JohnnyBot3000
Saturday, April 21, 2007 12:09:00 AM
Has anyone else every had a problem with a glitch in the bid system? This is odd...see my note to customer service: LOT # 442483

------------------------

Dear Sir/Madam:

See transaction below...I dont understand it. Second time this has happened to me. I placed a bid at $3 for this item and auto bid max at $17. I KNOW I did this because I triplechecked. Then, when I submitted the bid, it shows that I placed a $17 bid and one other bidder also was changed to $17. The other 2 bidders on the list show bids of $7 and $5. Something is seriously wrong here!!! Shouldnt the system have bumped me to $5 or $7 max? This is crazy and now I realize this is the second lot that this happened to me. I know I didnt make a mistake. The other bidder at $17 was NOT at $17 when I made the bid either...It changed after I made my bid. Why didnt the other 2 bidders change? Please either remove my bid or make a correction...

Regards,

Johnny

442483 Torano Exodus 1959 Torpedo 1 of 1 at $17.00

auto-bid:$17.00 WINNING Apr 25, 11:29 PM

burgess_b
Saturday, April 21, 2007 12:30:00 AM
Bid: $ 3.00 (per unit)

Quantity: 1

Maximum Bid: $17.00

Comment:

are you saying your screen looked like this? well, either you drunk bid, made an error, or there is indeed a mistake. i think there is something a little off with the system, but this is BIG, if indeed it happened. i am sure, they will roll you back to $7 or so....nah, they will pump those others up to $17!!! HA HA HA

wwf_fan_57
Saturday, April 21, 2007 12:56:00 AM
This same thing happened to me tonight as well when i bid on lot #442044. Luckily I have been outbid since. One guy jumped and matched me and the other two where at 3 and like 5
JHC
  • JHC
  • Herf-A-Holic
Saturday, April 21, 2007 5:13:00 AM
Does look very odd that 2 of you would make the same mistake.
burgess_b
Saturday, April 21, 2007 7:27:00 AM
yup, i put in some bids, and YOU are right.

there are 2 bids. 1 guy has a $1 bid (not auto bid). the other guy has a $1 bid on auto bid. i bid $3 with a max of $7. we went to $7 immediately.

THEN, i bid not auto-bid on a lot. i won it. then i wanted to edit my cid to a higher max bid, i was not allowed to UNLESS i raised my initial bid at the same time.

THE SYSTEM HAS A BUG! probably caught if from little sledn!

burgess_b
Saturday, April 21, 2007 7:30:00 AM
but, not all of them screw up...i noticed it has not screwed up if i am the first bidder...but if there are other bidders, all bets are off (though some did not err, as far as i know)...i did have a couple that did. and a couple i am suspicious of, but maybe my max bid was the EXACT bid the other bidder quit at.
burgess_b
Saturday, April 21, 2007 7:59:00 AM
HA HA HA!

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=443238 

My bid was $7...the 2 bids on now are $3 and $9...i was outbid!!! WTF?

DcnCan
Saturday, April 21, 2007 9:09:00 AM
Same problem with this one and one other (of course the bids have changed since, but still whacky)

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=442415 

Name Bid Qty Bid Time Comment

1. DH of

Clinton, TN $19.00 1 of 1 April 20

04:53 PM

2. AC of

Gold Canyon, AZ $19.00 2 of 2 April 20

05:06 PM

3. AM of

Burke, VA $7.00 1 of 2 April 20

04:23 PM

plinytheelder
Saturday, April 21, 2007 12:26:00 PM
1. DH of

Clinton, TN $19.00 1 of 1 April 20

04:53 PM

2. AC of

Gold Canyon, AZ $19.00 2 of 2 April 20

05:06 PM

3. AM of

Burke, VA $7.00 1 of 2 April 20

04:23 PM

AM of VA lost 1 of his bids, because he was outbid.

He put the first bid in for his 2 lots, so he retained 1, and lost 1.

The next bid that beats his max bid, will remove him from his last lot.

Gremlins...

DcnCan
Saturday, April 21, 2007 12:48:00 PM
Hmm... Here is the way it looks today:

1. DH of Clinton, TN $19.00 1 of 1

April 20 04:53 PM

2. AC of Gold Canyon, AZ $19.00 2 of 2

April 20 05:06 PM

3. SP of Purcellville, VA $15.00 1 of 2

April 21 10:39 AM

Am has been supplanted by SP. SP's bid is seventeen and half hours later and $4 less than AC's...

I am still struggling to understand.

DcnCan
Saturday, April 21, 2007 1:21:00 PM
Okay, The "2 of 2" was the first bid placed. A second bid was placed. The tird bidder took one of the "2 0f 2" bids and the open 4th bid. That left one of the "2 of 2" bids at the original bid amount, moving the third bid for two lots above the original bid. If the second bid for one lot was the same as the original "2 of 2" amount then it would have remained the same.

Since the second bidder would have been next to be eliminated as others bid it became a bidding war between the second and the next anonymous bidder. Or if the next anon bidder wanted 3 lots then it became a bidding war between the second and the third bidder for their share of the lots, preserving the first bidders remaining (low) bid. However, now the second and third bidders bids are safe until the original "2 of 2" surpass their bids.

Open to correction.

burgess_b
Saturday, April 21, 2007 6:02:00 PM
DcnCAN'T--no one can correct you cause brother, you need to post BEFORE you start drinking, LOL!

well, i lost all my bids...went back and am sniping 1 now...i am intrigued by this cigar, so i wanna give it a shot. who knows, it may NOT suck....

tomorrow is a new day to bid. maybe the glitches will be out. maybe they fired the WRONG computer geek, ROFL!

JohnnyBot3000
Saturday, April 21, 2007 6:13:00 PM
OK...not glad to see others having this problem but at least I know I wasnt going crazy when it happened cause I know I wasnt drunk 😛
burgess_b
Saturday, April 21, 2007 6:33:00 PM
well, then i think you were not enjoying your bidding...drunk bidding is the BEST way to go...especially if you do not read your "YOU WON" emails...just wait for the package and see what you have won (and how much you lost $).
lou2row
Saturday, April 21, 2007 7:07:00 PM
Me and KK had high bids when the bid was down at$13.00 I also tried to go back and it said another bid came in and I wouldn't be allowed to change my bid lower. No other bid had come in in the four minutes I tried to edit bid. $31 is prob what KK did his high bid as too.

1. LT of

Wauseon, OH $34.00 1 of 1 April 20

09:56 PM

2. KK of

Land O Lakes, FL $31.00 2 of 2 April 20

01:18 PM

3. HB of

Cortaro, AZ $28.00 1 of 1 April 21

02:30 PM

4. MM of

Beavercreek, OH $25.00 1 of 1 April 21

08:02 AM

5. JF of

WARREN, MI $25.00 1 of 1 April 21

10:38 AM

6. GR of

Parker, CO $25.00 1 of 1 April 21

04:59 PM

7. MP of

Glen Burnie, MD $22.00 1 of 1 April 20

05:41 PM

8. PB of

Brockport, NY $22.00 1 of 1 April 20

05:53 PM

9. JF of

Lincroft, NJ $22.00 1 of 1 April 20

06:19 PM

10. RS of

Miller, IN $22.00 2 of 2 April 20

09:02 PM

lou2row
Saturday, April 21, 2007 7:07:00 PM
Sorry, that is for Lot #443702
mingkou
Saturday, April 21, 2007 11:55:00 PM
I didn't follow the whole thing here, but it sounds like the usual autobid issue (no glitch). Read the rules for how autobid works (it is kind of counterintuitive but common in auction scenarios) and then think about it. There have been several postings in this forum about this issue. Keep in mind autobid is generally not designed to give you the best deal; it is designed to ensure that you do not get outbid.
lou2row
Sunday, April 22, 2007 5:50:00 PM
Obviously it was a glitch, cause now the prices are where they should be.
TrishS@CigarBid
Monday, April 23, 2007 7:03:00 AM
We have our IT guys checking out your concerns. I had a bunch of emails about the problem this morning. We'll get it figured out and let all of you know what's going on.

Thanks for bringing it to our attention!

IUROX
Monday, April 23, 2007 7:07:00 AM
IT guys should NOT be allowed to smoke while IT 'ing!!