a try. I picked up a bag of crystal clear litter pearls (no blue chips), and my humidity rose up to 64 within hours. Amazing. I'm amazed that this has been much more effective than just a dish of water. I guess it's a surface area thing. Just wanted to say thanks and happy bidding.
sw48362
Tuesday, February 27, 2007 6:17:00 PM
That's what happens when the kitty pees on your cigars! lol! Some say they don't work! The kitty knows better!
donutboy2000
Tuesday, February 27, 2007 7:06:00 PM
Kitty litter puts moisture into the air, but it will not remove moisture to regulate the humidity as the beads do.
GreenWolf70
Tuesday, February 27, 2007 7:56:00 PM
#1. Thank you.

Donutboy: The kitty litter beads work exactly the same way as those more expensive beads. They hold RH around 65%. They can both add and subtract moisture.

Dgar
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 1:40:00 AM
It seems they would have to absorb moisture, otherwise they wouldnt be to effective has KL???

I've never used KL, but I've been considering it for a new cooler, many BOTL have reported good luck using it.

Slimboli
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 3:58:00 AM
Kitty Litter vs beads.

It's been discussed many times, and they are not the same product. Can you "train" the kitty litter to perform like the beads? Some say yes, some say no. I say no, maybe yes in perfect conditions. The beads get my vote.

Let’s start with the basics.

Humidification beads are a moisture sensitive silica material which absorbs and desorbs moisture in order to offset changes in relative humidity (RH) in your humidor. The beads are generally available preset to a specific RH, in the case of cigars 60%, 65% and 70%. Opinions differ as to what is the “best” RH for cigars but most BOTLs seem to prefer 65% and that is my experience as well.

Humidification beads were first developed for the art and museum industry and are used extensively by that industry for the stable storage of priceless artifacts and art. The manufacturer also supplies places such as the Smithsonian and The National Archives.

A question that is often asked; “Are humidification beads the same as ordinary desiccant silica gel?”

Definitely NOT!

Humidification beads give off water vapor, as well as absorb it, to maintain a specific RH which is ideal for a cigars particular need. This is not the case with silica gel which can only absorb water then must be dried out after it is saturated. By nature silica gel is not meant to control humidity, only lower it. Humidification beads are the premier product for precise control in terms of performance, cost effectiveness, and simplicity.

One good point to remember is humidification beads have an indefinite life span. There is nothing to wear out and all that is needed to maintain them is either the addition of distilled water or the drying out of the beads if they become water logged.

You will notice that every time I mention the fluid that is added to the beads I will state “distilled water”. This is extremely important, anything other than distilled water will ultimately ruin the beads. All the impurities in tap water will be drawn in by the beads and remain there. Ultimately the beads will get plugged up and not work anymore. The same is true with any type of humidifier solution (also known as 50/50 solution) this will also ruin the beads in the long run.

The question often asked the most is, “How much do I need for my ______?”

Here are some quantities for various containers.

5 cubic feet requires 1 pound of humidification beads.

1/3 pound of beads per 50 quarts (coolerdors)

1 ounce of beads per 50 count in a desktop humi (so a 100 count would need 2 ounces, 150 count 3 ounces etc.)

For our metric friends: Each pound of beads will condition 141,584.233 cubic centimeters.

Calculating the cubic area of your humi:

Measure the depth, width and height of you humi (example is 24” depth, 36” wide and 48” height)

Multiply the three; 24x36x48=41472 cubic inches

Divide 41472 by 1728 (number of cubic inches in a cubic foot) 41472/1728= 24 cubic feet.

Divide the cubic feet by 5 (number of cubic feet per pound) 24/5 = 4.8

You would need 4.8 pounds of humidification beads for this humi.

Remember that these calculations and quantities are the minumum amount you should put in a given space for control of RH. You can however place more in your humidor than these amounts without the chance of harming your cigars or the humidor, the right RH will still be maintained. The additional beads will only increase the amount of stored moisture which will just extend the amount of time before any distilled water needs to be added. They will also help the humidor recover to the proper RH quicker after the lid or door is opened.

Another question that keeps coming up is; “How do I add distilled water to the beads when they get dry?”

There are a number of ways to do this but whichever method you chose only add enough distilled water to make 70-75% of the beads clear and the rest either opaque or white. This gives the beads the ability to absorb excess humidity introduced by more moist cigars you may add to your humidor.

The method most prefered is using a spray bottle. Purchase an inexpensive spray bottle at the grocery store and fill it with distilled water. When the beads need water just spray them until they have absorbed enough distilled water. This method will work well if you have the beads in a bag or dish.

You can just pour distilled water on the beads and pour off the excess. A lot of folks do it this way but the beads can fracture when it is done this way. One thing to remember, fracturing will not affect the efficiency of the beads or ruin them in any way, they will still do their job.

You can put a container of distilled water, like a bowl, next to the beads and let them absorb the distilled water in this way. When they have absorbed all they can remove the bowl. This method is effective but takes a while for the beads to absorb the water.

A method developed by a BOTL at another fourm is very easy. Place a paper towel that has been wet down with distilled water on the beads. They will soak up the moisture and re-charge.

Another question is; If my beads are going white, should I add distilled water until they are all clear?

The optimal is to have about 70-75% of them clear. Don't try to get them all clear because if you do they cannot absorb any sudden rise in humidity in your humi.

Another question is; “What do I put the beads in?”

A great variety of containers are possible. You can use a drawstring mesh bag, place the beads in a shot glass or small dish, put them is a leftover container with holes drilled in the lid, nylon stockings (be careful stealing them from your wife or significant other), the aluminum cases I sell to contain the beads (replaces the black plastic rectangular humidifier that comes with alot of humidors) or any other container. The main point of whatever container you choose is to have the greatest amount of surface area as possible exposed to the air. If possible the beads should be no more than 1 to 1 ½ inches deep, this way they will work the best.

Lastly we will deal with; “How can I tell when the beads need water?”

This is very easy. The color of the beads is the dead give away. When they are full of distilled water they are pretty much clear and when they are completely dried out they are a bright white. Believe me you will be able to tell the difference.

Grampa
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 4:48:00 AM
Great info Slim, thanks.

Gramps

drnos
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 5:33:00 AM
Silicon dioxide is silicon dioxide is silicon dioxide. It's SiO2 whether the package says "Museum Relative Humidity Stabilization Compound" or "Treat Your Cigars Ever-So-Gently With Heavenly Beads" or "Kitty Litter."

Some people just can't get past the kitty litter label. Fine, I don't care.

But I think it's like not drinking water because there's also water in your toilet.

JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 5:46:00 AM
I have trouble with the whole "distilled water" theory.

Doesn't the impurities from the cigars, and the air, immediately make it no longer distilled. Not to mention , a lot of "tap water" has anti mold additives. Does it really matter??????

chemyst
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 6:28:00 AM
IMHO using tap water doesn't make any difference

if you let a cup sit out for a day or so. Letting

the tap water sit out will allow the chlorine and

fluorine gases(and any other odoriferous gases)

in the tap water escape and leaves water with just

a few minerals in it. When the water vapor evaporates,

the minerals are left. The minerals are called

water spots.

Remember, evaporation is just verry sloow distillation

at room temperature. Minerals and other impurities

aren't carried with the water vapor. It's only the

dissolved gases, which may impart an odor or taste

to your cigars, that must be released BEFORE you put

the water in your humi.

The reason you use distilled water with beads and foam

is that eventually the minerals(water spots) will clog

up the surface of your beads and foam. Once the beads

become clogged/ineffective, you must replace them.

BOTTOM LINE ===>

So, if you're using JUST WATER to keep your RH up in

the winter you can use a shot glass of tap water that's

been out for a day, to let the Cl and F gases escape.

But if you're using beads or foam, using tap water

can reduce their effectiveness, so use distilled water.

If your water has smells or tastes, NOT of Chlorine or

Fluorine, don't use it in your humi... period.

Chemyst

BTW, usually only municipal water/city water has Cl

and F added for bacterial and dental protection.

Folks in the country often have wells and usually

don't add chemicals to purify our water. Soft water

has fewer minerals than hard water.

chemyst
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 6:33:00 AM
Final note...

If you charge your beads indirectly, using a dish of

water next to the beads, you can use tap water in the

dish, as long as you let it sit out for a day.

If you charge your beads directly with water, using a

spray or soak or wet paper towel, use distilled water.

Chemyst

teedubbya
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 7:03:00 AM
so if my cat (I don't have one) pees on the kitty liter, rather than just drying things out, the litter beads will actually humidify my house with urine?

JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 7:15:00 AM
The Chemyst has spoken!! Thank you sir. I knew somebody would help with that , just didn't expect it that quick.
02
  • 02
  • Aficionado
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 9:27:00 AM
Good GOD!

I PAID 78 CENTS FOR A GALLON OF DISTILLED WATER! I CANNOT AFFORD TO BUY MORE CIGARS. PLEASE SEND ME CIGARS ASAP!

On another note, a pound of beads costs about as much as a premium 5-pack. What's the big deal?

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 9:47:00 AM
^ just think how much you could have saved by using paintballs and air conditioner condensate runoff.
Slimboli
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 9:58:00 AM
So drnos ... if silicon dioxide is silicon dioxide is silicon dioxide ...

... explain to me how is is that the 'beads' have different specific RH levels ... and how that is accomplished.

JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:25:00 AM
That is a very good question...how do it do it?
JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:27:00 AM
02, I don't think it has anything to do with the cost it has to do with knowing why and how and if.
rkdub
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:35:00 AM
To make kitty rockets. lol
02
  • 02
  • Aficionado
Wednesday, February 28, 2007 10:41:00 AM
JHC, thanks. I, too, would like an answer to Slim's question. I have seen posts about this on other boards where it appeared people knew what they were talking about. Maybe I can find it again.