lofty1
  • lofty1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Monday, February 4, 2008 1:03:00 PM
rex grossman "took his team" to a superbowl. he flat out sucks. stats say that emmitt smith is the best running back ever. i like him, but i would NEVER say he's the best or even in the top 3.

look at superbowls all you want. good teams get there, not great players. look at stats all you want. when you're surrounded by talent, you tend to perform better as an NFL QB.

brady doesn't impress me. he never has. you guys want to pat his back and kiss his forehead while he cries for the next 5 months, be my guest. he's not impressive. he has a good arm. he's a good quarterback, but the NFL has many good quarterbacks. he's nowhere near the best ever. that's just crazy talk.

tailgater
Monday, February 4, 2008 2:20:00 PM
Lofty,

Do you even watch NFL football?

Until this season, Brady has never been a stat monger. He has won games because he has "it".

This season is just an example of how well he could perform when surrounded by talent. Manning has Harrison, Montana and Young had Rice, etc.

Who did Brady have before this year? The best he had was Branch, who is a distant #2 receiver on that team.

Brady (almost) always simply finds a way to win.

I don't care to discuss the "all time" comparison, because that should be reserved for after he retires and to be honest, I can only speak for QB's I've seen play in my lifetime.

But I've gotta ask: if you could choose any QB currently playing the league today, who would it be?

What about your top 3?

Charlie
Monday, February 4, 2008 2:23:00 PM
Agree with everything tailgater said...Brady is the most unselfish qb in NFL

My top three:

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Eli Manning-how can you not put him in there now?

Charlie

tailgater
Monday, February 4, 2008 2:24:00 PM
Rex Grossman and Trent Dilfer before him were the recipients of a team with a GREAT defense. Their job was to "not lose" the game.

Do you wonder why nobody mentions Rex in discussions of Great QB's?

Then why would you bring him up?

Besides, Grossman never won one, never mind three with two MVPs.

Yes, the TEAM has to be great. Does that mean the QB can't be great either?

Lofty,

How do YOU define a great QB.

You've obviously ignored both stats AND victories as being a crucial element in defining a QBs greatness. So please enlighten us with your savy.

Thank you in advance.

andytv
Monday, February 4, 2008 2:35:00 PM
Big Ben is WAY better at karaoke then the Mannings and Brady.

also, he can pass under pressure; only thing is, he makes bad decisions and can't seem to make great passes when he is NOT presuured.

BTW......the Mannings commercial with the "behind the back" kick is pretty damn funny.

MACS
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:09:00 PM
Re: #41

"Good teams get there, not great players"

Somebody tell that to John Elway the first three times he was there. He got crushed by the Redskins and the Niners. Hell, the SB against the Niners is STILL the largest margin of victory, 56-10.

I dare say no other QB takes those 'teams' as far. Later, when he got some linemen from the Vikes (Zimmerman) and the Skins (Schlereth) and got a running game, he won it twice.

MACS
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:11:00 PM
Also... in reference to Brady... he went to the AFC Championship with Reche friggin' Caldwell as his leading receiver.

THAT is impressive. Ask any Charger fan, that dude sucks.

blackfoot11
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:26:00 PM
there's no doubt brady is a great q-back, but look at the the talent that surrounds him. his completion percentage and touchdowns should be high when he has that much time to pick and throw to his recievers.

put tom brady on the dolfins last season. he wouldn't look so good, but, the fins woulda won more games. i think that can be said about all the great players in the league.

there's no "i" in team.

i wouldn't put eli manning in the top qb's in the league. just my .02

1 superbowl season doesn't make a great q-back in my book. he hasn't played real good till this season, and that started around the 4th or 5th game. i'll hafta see him over the next coupla years.

MACS
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:30:00 PM
Blackie, what about in 2001 when they won the bowl with no running game?

Or in 2003? Or before he got Randy, Welker and Maroney for that matter...

Boy, you guys are forgetful.

blackfoot11
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:38:00 PM
yer reading too much into my post. read the 1st sentance again.

'sides, its my .02, and i'll spend it the way i wanna........................

pacman357
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:39:00 PM
#48 No "i" in team, but there is an "m" and an "e".
MACS
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:45:00 PM

Looking forward to this year's installment.

**Foul language warning**

donutboy2000
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:47:00 PM
#48

There is no "i" in team, but there is "u" in ugly.

blackfoot11
Monday, February 4, 2008 3:51:00 PM
#53......yes, there is.....................
penzt8
Monday, February 4, 2008 5:03:00 PM
For the most part I don't like individual stats for team sports because they are pretty meaningless. Sometimes teams just play great together. Put Brady on half the teams in the NFL and he'd be just another average performer as would Favre, Manning 1, or Manning 2 . Favre has almost all of the individual records, so what? He's only got one Superbowl ring. Marino doesn't even have that.

The QB only controls the game when he's on the field. If the offense put up 35 points every game but their defense gives up 38, they still lose. He gets too much credit when they win and too much blame when they lose.

Place kickers on the other hand, now there's some guys that deserve credit. OK just kidding, they aren't really football players.

tailgater
Monday, February 4, 2008 5:59:00 PM
People are confusing the issues here.

First, if you know football at all, Brady is one of the best QBs in the game today.

Sure, he'd have a terrible record if he played for the Dolphins or Niners (Sorry MACS).

But what does that have to do with anything?

Josh Beckett was a great pitcher last season. It matters not that he played on the world champion Red Sox. You can't fault a player for being on a GOOD team!!

But then we hear folks (again, those who simply DON'T understand) who say that Brady is only great because of the talent around him. Well, that's true for THIS season, but what explains 2001?

Or 2003?

And when Brady finally DID get some offensive talent to surround him, what did he do?

Oh yeah, he broke EVERY record EVER made.

More points. more TD's. Posted the highest percentage in one game. Threw 300 tds to only 1 pick.

You get the point.

Not bad for an average QB...

blackfoot11
Tuesday, February 5, 2008 3:39:00 AM
so what was the issue here?

oh yeah, the 1st post. it read; brady is not a great q.b...........that is what my post was a response to, not ; "how great is brady"? seems i was posting in his defense.

so what............now you want me to agree with the topic?

JDELLLL
Tuesday, February 5, 2008 3:59:00 AM
The old chicken or the egg. Is he great because the team is great or is the team great because he is great? Maybe some of both. My observation is that Brady is one of the best. Besides, it tends to shine through. Most people knew Archie Manning was one of the best even though he never had a good team behind him. I lived in New Orleans in those days.
teedubbya
Tuesday, February 5, 2008 4:23:00 AM
there is an I in WIN

Brady is top ten ever maybe even top 5.

The Pats cheat and I am glad they lost.

Caldwells eyes still wig me out

Jr. Has pubes on his head

All things being equal, I'd take Farve over Brady.

But it would take some thought because Brady deserves to be mentioned in the same sentance with Farve

Did I mention I am glad the cheaters lost

I hope Brady is honest with congress, Leavenworth doesn't need another QB and Vick isn't willing to switch to receiver