Thanks for the candid responses. To cover off a few points..
- Tim left CAO last November. So are you saying that the quality of CAO basically started going downhill the middle of last year? What brands do you feel this happened with? Again - just asking for clarification.
- In terms of quality going down, that is a tough one to really pinpoint since it is such a subjective matter. What I will say is this - we haven't changed anything. The recipes are the same. The blends are the same. The tobacco is the same. When we began production of these cigars at HATSA (the factory in Danli, Honduras) and Esteli (in Nic), these cigars were now under the watch of employees who have been in the cigar business for decades. Say what you want about the recipes, but the "chefs and the cooks" are now some of the most experienced and hardest working in the world. Their goal is to produce the best quality cigars possible, on-time.
- I hear this one a lot. However, what names have been damaged? In recent years (say the last 10), the only other major "acquisition" has been La Gloria Cubana. I'd say Mike Giannini and Team La Gloria have done a pretty good job of coming out with some great products, even after Ernesto left to form his company. Serie N, Artesanos de Miami, Artesanos de Tabaqueros, and Retro Especiale (this year) have been the releases, and they've all pushed the envelope in terms of packaging and blend innovation.
- General has had a rough go with some new releases over the years, and I think a lot of that has to do with the perception that no matter what, it's going to suck. Have we come out with some sub-par blends? Sure. But we've also had some winners (Mac Cru Royale, Punch Rare Corojo, Upper Cut, the LGCs above, Hoyo de Tradicion). Sometimes a blend just doesn't resonate with people and that's fine - you move on and you try something else. But, I look at it this way - if you don't like Burger King or McDonald's, no matter what you're not going to like their new burger/chicken sandwich/whatever. You hate them, so you have a preconception that you won't like it - no matter what. And I don't know what to say there.
- I think the other reason is this one...
- This one hurts, as it's a tough one to overcome this perception. General is large, if not the largest. We've got some huge brands that people love - Punch, Macanudo, Partagas, Hoyo de Monterrey, Excalibur, etc.... the brands are ubiquitous. At the same time, every person who works here on the brands are passionate about them. I loved Punch for the 2+ years I worked on that brand - I still do. Rick and I absolutely love working on CAO now - we're able to do whatever we want on packaging, tobacco, blends, rollers, processing. It's so much fun, and we love talking to cigar lovers about what they want in a cigar. We do care. But when it doesn't translate out in the field, or the business side gets in the way, it puts a crimp in it all.
- I'm sorry you had that experience with a rep. That sucks, no doubt. But to paint them all the same and assume all General reps are douches is a tough way to go. Maybe the guy had a bad day that day. Maybe he was new. Maybe he was a douche. I'm not sure what to say there - but to say that the cigars suck because a rep pissed you off is mixing a little bit of apples and oranges.
I'll keep checking back in to this thread - and I'll give you my take on anything you want to know about here. Rick and I are wide open and will tell you what we think - and we want to know what you think. Only by communicating can we call come to understand each other's POV and hopefully move forward.
Thanks again, guys, for your time.
- Ed
Ed, I respect your candor and position to defend General Cigar, which is in my opinion, the destroyer of great cigar lines!
They are once again, trashing a great little cigar line, by taking it into their fold of bland sticks........promos, boxes, point of purchase displays etc do not make a great cigar..........if it did, GC would have a complete line of great cigars and Partagas would be worth smoking once again........
to each his own, I know I will not light another CAO, nor will many of my "elitist brothers"!
edmckenna wrote: