L-o-o-ong day of work and my cigar and I are just getting back to this thread, but let me see if I understand "the rules of debate," as made up on the fly by victor808.
There's no speculation allowed about whether or not Kerry would have made a better President, because that's relegating the discussion to "make believe" (which, if you're referring to my obviously quite serious post #32, uh, touche, I guess).
So what you seem to be saying is that it's not valid or appropriate for me to say, "You know what? Bush may not be perfect, but considering the person who otherwise could have been dealing with all this, I'm not sorry he was elected."
Let's go to a less politically charged analogy and see if this holds up. Say I could have married either of two women. Woman A is my current wife. She certainly has her flaws, BUT... from MY perspective she's a loving partner, a good mother, and I'm generally satisfied with our marriage.
Now in my most trying moments with Woman A, I would consider it valid for me to think back on the alternative, Woman B, and say, "Well, at least I didn't marry the drug-addicted, syphilitic whore who's prone to violence and has multiple felony convictions."
By your standards, that would be unfair because I have no facts to support such a statement. It's wild speculation (because of the "variance!") -- there's simply no way of knowing if Woman B might somehow have been an even better wife.
I think most people would agree, though, that I'm not being unreasonable to express gratitude that I am, in fact, married to Woman A.
Now obviously my analogy here (deliberately) strays into the arena of "make believe." But I think it illustrates your position's shortcomings.
So let me restate my position on Bush as compared to Kerry (in a way so simple that even people with multiple advanced degrees can understand):
"Based on what I know about Bush, and what I know about Kerry, I'm glad Bush is in office."
If this statement is still out of bounds for y'all and you continue insisting on rhetorical absolutism, how are you going to engage in debate about which of the candidates running in 2008 will make a better President? I mean, heck: that's "wild speculation," unsupported by facts!
(Incidentally, when it's my turn to make up the rules about how we all debate, I tap no overwrought name calling -- Bush as the idiotic religious fanatic, for example -- as I find this "detrimental" to constructive dialog.)
Now... It's getting late. Who wants another beer?
ScottHar