ScottHar
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 11:01:00 PM
L-o-o-ong day of work and my cigar and I are just getting back to this thread, but let me see if I understand "the rules of debate," as made up on the fly by victor808.

There's no speculation allowed about whether or not Kerry would have made a better President, because that's relegating the discussion to "make believe" (which, if you're referring to my obviously quite serious post #32, uh, touche, I guess).

So what you seem to be saying is that it's not valid or appropriate for me to say, "You know what? Bush may not be perfect, but considering the person who otherwise could have been dealing with all this, I'm not sorry he was elected."

Let's go to a less politically charged analogy and see if this holds up. Say I could have married either of two women. Woman A is my current wife. She certainly has her flaws, BUT... from MY perspective she's a loving partner, a good mother, and I'm generally satisfied with our marriage.

Now in my most trying moments with Woman A, I would consider it valid for me to think back on the alternative, Woman B, and say, "Well, at least I didn't marry the drug-addicted, syphilitic whore who's prone to violence and has multiple felony convictions."

By your standards, that would be unfair because I have no facts to support such a statement. It's wild speculation (because of the "variance!") -- there's simply no way of knowing if Woman B might somehow have been an even better wife.

I think most people would agree, though, that I'm not being unreasonable to express gratitude that I am, in fact, married to Woman A.

Now obviously my analogy here (deliberately) strays into the arena of "make believe." But I think it illustrates your position's shortcomings.

So let me restate my position on Bush as compared to Kerry (in a way so simple that even people with multiple advanced degrees can understand):

"Based on what I know about Bush, and what I know about Kerry, I'm glad Bush is in office."

If this statement is still out of bounds for y'all and you continue insisting on rhetorical absolutism, how are you going to engage in debate about which of the candidates running in 2008 will make a better President? I mean, heck: that's "wild speculation," unsupported by facts!

(Incidentally, when it's my turn to make up the rules about how we all debate, I tap no overwrought name calling -- Bush as the idiotic religious fanatic, for example -- as I find this "detrimental" to constructive dialog.)

Now... It's getting late. Who wants another beer?

ScottHar

bloody spaniard
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 4:49:00 AM
Ah ha, ah ha, oh yes, ah ha, please continues, you don't say, oh my, good point.

Great days in da mornin & sakes alives!

It's oblivious to me thru reductives thinkin, dat we has oursefs another menses card holder here!

Yes we does.

DrafterX
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 4:56:00 AM
Why I feel Bush is the better president as far as I'm concerned.

John Kerry`s two-decade long U.S. Senate record of opposing Second Amendment rights makes him the most anti-gun presidential nominee in history! Here’s the proof.

FACT: Kerry co-sponsors a bill that would ban all semi-automatic shotguns and detachable-magazine semi-automatic rifles, a gigantic step toward bringing Australian-style gun control to the U.S.1

FACT: Kerry says, "I think you ought to tax all ammunition, personally, I think you ought to tax guns."2

FACT: Kerry has voted nine times in favor of banning semi-auto firearms.3

FACT: Kerry has voted for a Ted Kennedy amendment to ban most center-fire rifle ammunition, including the most common rounds used by hunters and target shooters.4

FACT: Kerry has voted to close off hundreds of thousands of acres of the California Mojave Desert to hunting.5

FACT:Kerry has voted to hold the highly regulated American firearms industry legally responsible for the illegal acts of violent criminals.6

FACT: Kerry was one of only 18 Senators to oppose the Firearms Owners` Protection Act, which ended alarming abuses being committed under the 1968 Gun Control Act.7

FACT:Kerry was one of only 29 Senators to vote to prohibit gun manufacturers from discharging debts created by the reckless lawsuits filed by municipalities.8

FACT:Kerry has voted to allow BATF to conduct unlimited warrantless inspections of FFL holders.9

FACT: Kerry has voted to criminalize legal sales between private individuals at gun shows.10

FACT: Kerry has voted to impose penalties of a year in prison and a $10,000 fine on an adult if a juvenile steals a firearm from him, and then merely displays it in a public place.11

FACT: Kerry has voted to force many small firearms dealers out of business, which would have impacted both the availability and price of guns, particularly in rural areas.12

FACT: Kerry has voted 11 times to force law-abiding citizens to wait to exercise their Second Amendment rights. He voted to keep the federal waiting period after the National Instant Check System was in place.13

FACT: Kerry voted twice to eliminate the Civilian Marksmanship Program.14

FACT: Kerry wants to silence gun owners` voices. When NRA sought the same exemption from campaign finance rules that news organizations have, Kerry called that effort "hijacking America`s airwaves."15

FACT: Kerry commended the Million Mom March for their march on Washington that included calls for gun owner licensing, gun registration and other restrictions on law-abiding gun owners.16

Caspar Milquetoast
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 4:56:00 AM
Couldn't has said it any moah better than Mr. Spanish!!

You sir, must be a fellow man of leters 'n such.

How do one go about gettin' one of them there menses cards anyhow???

I be intrested.

HockeyDad
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 5:13:00 AM
I'm just glad I'm flying on Boeing products today.
victor808
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 6:35:00 AM
Scott, do you see the difference in the two arguments?

In your wife example, you are simply expressing gratitude that you have wife A (rather than the clearly superior syphilitic wife B... but whatever floats your boat). To do this one is simply defending he choices you originally made (A can't cook crack properly, B sucks a d$ck like she used to do it for money).

The argument I have problems with is specific current situations. An example would be if you said "well, wife A may not be doing the best job punishing the children (she beats them with a baseball bat), but I'm sure glad I didn't marry wife B because she would shiv them with a homemade knife".

That is a completely fictional statement, since you have no idea how even having the children would affect wife B, causing any number of changes in her decision-making capabilities prior to this particular choice.

The most aggregious of these is when people say "boy I'm glad we didn't have Gore (or other candidate) as president when the terrorists attacked". Since we never had an attack like this, there is absolutely no reference point for how any of them would act, and it is simply fantasy land.

And as a final point. I obviously don't make the rules. But when a person is using a bs argument, people would be remiss in not pointing it out. Hell, your post wasn't even bad, it just reminded me of many of the posts I've been seeing recently...

AVB
  • AVB
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 6:38:00 AM
83--> So you base your decision on one issue? What is the President supposed to do the rest of the time read "The Pet Goat" ?
DrafterX
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 6:50:00 AM
Not just one issue. I stopped & looked around at my friends, family and myself. Everyone was and still is doing very well financially. I didn't see the coming recesion or whatever the dems were crying about. In Oklahoma we had recoed enrollments at all of our top universities. I'm making more money than I ever had and recentley bought a new home. I didn't see any reason to rock the boat with any drastic changes.
ScottHar
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 6:56:00 AM
victor808-- Thanks for clarifying; I do see your point about instances when we don our magic hindsight glasses and get down into the nitty-gritty specifics.

I also appreciate the civil tone -- something that's frequently missing during some of these threads.

Now if only I hadn't REALLY married Wife B... (although, the sex? Dynamite!)

ScottHar

teedubbya
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 6:58:00 AM
^ I had that under Clinton but never voted for him nor never would.

All hail Corn Wallace...

victor808
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 7:08:00 AM
You know, you really haven't lived until you've married a crack addicted, syphilitic ex-street hooker.

FACT: They have all the good drug connections

FACT: You don't have to worry about them OD'ing

FACT: They know how to take a beating

FACT: Their hollowed out sinus really lets them keep breathing while "servicing"

FACT: When it comes to sex, do you really want an amateur? (compare pro basketball players to the previous olympics amateurs)

And yes, I am making fun of Drafter X's little rant.

DrafterX
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 7:10:00 AM
Rant? Just a copy & paste...
DrafterX
Wednesday, May 9, 2007 7:15:00 AM
I suppose I could just throw an opinion based on what I heard on the radio out there...