Copper looks great when it's shiny and new, and when it's weathered and splotchy green.
It's the in-between period that I hate.
Either way, if you like it shiny, don't worry about "shortening" the life of the copper by removing the oxidized layer. Unless you live to be 500 you'll never remove enough layers to make it a concern.
I know that Barkeepers Friend works great on the copper bottoms on cooking pans. It's abrasive and may leave swirl marks or scratches, but we also use it on the glass stove top with no ill effect.