jreddoch
23 years ago
Thanks to xiagoxx. Strong sucker, but tasty. Kind of leathery. You guys that like the strong ones should try these. I like 'em better than the Corojos.
jd1
  • jd1
  • Herf-A-Holic
23 years ago
Really? Better than the Diploma or 11/18? Have you tried the Camacho Liberty? I wasn't impressed with the SLR even though I wanted to be. The Diploma-11/18-Liberty are simply the best Camacho has to offer IMHO of course.
jreddoch
23 years ago
The 11/18 is one of the best cigars I've ever smoked. I was comparing the SLR to the regular Corojo line. Haven't had a Liberty.
jd1
  • jd1
  • Herf-A-Holic
23 years ago
JReddoch I was worried there! ...I have only a few of the Liberty. I'll include one in our deal and you counter with something. Surprise me. Looking forward to the box split.
xaigoxx
23 years ago
My local cigar shop gave me a few to try. I thought they were decent smokes. Strong but smooth.
Robby
23 years ago
are the SLRs the ones they store standing up in the tall box? If so, I don't like them like the corojo's. The corojo's ROCK!!
jd1
  • jd1
  • Herf-A-Holic
23 years ago
Yes, Robby those are the SLRs. Don't mean to harp on the Camacho Diploma-11/18-Liberty so much, I'm just a "Camacho Ho" !
xibbumbero
23 years ago
The SLR is a little less strong than the Dip and 11/18 but a has little more complexity to it. The Liberty is very similar to the SLR's,IMO. BTW,they all be good.X
SteveS
23 years ago
Camacho makes a damn fine cigar, IMO ... I picked up two of these babies the other day and will be giving at least one of them a try over the weekend ... sure looks and smells good.
Mr.Mean
23 years ago
I must have gotten a wierd box of the diplomas. I found the SLR's stronger than the diplomas. Interested in trying the liberties, have not seen them (have not looked either).
SLR damn fine representation of what leather taste is in a cigar. Recommended with love from Mr.Mean.
jd1
  • jd1
  • Herf-A-Holic
23 years ago
Wow with all the talk of the SLR, I now must go back and give them a second shot. I felt they didn't compare to the Diploma-11/18 and damn sure nowhere near the Liberty.
Mean: email me jsd2az at hot mail dot com
eleltea
23 years ago
Traded off all my corojos. Very strong, not my flavor profile. Liked the Liberty a lot, thanks to X. Haven't tried the Diplomat or even seen a 11/18. Must check it out soon.
xibbumbero
23 years ago
LLT,The 11/18 is just a Perfecto shape of the Diploma. X
Users browsing this topic