Age, hmm.
Age before beauty?
But, I digress...
I notice a very real difference in cigars left in a humidor for several to six weeks. The time stabilizes and equalizes humidity and some flavors.
Between 6 weeks and a year, have never really noticed much difference. And, its hard to wait a year.
I did have some dog rockets that I tossed in the bottom of the cooler-dor, and found four years later (last month). They had improved considerably over what they were, aging helped, but they were still dog rockets and not worth the time or effort.
I have never run accross "properly" aged cigars that were over five years old. Seems that somewhere in the "aging" process they had been treated less than optimally, and that resulted in dried out, or molded, garbage.
Hey, if you've a relatively small humidor, rotate your stock, smoke the ones that are a month or two old, but don't worry about significant age. It will take a BIG humidor to store a five year supply in order to get some to five years old. And that will only work if you provide a lot better care than most people during that wait.
Smoke 'em if you got 'em.