[quote=JohnE1000]Recently I had one from 07 and another from 09. To me, the 07 was smoother, but flatter.

I tell you what, I will try another from 07, and if I don't like it, you are welcome to the rest.

[/quote]

Not at all saying I doubt your tastes John. Every batch/year is different for many reasons. I have not missed a year on PSD#4 since '01 and some have been better with less age. Just talking generalities with my experience.

If you find them not to your liking I'm sure someone will be happy to get them.

DED

SCdlH Principe next up

Elitest

John since DED turned em down I'll take you up on that offer...

[quote=dubleuhb]Elitest[/quote]





I have 1

I'll second wheelie's opinion of the JL's. They are a nice smoke when young. Not too strong and very floral. Not sure if that fits your profile, Ray, but they have a nice sweetness to them and you can actually catch whiffs of baby powder while you smoke them. Hell, the wife has even commented that she likes the smell of the Juanny's.

Same vitola? #2?

[quote=fishinguitarman]Same vitola? #2?[/quote]


Gimme a minute. I'ma go git one and fire it up. I guess I forgot what I got.

[quote=JadeRose]Gimme a minute. I'ma go git one and fire it up. I guess I forgot what I got.
[/quote]


Nope....these are the Petit Corona. Little suckers but a nice "savor" smoke. You can coax an hour out of them. The one strange thing I've noticed about them is how thirsty they are. I kid you not, I have to really pay attention to the humi they are in because it dries out fast with those in there. (No..it's not the humi..never had this problem with it before.)

As I said, not sure if they fit your profile, with you being a maddie-headed ho, but I like em.

[quote=fishinguitarman]I'm soaking up this wealth of knowledge[/quote]
all your living years i am quite sure you have a whole lot of knowledge soaked up but i heard you had a brain leak? LOL

[quote=JadeRose]Nope....these are the Petit Corona. Little suckers but a nice "savor" smoke. You can coax an hour out of them. The one strange thing I've noticed about them is how thirsty they are. I kid you not, I have to really pay attention to the humi they are in because it dries out fast with those in there. (No..it's not the humi..never had this problem with it before.)

As I said, not sure if they fit your profile, with you being a maddie-headed ho, but I like em.[/quote]




Gotta dig....think I have one to try....

[quote=t33bone]all your living years i am quite sure you have a whole lot of knowledge soaked up but i heard you had a brain leak? LOL[/quote]






leak...no



fart....yes

Which One........






Rascc
RASS
PSD4
SCdlH Principe
Juan Lopez Petite Corona
Party Shorts

JL is prolly the best bargain in your list..

muchass grassyass

[quote=fishinguitarman]Which One........






Rascc
RASS
PSD4
SCdlH Principe
Juan Lopez Petite Corona
Party Shorts[/quote]

color me a ruh'tard...but didn't you about squirt yourself over the PSD4 you smoked?

seems purdy obvious to me....


Buy several and split em'![frypan]

[quote=fishinguitarman]Which One........






Rascc
RASS
PSD4
SCdlH Principe
Juan Lopez Petite Corona
Party Shorts[/quote]

All of them, lol I havn't tried the JL but the others yes minus PSD4 and I have only heard good things about them. I actually might just have aquired some 😰 .

[quote=APBTMarcel]All of them, lol I havn't tried the JL but the others yes minus PSD4 and I have only heard good things about them. I actually might just have aquired some 😰 . [/quote]




Minus the PSD4?

[quote=fishinguitarman]Minus the PSD4?[/quote]

Yea my bad that was a confusing post. I just say minus the PSD4 because I have yet to try one. I did pick up some PSP2's though. I know I need to try a PSD4 it's a cuban staple. Maybe next order I'll be a box of 10.

With my minimal experience with CC's, I'm at the opposite end of the spectrum from being knowledgable about them, but I can still tell when I've smoked an incredible cigar and the PSD4 fit the bill!