tailgater
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 2:39:00 PM
Boss,

It's OK to question and discuss how "god" fits in to a world filled with terrible things.

I'd say about half of my close friends don't believe in a god, or don't care either way. Maybe it's more, it's not a frequent topic.

But to suggest that oneself gets "sick" when the topic is discussed? That's absurd.

If an agnostic finds out their kid is ill, and a well-wisher offers to "say a prayer to God for their recovery", how is that even remotely offensive? It's a kind gesture, probably from the heart. And since the well-wisher is not likely the doctor, it's the only thing they feel they can do.

It's a beautiful, selfless act intended to provide comfort, but some people feel compelled to scoff at the offer.

I've seen similar posts where people offered prayers because somebody on this board had/has a sick family member. Does that sicken the non-believers?

Those who don't "believe" should save their contempt for the religious fanatics who force their own agenda. They shouldn't chastize a peaceful thought of good intent.

victor808
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 3:02:00 PM
I'm going to disagree a little with you Tailgater.

I think this is completely contextual.

For example, if I ever had a child (god forbid, pun intended) and it got sick, and I actually wanted it to recover... I would be very bothered if someone said they were praying for me/it.

This is for the simple reason that if there is a positive outcome, the "well wisher" gets to co-opt some of the joy and pretend to take some credit for the event... (sort of a "good thing I was praying for you" thing).

If everyone involved has the same religion, there is no issue. So for the thread the OP mentioned, this isn't an issue. But I do think that one should be sensitive to this before doing anything like that.

jpotts
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 3:08:00 PM
victor808:

With all due respect, and seeing that you're an athiest, I don't think you understand the purpose behind prayer.

I also don't think you want to either, so I won't go into any great detail.

Prayer supposed to be used more for comfort then is is petitioning a diety. Which is the reason why is somewhat astounds me that people take issue with fairly harmless and / or comforting comments in the thread in question.

Ergo my belief that some people need a good ole' fashioned colon cleaning to work out what it is in their system that's got them all bent out of shape.

Never let it be said that Bran doesn't have its uses.

jjohnson28
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 3:10:00 PM
Nuts
victor808
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 3:26:00 PM
Ah,but thats sort of the point potts.

If it isn't my religion, I'm not going to understand (nor really care to understand) the point of it. It becomes a somewhat insulting statement, possibly through misinterpretation, but still insulting. this is why I say it should be contextual. As long as you are confident that the recipient of this type of comment will understand and appreciate it,then it is kind.

RICKAMAVEN
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 4:01:00 PM
i'm glad no one got hurt in that ied vs the humvee photo

i don't care who or what you thank. if you have a specific faith and you believe your faith saved your son and the two others, so be it.

any one that wants to discuss anything about god, ping me, start a new thread, and get out of greenwolf70's face, his son was not hurt. mr greenwolf70, i hope your son returns home safe and sound, and soon.

RICKAMAVEN
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 4:05:00 PM
putz

y have u diminished yourself to writing bran muffin recipes (the s means more then 1)

tailgater
Wednesday, June 11, 2008 4:27:00 PM
Vic,

If you ever had a child, and that child got hurt, you would NOT be offended if someone were to take partial credit. You wouldn't care how. You wouldn't care why. You would simply be thankful that your kid was OK.

You don't need to believe in God to feel that kind of love for your child.

You and I may forever disagree on virtually every subject matter worth discussing, but you are not a dispicable person. And it would take one of those to be bothered by the "details" of who takes credit when you finally get your kid back.