nine999
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 6:49:00 AM
jpotts:

nah bro- just copying barlett's #18 post. not that rickamaven needs support, just letting him know he is not alone.

you want an attack? i'll use my "left" arm on YOU!

nine

jpotts
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 6:56:00 AM
I've seen something on it, but the source of the allegation has been archived off most sites. I can't tell whether it was plagerism or inaccuracy.

I'm sure that there may be one or two instances of that in his documentary...the thing spans something like 10 episodes. I'm frankly willing to cut the guy a little slack.

jpotts
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 6:57:00 AM
nine999:

Don't start goin' all Chuck Norris on me! 🙂

teedubbya
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 7:08:00 AM
potts.... as for kearns-goodwin and others who do indepth research I often wonder how they dont "steal" others ideas....

I mean can you attribute everythought of your own to a source (well you can....rove....but I can't)

jpotts
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 7:26:00 AM
Kerns-Goodwin also got nailed on her book about Lincoln (if I remember correctly).

I'll tell you this, when you write a book it's really, really hard to make sure every source is quoted accuraterly on top of editing (or more like fighting with the editor), ensuring accuracy, and so on. Even people who are extremely anal about details will make a mistake now and again. And it's one of those things that, until it's pointed out, will be overlooked.

You know, I can forgive someone for "plagerizing" a paragraph out of an entire book, especially considering if you have 600 pages, and you forget to add intro, context, and quotes to a paragraph, it's REAL easy to forget that you cited it from another source, especially when you wrote that chapter 3 or 4 months prior. And usually the people nit-picking this kind of stuff haven't gone through the process of publishing, at least in book form.

However, there are instances of plagerism that are just obscene. I saw an article on some young author (18-year old harvard student) that landed a 2-book deal to write chick-lit, and ended up scamming and rewriting entire sections from her favorite author's books (I think the author wo was ripped-off was the same person that wrote "The Princess Diaries"). The obscene part wasn't really the plagerism, but the fact that this young author scored a half-million dollar advance for both books - neither of which had been written yet - whereas the original author only got around $30,000.00 advance for her most famous book.

Now THAT'S a scam.

mingkou
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 7:33:00 AM
"The problem we've been having lately is that a lot of people have been looking at hospitals and doctors as the lotto jackpot, by either getting free service and not paying, or sueing hoping for a payoff."

Jpotts, what evidence is there of this? Medical malpractice lawsuits eat up about 0.5-1.0%% of all health care costs and have not grown any faster than health care costs as a whole.

http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/349/8/768 ). The data on people crossing the border for healthcare is that in border areas, about 0.9% of all of hospital visits by Canadiens are done in the the U.S. Canadian surveys indicate that 0.05-0.09% of Candians went to the U.S. for healthcare on purpose. By the way, the number of americans who head to Canada is about 75x that.

This free market crap was great for Adam Smith when property was much more widely dispersed and commodities were mostly objects that had some sort of intrinsic value according to their purpose. It assumes people will not buy things that are not neccessary and was dreamed up before advertising essentially became the art of deception to pander to hopes.

Here's a recent example of how medicine is sold. Watch direct to consumer advertising for antidepressants and all you see are clouds, fields, and imagery meant to make it look like the people are moving on to a happier place. But do they have any disclaimers about the effectiveness? (http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/349/8/768)

How many advertisements and advertisers tell parents this?: "In general, nine depressed youth must be treated with an antidepressant to obtain one clinical response above that achieved with placebo." Unless the parents read all of the current psych journals, or try to make a decision based on thousands of pubmed requests and can interpret statistical coefficients, they are going to get conned by the ads. Thank God heart medication isn't like this...oh wait, nevermind.

teedubbya
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 7:44:00 AM
yea - I don't think that lincoln book thing was a huge issue. More embarrasing than anything.

But I thought Burns deal was bigger.

teedubbya
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 7:48:00 AM
By the way.... My dad says Newts books are pretty good
pmn1
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 7:49:00 AM
Don't Like the message - Can't argue the position? - Attack the messenger. The Carl Rove approach to being a Republican.
mcormier
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 5:33:00 PM
why is it that most if not all (a necessary caveat) liberals must resort to an ad hominem. ab absurdum argument to justify their brand of facism.

mcormier

RICKAMAVEN
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 6:45:00 PM

70. Author: mcormier

"ad hominem. ab absurdum"

i think your over indulgence in jelly beans during the reagan era, has overloaded the sugar in your brain.

sort of a reverse LSD trip

jackconrad
Wednesday, May 30, 2007 8:16:00 PM
DSL trip
jpotts
Thursday, May 31, 2007 7:30:00 AM
mingkou:

"Jpotts, what evidence is there of this? Medical malpractice lawsuits eat up about 0.5-1.0%% of all health care costs and have not grown any faster than health care costs as a whole."

First, 0.5% is just plain bogus. Obviously those numbers are drawn from just the payouts alone, and don't even touch how much is spent in the prevention of malpractice suit. It doesn't cover legal fees by the insurance carriers, legal fees paid by the doctor, legal fees paid by the hospital, premiums on malpractice insurance for both doctor, hospital, and individual office. I'm also sure it doesn't cover premium increases everytime an insurance carrier gets sued. And I'm not even going to start into how many tests that are done nationwide, that are generally not required for an obvious disgnosis, in order to prevent a malpractice suit.

I remember, explicitly, one lawsuit in the 1970s that a hospital in Michigan lost, and they were ordered to pay $2,000,000.00. In the 1970s, that was a lot of money. It concerned a pregnant polish woman who didn't speak a lick of English. Even when they found a translator for her, she refused to listen to the requests of the nurses and doctors, which was to - specifically - stay in bed. Instread, she got up, and delivered her baby into a toilet while the nurse was out of the room. The baby ended up with brain damage, and the hospital ended up getting sued.

Please, don't even attempt to lecture me about the costs of malpractice suits, and their effect on the medical industry. We've got doctors in our family with their own private practices, and I regularly hear how much the cost of insurance alone factors into what you pay to see a doctor.

http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/349/8/768 ). The data on people crossing the border for healthcare is that in border areas, about 0.9% of all of hospital visits by Canadiens are done in the the U.S. Canadian surveys indicate that 0.05-0.09% of Candians went to the U.S. for healthcare on purpose. By the way, the number of americans who head to Canada is about 75x that."

Funny how you didn't reference the CORRECTION to that article you cited:

http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/349/25/2461 

And as far as those numbers are concerned - specifically the number of Canadians coming here to the US for healthcare - I believe them to be a load of bullcrap as well. No on, and I do mean NO ONE, is going over to Canada for major medical procedures, mainly because the waiting lists are so long for things that are often routine here in the United States. You generally have to wait about 6 weeks for a CAT scan - here in the US, it's only 1 week, and that's only because an earlier time usually conflicts with your schedule.

The numbers for most of these bogus studies only reflect what people choose to answer.

The statement that "1/6th of the people have no coverage" is also misleading. People move in and out of healthcare insurance all of the time, and some CHOOSE not to have healthcare insurance coverage. So, a majority of that astounding number you cite (which I also think is just plain bogus) is transient.

Then again, healthcare is free in this country if you cannot pay for it. In fact, we've got so many people abusing this principle, that many hospitals are closing down their emergency rooms because people are coming in to get treated, and not paying - which is the reason why I mentioned that people view the healthcare system in this country as their own private piggy bank.

By the way, a good number of these hospitals I've mentioned are out in California, where illegals are sucking the state's healthcare funding virtually dry, and generally not paying into the system.

Again, there are LOTS of Canadians coming here for healthcare. They do it because if they wait for their healthcare system to get around to healing they, they'll most likely be dead. And, by the way, where do you think a lot of Canadians go when their doctors go on strike? Trust me, it ain't Great Britian.

By the way, a significant portion of my wife's family lives in Canada. Don't assume I'm speaking from ignorance here. One of her father's cousins had to come to the US for bypass surgery.

Now, as far as administration costs are concerned, did the US numbers include private sector dollars or was this government comparisons? Frankly, I'm not paying a fee to find out. But what I will tell you is that the amount that they pay for administration does not reflect well when you consider that the healthcare they receive - teartment and timeliness - is considered below par by the expectations of US citizens.

"This free market crap was great for Adam Smith when property was much more widely dispersed and commodities were mostly objects that had some sort of intrinsic value according to their purpose. It assumes people will not buy things that are not neccessary and was dreamed up before advertising essentially became the art of deception to pander to hopes."

Yeah, and we've seen just how well socialism has held up over the years. By the way, there's a good reason why Great Britian, Canada, and Germany are all looking towards healthcare privitization.

"Here's a recent example of how medicine is sold. Watch direct to consumer advertising for antidepressants and all you see are clouds, fields, and imagery meant to make it look like the people are moving on to a happier place. But do they have any disclaimers about the effectiveness? (http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/349/8/768)

How many advertisements and advertisers tell parents this?: 'In general, nine depressed youth must be treated with an antidepressant to obtain one clinical response above that achieved with placebo.' Unless the parents read all of the current psych journals, or try to make a decision based on thousands of pubmed requests and can interpret statistical coefficients, they are going to get conned by the ads. Thank God heart medication isn't like this...oh wait, nevermind."

Hey, you want an argument about pharma companies advertising on nationwide TV? You're not going to get it from me. Personally, I think it's a waste of time and money. But the flip-side of the coin is that it makes the general public aware of new and emerging medications.

However, if you go to a doctor and he's not telling you the same potential side effects and the probabilities that the medication will work, you'de better find another doctor, because that's part of his job.

If you choose to remain ignorant about your treatment options, then you deserve the crappy treatment you get. It costs you virtually nothing to ask your doctor these questions, and if he doesn't respond to you in a way you like, there's no law saying you have to stay with that doctor. I ought to know: I've booted two of mine because of that kind of crap.

jpotts
Thursday, May 31, 2007 7:33:00 AM
"Don't Like the message - Can't argue the position? - Attack the messenger."

Yeah, and we all know that Bill Clinton and his cronies never resorted to that, right?

Anyone remember someone saying something about running through a trailer park waving a $100.00 bill?

How short some people's memories are.

teedubbya
Thursday, May 31, 2007 7:43:00 AM
Apology Accepted
jpotts
Thursday, May 31, 2007 7:50:00 AM
I forgive you.
HockeyDad
Thursday, May 31, 2007 7:51:00 AM
If Bill Clinton did it then it should be perfectly acceptable for anyone else to do it and even should be written into the US Constitution to reflect this God-given right.

The GOP has really low standards! This is good for America?!

teedubbya
Thursday, May 31, 2007 7:56:00 AM
If its wrong, but Bill did it too, why should we talk about our man?

Apology Accepted.