Big John
Sunday, March 4, 2007 6:05:00 AM
Like many others I am a sucker for most of the new lines put out (with alarming regularity) by some manufacturers such as Rocky P and Gurkha.

The latest releases from the latter are the source of my question.The Royal Brigade is described as using the same wrapper as the Nepalese Warrior, however it looks feels and smells exactly like the wrapper from the extra fuerte. The wrapper on the Grand Age is a Cami but not the same as the Nepalese Warrior?

I have both of these resting right now and have yet to smoke either one, I am wondering who of you have and what is your take on them.

burgess_b
Sunday, March 4, 2007 6:16:00 AM
i have had like 30 X-fuertes in my possession, and i gotta say the wrapper colors differ greatly. i am a gurkha guy, but the quality control, which is to say wrapper consistency is not the greatest in the business.

not to worry, though, for here is the good news...smoke them...if you like them, buy more. who cares what wrapper they have on them. those you listed are WELL worth the smoke...at least until a smarter brother shows up--sarnone, havanaone...hell, anyone who's name ends in one!

havanaone
Sunday, March 4, 2007 6:23:00 AM
Heck I ain't so smart,just know a good smoke.Now send me some to try out....now that's smart.Hehehe
richard wharton
Sunday, March 4, 2007 6:35:00 AM
^^ MOOCH ^^

(if you get some send a couple my way)

Big John
Sunday, March 4, 2007 6:47:00 AM
Thanks for the advice, “If you like them buy more”, I may never have thought of that.

But my question remains and what I am really wondering is, are some manufacturers less than 100% honest in their descriptions? Is there a possibility of a mistake? This Royal Brigade looks, smells and feels like an Extra Fuerte Perfecto (even has the same band). Did Gurkha indeed ferment a Cami wrapper twice in order to get a true Maduro? Is it dyed? Why is it so dissimilar in appearance texture and smell to the Nepalese Warrior when it is supposedly the same leaf?

sw48362
Sunday, March 4, 2007 6:48:00 AM
I've received 5pks same brand/cigar with a very noticeable wrapper color variation. I think that's what's meant by complexity. lol!
havanaone
Sunday, March 4, 2007 7:00:00 AM
You say it is possibily the same leaf,could of it been fermented 2xs,dyded.There are some leaves that are more outstanding and of better quality looking,smelling depending upon where there grown.thus as well as the person whom is rolling the smokes and picking the leaves to wrap them with.The out side of a bundle of leaves is gonna be a slight dif than those in the middle of the bundle,hence comes the color variation.But if you receive smokes that are some what dried out and then compare them to the ones with humidity there gonna look different,smell slightly different.I have seen this with some Islanders from time to time.

As far as what there doing and using the same leaf,you'll just have to ask them.

jespear
Sunday, March 4, 2007 10:07:00 AM
I recently bought a 12 pack of the Royal Brigade.

The wrappers look EXACTLY like the wrappers on

all of my Centurian XX's.

I haven't tried one yet, so I can't comment on the taste.

jes

Big John
Sunday, March 4, 2007 11:19:00 AM
Wow!

The Centurian XX is probably my favorite Gurkha, all of them have a "Colorado" shade to the wrapper (medium brown with a slight red hue). The Royal Brigades I got are unevenly colored and nearly black, not even close in coloring to my Centurians. I can't believe that there is that great a disparity with in the same line.

havanaone
Sunday, March 4, 2007 11:56:00 AM
Longer aging process I believe.
bsevern
Sunday, March 4, 2007 12:49:00 PM
Big John I'm not surprised in the wrapper differences. If you've ever seen them sort cigars for boxes or lots at the factory, they do indeed vary in color, sometimes quite a bit. When their sorting the cigars for boxes, they sort them by matching shades as much as possible for the same box, but the next box could be at the opposite end of the spectrum.

Habanos do this when they sort as well, and take it one step further. In the same box they sort them from lightest to darkest from top to bottom.

Bottom line is if their all using the same wrapper, it doesn't really matter that much IMO, so long as the flavor profile hasn't changed.

Surprisingly I haven't noticed much of a variation on the Gurkha X-Fuertes, but they sure are damn good!

Big John
Tuesday, March 6, 2007 5:31:00 AM
O.K I smoked a Grand age perfecto and a Royal Brigade perfecto. The Grand age perfecto was very nice, great draw & even burn for a perfecto. Had a rich flavor and smooth finish, I really enjoyed it. The Royal Brigade was a bit damp and was very similar to the Extra Fuerte with a heavy Licorice taste on the finish, should improve with a couple months rest. I still believe that the Royal Brigade uses the same wrapper as the Extra Fuerte and not the Nepalese warrior. Maybe I'm just paranoid!