BrillKill
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 1:24:00 PM
ok....so....I win a bundle on an auction from the other place (sounds like "Blame-us Smokes") and its one of their house brands that didn't have any reviews. So i get the bundle, light one up and nearly threw up on the spot. I tried another just to make sure it wasn't a fluke.....still bad. I'm not an expert by any stretch but I can tell when a leaf has gone past a period of optimal fermentation into the borderline of decaying. It tasted like rolled compost dipped in green mud from a polluted river. Really repulsive.

Being a reasonable guy I understand its not an exact science and things can go wrong but i found it very hard to beleive someone tried one of these and gave the thumbs up to sell them.

Anyhow, I got my RMA and then call for my shipping label. At that point I'm told that I would have to pay for the shipping as the product was gotten from their auction and not the main site (the auction is a tab on their main sites menu...lol) and further, seeing it was a matter of me just not liking it, that further justified their making me pay to ship it back. I asked if they were aware that Cbid actually trusts it customers enough to send out the return shipping label on the same day as their replacement/refund no questions asked? There was a long silence and then an uncomfortable chuckle saying "well, I'll pass that info along to management".

To make a long story short I wrote telling them I would no longer use their site. The same woman wrote back that they would mail me a label and "there must've been a misunderstanding yada yada yada...". I had heard similar stories from others but i just dismissed it as whiners but evidently they like nickel-and-diming people. I closed the letter stating "I hope the 3-4 bucks you saved is more profitable than another 20+ years of me being a loyal customer".

Anyway, moral of the story is: They suck, I stick with Cbid from here on out.

-Brill

nine999
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 1:46:00 PM
lol....

sorry 'bout that bro. no matter.... i think they cheat, anyways...

good to be here, eh?

nine

burgess_b
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 4:44:00 PM
you can make a LOT of money nickle-and-diming people. I'm just saying.

that place actually confuses me. i never won an auction. i bought a crazy mixed 8er or 10er for like $20 (maybe $30), but it had some great sticks--all robusto.

stay away from house brands, though...hell, CI is lucky that the Legends series is soo good...but they are a more expensive house brand, i would say--aiming at $5 each...and when you play the auction, $2 each. a perfect plan!

Slimboli
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 4:49:00 PM
Never had a problem with that site ... and love the auctions they offer.

I guess the more you participate in anything ... the more chances ther will be for 'incidences'.

Same everywhere ...

BrillKill
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 6:03:00 PM
burgess, actually they have one particular house brand that is exceptional but the rest seem to be a crap shoot.

yes, I'm sure a lot of cash can be made nickel-and-diming folks but nowhere near the amount if you have policies in place that keep one loyal and continually recommending your business to others. I recommend Cbid every chance i get....the other place, no longer.

colinmcfall
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 6:21:00 PM
Some people just don’t understand the importance of good customer service. I have made a few purchases from “the other site.” I have tried two house brands. One was not worth ordering again, at any price. The other was actually good. However, the good house brand is terribly overpriced, retail anyway. Nevertheless, you can get it at auction for a buck a stick. That said, it still does not beat “Fire” as my favorite buck a stick cigar.
R_Wu
Tuesday, May 22, 2007 6:23:00 PM
if you think the domestic competition sucks, the international ones are even worse!

there's this site i used to order from, they have a price match policy. so one time i email them for 2 boxes of siglo 2s and a box of diplomaticos no.2 with links to competitor's on sale prices. but since price match has to be done manually, by the time they reply, one of their competitor's special offers has already expired.

so they send me an email stating that per their "policy" they cannot honor expired prices, i of course send them a reply to protest since imo it's not my fault that it took them two days to process price matching.

their second reply is just great- not only they wouldn't price match the diplomaticos, they will no longer price match the siglo 2s either since it has just expired. in my reply i simply ask them to kindly remove me from their mailing list and i cc their manager.

a few days later, their manager replied, and guess what, he's regrets the "misunderstandings" and offer me "a couple of their private label on the house" for my next order, without providing any remedies for this order!

i guess i should consider this a rare honor especially since i've only been their customer for several years with no prior complains whatsoever, and i only order from them twice a month each time only two or three boxes!

BrillKill
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 6:13:00 AM
I'm guessing that some of these places feel that if they get too *generous* with their return/exchange policy that the system will somehow be "abused". This is silly as they have a detailed record of all customer transactions and it would be a simple matter of putting the brakes on someone who is trying to scam the system. They don't grasp the fact that if you treat people like they matter and not like a thief they become loyal.

example: I buy a lot of PC equipment as I'm a gamer. Theres only one place I buy my stuff at and thats NewEgg.com. While they aren't the absolute cheapest, their customer service is beyond reproach. I know if I buy something there and it isn't what I expected or its broken they'll issue an RMA on the spot with all shipping etc paid for. Because of their customer service they are the largest and best rated private PC supply company on the net. To me thats a far more profitable way of doing business rather than nickel-and-diming your customers.

Torpedo1
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 6:32:00 AM
You are in better company here anyway.
burgess_b
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 6:37:00 AM
i have been working in japan for a while...and the english language school philosophy is nickle-and-dime...which is why i had to leave it...now, i am all about customer satisfaction...and i make a killing working for myself!
teedubbya
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 6:52:00 AM
Customer Service is a thing of the past. I hope it returns.

I used to work at target. Our CS department took everything back, obviously worn out shoes, merchandise with KMART tags etc. It was wrong and cost too much money.

Now Target CS and return policies are terrible. The pendulum swings.

CS here has always treated me well. I had some issues when I first came in here where I was less than patient, and they were truly trying to help me. I've since mellowed......

They do a nice job in here while still maintaining a business.... its a tough balance sometimes.

IUROX
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 7:09:00 AM
There is another Cigar site????????
DrMaddVibe
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 7:49:00 AM
I've NEVER had a bad experience...with anything!

Life's a bowl of cherries.

You must be doing something wrong.

I've NEVER had those kind of issues.

Good luck!

golden13
Wednesday, May 23, 2007 9:06:00 AM
I live near the competitor you speak of. I have never used their auction site, but have visited their store. While they do have some deals here and there and have some decent prices on fivers, their CS is terrible. No one there really knows much about cigars. There are usually two females behind the counter (at least ones not bad looking), but neither knows anything. They are no help at all. Now, I am fortunate to live/work near CI also. Most of my business goes to CI/C-Bid. Much more knowledgable and the CS is great.
BrillKill
Monday, June 4, 2007 7:49:00 PM
The saga continues. I paid 20 for the cigars (at auction) and 5 for shipping. I get a friendly note telling me I will get my $18 credited to my account. I wrote back wondering why there was a two dollar difference. I get the following:

------

Thank you for your email.

Upon the inspection of the cigars by our Returns Department they found

do(sic) defect with them. As this was the case your credit was prorated for

the amount of cigars you returned. This is in accordance with our return

policy for auction orders.

We hope this information helps and please let us know when we can be of

further assistance.

-----------------

After ALL that crap over return shipping (see original post) this embarrassment to online tobacco sales further nickel-and-dimed me for 2 CIGARS! These weren't 'effing high-end Davidoffs or Auroras, they were cheap, house brands...LOL! Keep in mind that I already paid for the original shipping and the RETURN shipping.

By no means are the amounts of cash any issue to me. The total they clipped is less than I spend on coffee in a day, it's the principle of the whole thing. They advertise a certain level of customer service for the retail section yet have an entirely different set of rules for the auction site. If it were set up like CBid/CI i could buy into that but the auction and retail site are one and the same.

Anyhow, I'd be insulted if it weren't so funny. I really would be embarrassed if I were them.

donutboy2000
Monday, June 4, 2007 8:03:00 PM
R_Wu

Did I understand that you've been buying 4 - 6 boxes a month for several years? Dude, you dealing?

aceswired
Monday, June 4, 2007 9:03:00 PM
CBid service rocks. I've only ever had one issue and they took care of things straight away. I start to forget why I ever bought from anywhere else.
engletl
Tuesday, June 5, 2007 4:04:00 AM
Never used CS at that other site. Have won quite a few auctions over there. I like their wholesale lots.

Other than the Legends series here I have never had a decent house brand. And don't even make an attempt to try any more house brands.

Todd

R_Wu
Tuesday, June 5, 2007 8:04:00 AM
donutboy2000,

no no i'm not a dealer, this is a hobby not a business.

i buy on average 10 boxes a month (from different retailers) and i would say less than 20% of them are actually for personal consumption, and within those more than half are set aside for long term aging. i don't smoke cigars everyday as i'm primary a pipe smoker.

ARN
  • ARN
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, June 5, 2007 8:19:00 AM
R_wu I wanna come over and play!!!!LOL!