For the most part, I select a neutral accompaniment; like a gin martini or gin & soda. Since I try many different cigars, I like to taste the cigar without any other influences.
That is not to say, however, that I pair some of my favorites with various accompaniments.....I like a nice single malt scotch with a strong full bodied cigar. For a more medium bodied cigar, I like dark rum.....like Mt. Gay. Cognac is nice too. Come to think of it.....bourbon works well.
I guess I like darker liquors with cigars.