TimmyJ
Thursday, April 19, 2007 8:53:00 AM
I am new to Cigars. I have been reading about humidors and the like. I have found a consensus that if you do not have the money to purchase a good humidor you are better off creating a tupperdor(tupperware container with a water pillow). I just started to use that until I get a decent humidor. Any advice on whether or not I should remove cigars from the wrappers while in this tupperdor
dunkaroos
Thursday, April 19, 2007 8:57:00 AM
a wise man once said..."Seek (Search) And ye shall find".
BiggDawg
Thursday, April 19, 2007 9:08:00 AM
Wrapper adds between 30% and 60% of the flavor.

I'd never remove the "wrapper" and get rather annoyed when they unwrap while smoking.

amac24
Thursday, April 19, 2007 9:32:00 AM
Just so you don't have to go digging through forums:

A tupperdor or coolerdor will work just fine as long as you have the accessories to maintain ~70% relative humidity and ~70º temperature (beads, gel, crystals, whatever).

I think the main question you have is whether or not to remove the cellophane. As you may know, a cigar is made of of the filler, the binder, and the wrapper. Oftentimes a cigar will also come in cellophane, which is what we believe you are referring to when you say "wrapper" (and why most guys are giving you smart-a$$ responses).

Cello breathes, so humidity in your humi will be able to get through. It just doesn't respond as quickly to humidity changes. Half of the guys will tell you to leave it on, the other half will tell you to take it off. Either works. If you want to see the cello start to yellow a bit (one sign of a well aged cigar) then leave it on. If you want your stogies to pick up a little bit of aroma from the sp. cedar in your humi, then take it off. It's all about personal preference.

richard wharton
Thursday, April 19, 2007 9:33:00 AM
Now Dawg be nice,I'm pretty sure,releative certain

,i think, sorta positive,but i could be wrong

in assumeing that lil Timmy is referring to the

CELLO wrapping on his smokes,and not the actual

tobacco wrapper ??

Maybe he will do a search regarding Cello on or Off.

TimmyJ
Thursday, April 19, 2007 9:40:00 AM
I appreciate the info...Guess I ll need to be and aficianado before I ask another question on here or I'll be banish for ingnorance. Again, thank you
dunkaroos
Thursday, April 19, 2007 9:52:00 AM
Rather than re-type information again and again, which many people here will still do if you ask them nicely, its easier to tell you where to find it. You can then decide for yourself which way is best after reading many many informational pieces found here. At least thats what I've found. Who knows, you may find out more things you didn't even think of before.
BiggDawg
Thursday, April 19, 2007 10:21:00 AM
Oh, well!

If it's CELLO ON/CELLO OFF he asks,

then, of course, it doesn't matter, but is a matter of personal taste.

There, I saved a lot of search.

As for me, I like my cigars like my women, naked and strong...

BiggDawg
Thursday, April 19, 2007 10:24:00 AM
Oh, and sorry Timmy, I couldn't resist.

If I hadn't, some one else would have.

Welcome to the club, BOTL! (Do a search there, too!)

Oh, I've been a very bad Dawg...

docrks
Thursday, April 19, 2007 10:56:00 AM
Let's see -

we have a Dawg....

we have Timmy....

is the answer to the puzzle ---- Lassie????

As far as the other question - the Coolerdor is a well proven and excellent way to store/age your cigars. There really is a LOT of info on this Forum regarding setting up and maintaining this very low maintainance operation. I have seen the Coolerdor approach outperform many, many of the lower to even mid-range priced humidors. Good Luck..

PtRD
Thursday, April 19, 2007 12:02:00 PM
Hey timmy

Check out the picture post. I posted a pic of my coolerdor. It is my first pic post so I am not sure if the format will be correct but I guess we'll find out.

I am pretty new to this but my suggestion about the cello issue is to keep it on until you have a stable storage situation. I took all my cello of before I had a good storage situation and they have taken a beating every time I try to move them.

mtstanger
Thursday, April 19, 2007 12:37:00 PM
Hey Timmy - welcome to the madness. If you hang around this site long enough, you will soon be purchasing a second tupperdor - mark my words. And if you're married, I know a good divorce lawyer...

As for your question about the cellophane, I agree with the other guys regarding it being personal preference. Mine is to leave the cello on when the smokes are in my tupperdor, but take it off when the cigars eventually make their way "on deck" to the glass-top humidor. I just think they're nicer looking nekked.

Good luck, and don't take the ribbing personally - there are some great people here (yes, even Dawg) who share a wealth of information, and they all love cigars, which makes them even better people.

teedubbya
Thursday, April 19, 2007 12:51:00 PM
Hey Timmy

Do you like gladiator movies? Ever seen a grown man nekkid?

dunkaroos
Thursday, April 19, 2007 1:11:00 PM
My dad says you dont hustle on defense
teedubbya
Thursday, April 19, 2007 1:13:00 PM
^ lol
docrks
Thursday, April 19, 2007 1:14:00 PM
Were you ever in a Turkish prison?
teedubbya
Thursday, April 19, 2007 1:19:00 PM
who knew such civilized gentlemen would have such a lowest common denominator lol
teedubbya
Thursday, April 19, 2007 1:20:00 PM
^and that I could be so gramatical....

6 years of gwb and now MY grammer is shot

GreenWolf70
Thursday, April 19, 2007 6:49:00 PM
^^^^^^ Now that thar is funny, I don't care who you are.

TW, buddy, come back into the light. You are being sucked into the liberal camp. Bush is not responsible for all the wrongs in your life, or in the world.

Tuckersdad
Thursday, April 19, 2007 6:55:00 PM
NOTE: Tim, maybe this will help . . . this is a post I wrote several years back. I post it here hoping it might be of help to some of our newer cigar lovers. Tuck

I've recently had several e-mail interchanges with a new cigar smoker, who was asking questions about storage. He was having problems with wide swings in humidity. I thought other new smokers might like to see the info I shared, so I've compiled most of it here. If it's a bit disjointed it's because it's from several e-mails.

In Arkansas the crazy weather and humidity can do weird things to the humidity in our humidors. Sometimes it makes it necessary to chase it almost daily if you are using (ancient) methods such as foam humidifiers.

For this reason, I bit the bullet and made the best decisions I've made since I lit my first stick.

1. I tossed all analog hygrometers straight into the dumpster, and replaced them with good digital models. I use nothing but digital hygrometers, which give both humidity and temperature. They sell for around $20. They're small, I use the cigar shaped type, about the size of a very small corona. They also work (and fit) well in small travel humis. I think I have about five of them.

2. I tossed every single one of my humidifiers. I use nothing that uses foam or anything similar. They are terribly unreliable for anything but breeding mold, and take way too much attention and maintenance. I bought a supply of the best beads on the market. There are complete instructions on how to use them and how much to buy on the sites that sell them. As far as containers . . . you can use an old nylon (pantyhose), a travel toothbrush holder poked full of holes, the same containers you have now (just toss the foam), or very nice commercial "tube type" containers (I use these) are available on the sites. Or you can just put them in a small bowl.

Boom! Problem solved. My maintenance went to every few months instead of every few days. And you can buy the beads in the exact humidity you prefer. I use the 65% beads. Bang! Humidor is held spot on - 65%. You can also get them in 70% beads if you prefer.

Now, here's what's important to know . . . . . the beads work in both directions.

- If your humi is too dry, the beads release moisture to bring it to 65%.

- If your humi is too wet, the beads will absorb moisture until the humidity is lowered to 65%.

NOTE: The beads can only do this if you use them right. You don't soak all of them, you wet about 60%-70% of them, leaving some dry to be able to absorb moisture if needed. The instructions on the site explain this.

Almost everyone goes to beads, sooner or later. I just skipped all the dumb chasing and getting mad, and went straight to beads very soon. Years later I'm still happy as a clam, and my sticks are very healthy.

I have four humis, but only use one, along with two large "tubadors".

Gorgeous wooden humidors are beautiful, but way too small, and way too expensive.

I went to Wallyworld, bought two large Steri-Lite tubs (in the housewares dept.), put beads and a digital hygrometer in each one, and my cigars have been nailed on 65% every since. I paid a grand total of $3.87 for each tub. Each one can store 15-22 full boxes at a perfect 65%. Cheaper and lots more storage than coolerdors. You will be amazed at how few beads you will need to keep it nailed on 65%.

Hang around HerfHut long and you'll need one or more.

You can still use your gorgeous wooden humidor for your "on deck" smokes, and for show, and the tubadors for your bulk storage and aging.

(I was then asked if the tubs had an air tight seal.)

No, the Steri-Lite tubs are not air tight. This worried me a bit when I was making a decision between tubs or coolers. The seal looked too loose on the tub, but the seal on coolers (ice chests) is too tight without doubt. So I figured $3.87 is a mighty cheap test.

I bought one to begin with, put beads and a digital hygrometer in it, and the empty tub was holding 65% within 2 days. I didn't clean or scrub it, nor do anything to counteract odors. I filled it with cigars and it immediately recovered to 65%. Since then I've tossed sheets and blocks of cedar in the tubs as I accumulated them from cigar boxes I bought (full). Don't worry about the cedar, you don't need it immediately.

I checked the tubs every few days for a week or two with no problems. The lid snaps on, and seems to be a perfect balance between a solid seal, and just loose enough of an "air leak" to let it breathe and release ammonia. I've never had to burp the tubs as you must with tupperware or coolers.

Now I don't even think about them. It's been two or three months since I last added distilled water. Plus they're very light and easy to handle, and they stack.

The only condition when I would recommend a cooler is in extreme heat, to keep the temp down. We have central AC and have never had a problem with this.

The tubs come in a couple of colors (blue & gray) and translucent. I bought gray tubs as I don't like light to hit my cigars (glass top humis are pretty but not the best, cigars do better in the dark). If I did it again I would buy one of each color, to easily distinguish between the tubs. I use one for very special sticks, and long term aging. I use the other for sticks waiting (short term aging) to be smoked.

I buy cigars by the box, and never throw away a box. When I empty a box I take out the sheets/blocks of cedar and toss 'em in the tubs. You'll soon have a bunch of cedar to line your tubs.

I reuse the empty boxes for bundle cigars. I have a large supply of empty cedar boxes, so when I receive bundle cigars I remove them from the bundle, put them in a cedar box, and into the tub for aging.

When I receive boxed cigars, I remove the outter celephane, open the box and check the sticks, and place the box in the tub. I don't remove the cigars when checking, just give 'em a quick look, unless I see a possible problem. I leave the individual cello on the cigars.

I have a gorgeous wooden humidor I keep by my recliner. I use this as a dry box (no humidification device). I keep a small supply (3-4 days) of cigars for smoking at my fingertips. I like to let 'em sit in the dry box for a day or two before smoking. This almost guarantees you won't have a wet cigar, or bad burn.

Hope this helps. It's an almost worry free/maintenance free way to store your cigars.

[NOTE: The above is my opinion only. Other vets may do things a bit differently, especially when it comes to tubs/coolers. But this has worked very well for me.]

Tuck