Steve,
You're right. Insult is too harsh a word. I've tried about half of the cigars in the sampler, including the Brocatus and when I compare it to the ones I did try and the reputation of the ones that I haven't, it REALLY comes off as being out of place in that lot.
To be honest, the description on CI's webpage doesn't do much to to further the belief that this is a really good cigar. Just a decent one at a great price.
And there's nothing wrong with that. For some people that's their ideal.