Nestor for less than $2
Don Tomas SE Connecticut for $1 or less (very mild but very good.)
Double Happiness (same as above)
El Mejor
Pirate's Gold Maduro
Tierra del Sol
Onyx for less than $3
Some Gurkhas for $3 or less (shop long and bid low)
Bid on a Shade Grown Festival - you can get them for about $2 a stick and you get Padilla Special edition, RP EURO '90, Gurkha Expedition, and IT Sp.Ed.
There are plenty of decent sticks out there for around $1 each, but you have to like mild & uncomplicated.
These are all cbid prices of course - don't get your hopes up about getting ANYTHING this cheap elsewhere.