I wrote this for our December '06 Newsletter:
Every cigar novice runs into the same dilemma after breaking in their first humidor: cello on or off? Truth be told, it is entirely up to you and makes little to no difference...with a few exceptions. Cellophane is a porous product made of wood. Therefore, it does breathe and will allow the transfer of both air and moisture. That said, your cigars will not lose freshness if you store them within the cello. The same can be said for sealed boxes. Your cigars will be just fine.
Some things to consider...
1.) Over time, different cigars will marry when aged together, slightly acquiring the variety of attributes from other cigars. Additionally, the cigars will pick up a cedary flavor or aroma when stored in a cedar-lined humidor. The cello will slow down this process.
2.) Cellophane protects the outer leaf of the cigar. If you’re like most enthusiasts and take a few sticks out on the town, the cellophane will come in handy. Especially if you give cigars to others, or trade with fellow enthusiasts.
Yes, the cigars look much prettier when they sleep naked inside that glass-top humidor. But, there is no clear-cut, pre-defined answer to this undying question. It is merely a matter of preference.