Sardious
Tuesday, March 6, 2007 12:24:00 PM
When I first tried the Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970 I thought they were the most amazing cigar so I big a lot and would I could not get on bid I bought from the local. Now after almost 2 years of rest I notice that they sleep very badly. Is it just be or do they lose a lot of flavor after resting for over a year. Now at 2 years I think they have at least 25% less of that base leathery flavor. I can tell some of the background flavors more but they are no pay off. Anyone else having this same experience with these? I am almost finished with my stash but now I plan to have no more than 1 box of any size in my Humidor at a time now to keep them more fresh. It is about the exact opposite of most cigars where normally aging = better
deadeyedick
Tuesday, March 6, 2007 3:21:00 PM
I find many, if not most, domestics lose some of the initial flavors after a few years. Depends on what you perfer in a flavor profile. If you like a stronger, richer, spicier cigar vs one with resolved, balanced flavors stick with 1-2 years age. The Ashton VSG is a good example to me. They are best within a year or two of release.

Now Habanos are definetly an exception.

DED

gunbuyer76
Tuesday, March 6, 2007 3:22:00 PM
I like these ALOT, with alot of time, I believe thier flavor gets better, but they lose that edge in thier body it becomes more of a medium-full smoke, than an ass whooper
cgbgjr
Tuesday, March 6, 2007 10:53:00 PM
sardious

The JDN flavor becomes more subtle after a couple of years--and the smoke is smoother and less jarring. I enjoy them that way.

The Machitos are your best bet if you still crave that major kick a couple of years after storage.