Charlie
Sunday, September 11, 2011 10:14:17 AM

Thanks for the candid responses. To cover off a few points..

- Tim left CAO last November. So are you saying that the quality of CAO basically started going downhill the middle of last year? What brands do you feel this happened with? Again - just asking for clarification.

- In terms of quality going down, that is a tough one to really pinpoint since it is such a subjective matter. What I will say is this - we haven't changed anything. The recipes are the same. The blends are the same. The tobacco is the same. When we began production of these cigars at HATSA (the factory in Danli, Honduras) and Esteli (in Nic), these cigars were now under the watch of employees who have been in the cigar business for decades. Say what you want about the recipes, but the "chefs and the cooks" are now some of the most experienced and hardest working in the world. Their goal is to produce the best quality cigars possible, on-time.

- I hear this one a lot. However, what names have been damaged? In recent years (say the last 10), the only other major "acquisition" has been La Gloria Cubana. I'd say Mike Giannini and Team La Gloria have done a pretty good job of coming out with some great products, even after Ernesto left to form his company. Serie N, Artesanos de Miami, Artesanos de Tabaqueros, and Retro Especiale (this year) have been the releases, and they've all pushed the envelope in terms of packaging and blend innovation.

- General has had a rough go with some new releases over the years, and I think a lot of that has to do with the perception that no matter what, it's going to suck. Have we come out with some sub-par blends? Sure. But we've also had some winners (Mac Cru Royale, Punch Rare Corojo, Upper Cut, the LGCs above, Hoyo de Tradicion). Sometimes a blend just doesn't resonate with people and that's fine - you move on and you try something else. But, I look at it this way - if you don't like Burger King or McDonald's, no matter what you're not going to like their new burger/chicken sandwich/whatever. You hate them, so you have a preconception that you won't like it - no matter what. And I don't know what to say there.

- I think the other reason is this one...

- This one hurts, as it's a tough one to overcome this perception. General is large, if not the largest. We've got some huge brands that people love - Punch, Macanudo, Partagas, Hoyo de Monterrey, Excalibur, etc.... the brands are ubiquitous. At the same time, every person who works here on the brands are passionate about them. I loved Punch for the 2+ years I worked on that brand - I still do. Rick and I absolutely love working on CAO now - we're able to do whatever we want on packaging, tobacco, blends, rollers, processing. It's so much fun, and we love talking to cigar lovers about what they want in a cigar. We do care. But when it doesn't translate out in the field, or the business side gets in the way, it puts a crimp in it all.

- I'm sorry you had that experience with a rep. That sucks, no doubt. But to paint them all the same and assume all General reps are douches is a tough way to go. Maybe the guy had a bad day that day. Maybe he was new. Maybe he was a douche. I'm not sure what to say there - but to say that the cigars suck because a rep pissed you off is mixing a little bit of apples and oranges.

I'll keep checking back in to this thread - and I'll give you my take on anything you want to know about here. Rick and I are wide open and will tell you what we think - and we want to know what you think. Only by communicating can we call come to understand each other's POV and hopefully move forward.

Thanks again, guys, for your time.

- Ed

Ed, I respect your candor and position to defend General Cigar, which is in my opinion, the destroyer of great cigar lines!

They are once again, trashing a great little cigar line, by taking it into their fold of bland sticks........promos, boxes, point of purchase displays etc do not make a great cigar..........if it did, GC would have a complete line of great cigars and Partagas would be worth smoking once again........

to each his own, I know I will not light another CAO, nor will many of my "elitist brothers"!

edmckenna wrote:

🐴 [ram27bat]

robertknyc
Monday, November 14, 2011 3:16:13 PM
Interesting thread. I tried this cigar fresh from a local last night and loved it. I had the Lot 58, 6.5 x 58 and it was a 2 1/2 hr. smoke. I'm a big fan of the MX2 and this one is a refreshing change of pace. I would describe it as having a flavor similar to a Macanudo, but instead of being mild it's medium+ and very full bodied. With its very reasonable price it will definitely go into my rotation.

As for all the other CAO stuff, I think people are overthinking this. Buy what you like and don't buy what you don't like. I enjoy the LX2, MX2, America and Brasilia but not much else. The nice thing is that there seems to be something for everyone at a reasonable price. I'm glad they're there.

05busa
Monday, November 14, 2011 3:19:59 PM
i want to try these sooner or later
yardobeef
Monday, November 14, 2011 6:02:58 PM
I'm just getting started with cigars so take my opinion for what its worth.

This was the 4th cigar I tried (I'm excluding my reckless youth with the occasional gas station smoke) and I really liked it a lot. It had a very refreshing flavor with perhaps a hint of pine and the wrapper smell was a bit minty. I had the robusto and enjoyed it thoroughly.

leftyposthole
Monday, November 14, 2011 6:37:01 PM
I happen to like the brazillia gol as well and they only are only 88.00 bucks a box all over the internet....................
critter2
Monday, November 14, 2011 6:40:48 PM
another vendor sent me a sample robusto with an order, wasn't worth free
t33bone
Monday, November 14, 2011 11:45:39 PM
any OSA ho's out there? PM me
hambone71
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 12:42:44 AM
I recently bought a CAO La Traviata single. Haven't smoked it yet, just have it resting in the humi. Anyone have any thoughts on that stick?
dubleuhb
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 12:45:20 AM
Decent smoke, enjoy!
hambone71
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 12:52:58 AM
Thanks
Lancaster6802
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 1:04:09 AM

I sent all my Brazilia BPs over to A'Stan & Iraq quite a while ago.

I am down to a couple Sopranos, a box of America from the first year of release and a couple of "odds & ends" older lines

engletl wrote:

Was the Sopranos any good? Iv always wondered... I Love the show and the packaging looks cool, but the price is high for a CAO.

I saw jokers stick you sent him, looked vintage....very nice SIR

stogiemonger
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 7:39:26 AM
I rather enjoy the OSA. I've only smoked a few robbies, but, they were a nice medium bodied smoke with a nice aroma. I'll buy more eventually.
delarob
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 8:31:25 AM
Wow. I'm sure my supv wouldn't like the time I wasted reading this whole thread but meh, what are they gonna do? 😰

Anywho, I gotta say I do loves me some old Annies, the Sopranos, CAO Black (Gothic only) and the La Traviatas, can't stand the Criollo. As far as the rest of the lines I can take em or leave em but I like to find a couple in every line up and stick with them. I do get annoyed with some companies that have to put out 1 or 10 new lines every year. Make a couple blends, do them well and quit fiddle-fu**ing with new stuff all the time. Rocky used to put out a couple blends and he did them great. I won't buy his stuff anymore because it's all bland to me now. Same with Perdomo. I think this may be where people are coming from Ed. Reign it in a bit. Quit with the MX, Vision, OSA and so on and so forth ad-nauseum. Get back to basics and bring back what people loved about the cigar.

And please, stop with the "innovative packaging" and all of the glitter BS. I could give a rat's-ass what the box or band looks like. You could take a marker, cut strips off of an old paper bag and tape it (carefully of course) on the cigar and I'd be cool with it. I ain't smoking the package. If the cigar is good, it speaks for itself.

I still keep the old Mayorga High Octane triangle box around to remind myself NOT to buy a space killer like that again.

dubleuhb
Tuesday, November 15, 2011 8:38:14 AM
^^^Well said=d> ^^^
robertknyc
Saturday, December 3, 2011 1:54:00 AM
Okay, I bought a box of the 54s and after smoking two I found that they were more mild-medium, unlike the 58 I bought at the local which I describe in post 102.. Still a good smoke but I would prefer it being a bit stronger. I wonder if the strength level varies from box/vitola to box/vitola...time will tell.
t33bone
Saturday, December 3, 2011 3:35:54 AM

any OSA ho's out there? PM me

t33bone wrote:

I guess none are really loving this cigar cuz I got no PM from anyone. [ram27bat]

t33bone
Saturday, December 3, 2011 3:37:00 AM

I haven't seen this cigar but if TG and t bone says try it I guess I will look harder.

grmcooper wrote:

:-k

chazbo
Saturday, December 3, 2011 5:46:37 AM
Tuck, pm sent

Thanks

Chazbo

robertknyc
Saturday, December 3, 2011 11:11:32 AM
Tuck, thanks for the invitation...I just decided to go in for a box myself.
delta1
Saturday, December 3, 2011 7:36:18 PM
Haven't tried too many CAO's. My only experience was a fiver of the Golds, which didn't impress me enough to put them on my "get more" list. I did get an OSA robusto as a freebie when I bought a bunch of stuff from another vendor (some vendors still throw unexpected goodies into the box when you buy a bunch). After about a two month rest, I smoked it and really enjoyed it. It had a likable blend of flavors for my still maturing palette, drew well, decent aroma, and enough kick to satisfy and relax. The CAO OSA is on my list.