"...Max Pavey Chess Club here in NY..."
WOW! That's a pretty strong club, as I recall. Isn't that where Bobby Fisher started? Ruben Fine and a bunch of other GM's used to play there?
Here's a chess story for you: In regional tournaments like the 1975 San Bernardino Open they don't give a "brilliancy" prize, because no one is really qualified to judge. So they substitue a "Biggest Upset" prize. That's what I won by beating an A player.
Now I'm a 20 year old college student, and my opponent is a KID! Prolly not even in HS yet, but he's an A player. I play white against his French defense. I never studied that one (at least not as extensively as the Ruy Lopez or Sicilian), but I have always fared well as white against it. He brings his Q out to the K-side and I trap her there and end up getting her with a knight fork. Now even tho he's an A player and I'm a C, he can't give me queen odds and win. So the biggest upset is mine.
Later the very last game is going on, and it's a C player against a B. I'm ahead of the C player by 1/2 point for the best record in our class. There's some $$ and another trophy at stake. He's in trouble. The B player is from Las Vegas and I end up talking with 2 of his friends who are waiting for him to finish so they can drive back together.
The B is out of contention, sees us all waiting, SO HE RESIGNS!! In a superior position.
Oh, well, it's only a game.