teedubbya
Wednesday, May 16, 2007 12:36:00 PM
remember "we don't want to be the worlds police force"?
teedubbya
Wednesday, May 16, 2007 12:36:00 PM
but the war is over
cbc812
Wednesday, May 16, 2007 12:43:00 PM
tailgater - I am with you completely.

But we have a problem. The fact of the matter was that the American public was never on board for a long, costly slog. We were told it would be a cakewalk, and a necessary one, given the "mushroom cloud" rhetoric. That's why no new plan has been put forward by the administration - to finally do it right, they would first have to admit to the country that they either lied or were too horrendously stupid to listen to those who warned of the need for many hundreds of thousands more troops and a ten year time horizon before we went in. In fact, those voices of reason were actively sandbagged. Remember General Shinseki?

These guys will not admit a mistake - and to stabilize Iraq, they would have to. I think most Americans would support a massive overhaul of strategy if a goal was clearly spelled out and set. But all we get is just a "surge" of troops here and a few billion dollars more there. This sounds crazy, but maybe the solution is to impeach Bush and Cheney and replace them with somebody, ANYBODY, willing to speak the truth to the American people about the importance of the mission and the costs of getting it right.

Because right now, the fearmongering, impugning of peoples' patriotism, and senseless waste of blood and treasure is making withdrawal an inevitability. Americans simply will not put up with another 17 months of a failed strategy burining tax money and shattering the lives of our troops and their families.

tailgater
Wednesday, May 16, 2007 1:16:00 PM
cbc,

I think you've summed it all up quite well.

We approached the subject from opposite sides, but we're not that far apart on the core issue.

I happen to think that the administration would be more likely to either admit fault, or at least be honest regarding the sacrifice required if it were not for the Harry Reids of the world declaring defeat and convincing the American public that we can't win. It's a partisan display of machoism (or is it masochism?) where neither side will want to show a kink in their armor.

It's dispicable because lives are being lost.

victor808
Wednesday, May 16, 2007 1:20:00 PM
^40

Tw's right. We won the war. We went in because Saddam had WMDs and we were afraid they would somehow make it to the US (irrelevant whether he actually had them or whether they would make it here or not). We waged a war against Saddam and his gov't, it WAS a cakewalk and we won.

We should have taken the troops out and brought them home a couple years ago.