Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, September 2, 2011 11:33:21 AM

Yeah...sorry...the guy comes in with a post saying and it's on the previous page saved in a quote...

"This is the first time I've posted to a board in response to a post like this, as I don't want to seem like I'm invading a sacred space, or trying to sound like a company wonk. I'm generally curious as to why folks have certain opinions and want to make sure everyone has all the facts before they make a decision about CAO. I hope you guys can help me understand and we can at least understand everyone's POV.

- Ed McKenna"

Then alters the post.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

I just ran a diff on Ed's posts and what was quoted and they are identical. Nothing changed.

Sorry, I haven't been keeping up with the CAO brand for years because of the shady stuff they've pulled.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

They you should be happy about that THOSE people, THAT factory and all the shenanigans that you feel THEY pulled are all gone and out of the picture now.

No pleasing some people I guess.

/shrug

So which is it? Now we know. He could've been upfront to begin with but he wasn't. He took the "Gosh, I thought everyone knew who I was" route. Sorry, I haven't been keeping up with the CAO brand for years because of the shady stuff they've pulled. Yeah, I'm the one guy that will call it what it is. I really don't care what a rep says. The cigars DID change and it's not just me stating that. Pretty funny that they changes happened, oh about the same timeline that they moved production, but then again...their ""chefs" know best. Please. Now Ed wants to slam anyone that disagreese with his POV? Sorry Ed, I'm all out of 2nd chances when it comes to CAO. There are better brandnames out there and PS...General doesn't carry them! The same dulled brands your "chefs" have killed off are the ones that cannot be found here anymore. Thank God for small miracles I guess.

But please hang around...now that we ALL know who you are...NOW! I don't know you might be a nice guy...Who knows, but the cigars you represent...I don't buy, for a good reason.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

So you gave up years ago on CAO, long before General, and now you're screaming at the new owners over what they had nothing to do with.

Makes perfect sense. No, really...

DrMaddVibe
Friday, September 2, 2011 11:39:45 AM

Seemed fairly obvious to me from Ed's first post that he worked for General Cigar. Sure, he didn't spell it out, but there were enough clues there; the questions asked, how they were asked, referencing how he hears the same things over and will continue to hear them, referring to understanding a POV, speaking in the first person but using "we" rather than "I", etc.

Not quite sure how loving ones job and trying to improve things by finding out what people don't like about a company/line/product while also offering some explanations on certain issues makes them a wonk either. /shrug

Thunder.Gerbil wrote:

You even commented on my post!

Sorry, like I said...they used to be able to make a 1st run that would have me buying their cigars...the Maddie and Cameroon Annie's...were awesome...the new runs...Utter crap! Same goes for every other line that used to be out there except for the ones I mentioned earlier.

At their price point there are FAR better cigars to smoke than theirs. I'm even willing to say I'd pass on a freebie. Gringo gave me a LaTravesty...I tried it. It was okay but not something I'd ever buy. I was glad I tried it, but it's not going to make me rush on down and get one.

DrMaddVibe
Friday, September 2, 2011 12:12:35 PM

So you gave up years ago on CAO, long before General, and now you're screaming at the new owners over what they had nothing to do with.

Makes perfect sense. No, really...

Thunder.Gerbil wrote:

I really wanted to say that I was prolly the first one here to take a swipe at Jon and what CAO was all about, but I could be wrong. There were others here that mentioned it too...I KNOW I wasn't alone.

The posts are here....somewhere.

New owners...old owners...that doesn't change a thing! The cigars are the cigars. They sucked then and they suck now. Oh, sure there are fanboi's of theirs that buy everything they make...good! It's not my cup o tea at all. I'm not going to swivel at the waist and tell long stories about how great they are now either because someone else overpaid for their name!

CAO found a buyer and they sold on a highnote. That's Business 101.

Now, because they have new people hawking their wares I'm supposed to pretend that EVERYTHING has changed? C'mon...even YOU know that it hasn't!

Whatever. Really. The "guy" that's really a rep wanted info. Well, he got it. Prolly not what he wanted but that's not my problem. I'm the one being 100% completely open and honest.

Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, September 2, 2011 12:35:48 PM

You even commented on my post!

DrMaddVibe wrote:

I know I commented, and why wouldn't I? It seemed obvious to me, and apparently to others too, that Ed worked for General.

Sorry, like I said...they used to be able to make a 1st run that would have me buying their cigars...the Maddie and Cameroon Annie's...were awesome...the new runs...Utter crap! Same goes for every other line that used to be out there except for the ones I mentioned earlier.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

That would be solely a CAO under Cano with rolling at Perdomo and later Cano & Tim with rolling at Torano issue then, would it not?

If it drove you from the brand, hey, that's cool, I understand. I've noticed changes in other brands before, sometimes it's for the better, sometimes the worse. When it's for the worse, I just move on. I'm certainly not going to get worked up about something that is supposed to be relaxing.

That's why Ed asked. He wanted to know what drove people from CAO back when CAO was CAO. And it seems that inconsistency is a big issue. Just personal opinion here, but I've always felt that while General might have it's faults, lack of consistency was never one of them.

At their price point there are FAR better cigars to smoke than theirs. I'm even willing to say I'd pass on a freebie. Gringo gave me a LaTravesty...I tried it. It was okay but not something I'd ever buy. I was glad I tried it, but it's not going to make me rush on down and get one.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

Smoke what you like, like what you smoke, since to everyone else, it's just contaminated air. :)

To you it might be crap. To the next guy, it might be tobacco nirvana. It's really not that important so long as you are enjoying what you are smoking.

La Traviata was Huber's blend, I believe. I thought it was a good cigar, but just not what I care to smoke.

elk hunter
Friday, September 2, 2011 12:51:37 PM

Absolutely. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. In the absence of information, people tend to speculate to the negative as well. I think that happens quite a bit.

You guys are right here, and as several of you have mentioned to me, this is probably where the whole pricing perception thing comes into play.

I could say that General didn't run Tim off, but that probably sounds hollow. Tim summed it up himself the day he left the company:

http://www.toastedfoot.com/2010/11/personal-statement-tim-ozgener-leaves-cao-international/ 

We're getting into a complex group of hypothetical chefs, cooks, and other eating related terms - but I get what you're saying. Again, all I'm saying is that the recipes are the same. You can argue whether or not there are master chefs at the helm at HATSA and Esteli, but having been there many times, I know those guys know what they are doing - and they can make those recipes.

I'm glad you liked OSA, and I hope others will give it a try and see if it is for them. If not, that's fine too - hopefully we'll make something they will like down the road.

Thanks again to everyone for giving me their perspective - I hope to meet some of you at events down the road - in fact, Rick is about to head out for about 40 events throughout this fall to talk about OSA. Keep an eye out at your local B+M for those - and of course the info will be up at our website as well.

edmckenna wrote:

Well, come on out to Portland Oregon!!! Ed Trevino has been the rep out here, and he is a DAMN GOOD GUY!!!

Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, September 2, 2011 1:17:15 PM

I really wanted to say that I was prolly the first one here to take a swipe at Jon and what CAO was all about, but I could be wrong. There were others here that mentioned it too...I KNOW I wasn't alone.

The posts are here....somewhere.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

So this is a personal vendetta.

Awesome.

New owners...old owners...that doesn't change a thing! The cigars are the cigars. They sucked then and they suck now.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

It absolutely does change things because the new owners have changed the operation and the people in it. You even said how great the first releases would be, and then how the subsequent releases would go to crap in your eyes. The new owners have these old formulas (blends) that were great on the first release, but they have removed most of the elements that could cause the changes that would make them go downhill.

I don't know if General can resurrect the flavor of the original releases of old or not. That might not be possible because how the old CAO handled tobacco lots. If it's a buying issue, no one has more buying power than General. No one.

How will all of this pan out in the long run? That remains to be seen.

Oh, sure there are fanboi's of theirs that buy everything they make...good! It's not my cup o tea at all. I'm not going to swivel at the waist and tell long stories about how great they are now either because someone else overpaid for their name!

CAO found a buyer and they sold on a highnote. That's Business 101.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

Instead you're swiveling at the waist and jumping up and down screaming about how bad you feel they are, kind of like how the "fanboy' you so despise would defend it.

Ironic, isn't it?

Now, because they have new people hawking their wares I'm supposed to pretend that EVERYTHING has changed? C'mon...even YOU know that it hasn't!

DrMaddVibe wrote:

No, not EVERYTHING. And there is nothing to pretend. Some things did change. Some, like the blend formulas that resulted in the cigars that you, yourself said were outstanding on their first release, didn't.

Again, I don't know how this is going to pan out and I'm not making predictions. But I'm willing to watch and wait as it does.

Whatever. Really. The "guy" that's really a rep wanted info. Well, he got it. Prolly not what he wanted but that's not my problem. I'm the one being 100% completely open and honest.

DrMaddVibe wrote:

...and then some.

DrMaddVibe
Friday, September 2, 2011 1:22:53 PM

So this is a personal vendetta.

Thunder.Gerbil wrote:

Nope, not at all.

When you eat a crap sandwich you can either nibble at it or munch it down.:-&

It's still a crap sandwich made by a "chef".[jester]

I'd rather just not go there ever again.

More power to ya though![-x

HockeyDad
Friday, September 2, 2011 1:24:40 PM
Does ThunderGerbil work for General/CAO as well?!
DrMaddVibe
Friday, September 2, 2011 1:27:10 PM

Does ThunderGerbil work for General/CAO as well?!

HockeyDad wrote:

I dunno...maybe CAO tore a page from the Gurkha Fan Club.

[frypan] [frypan] [frypan]

NYYankees
Friday, September 2, 2011 1:55:29 PM

As far as this March mandated price increase - I honestly don't know what that's referring to. If there was one, I'd have to be the one to approve it. And I didn't. The last thing we would have done upon taking the brands would be to mandate a price increase. That's just insanity and stupid, and yes if we did it - that would be greed personified. But we didn't. So again - not sure where that info came from. If you can show me where you saw that, I'd love to know.

edmckenna wrote:

If there wasn't a mandated price hike on General's orders, then there are some companies, local shops as well as mass market catalogue shops, that have including much advertising indicating CAO's were going up in price due to a mandated order.

In my local area it was June 30th/July 1st as the posted hike date.

Whistlebritches
Friday, September 2, 2011 2:35:16 PM
Thunder.Gerbil

Does General pay you to toss their salad????Or do you just enjoy it???:-"

Ron

HockeyDad
Friday, September 2, 2011 5:31:47 PM
As I said in post #11, the brand was on the downhill slide long before General got involved. The "powers that be" cashed out at the perfect time.

There once was this startup cigar company named CAO. They had some staff, some contracts with some factories, and had some cigar blends that were targeted to the mid-range of the market around $5-$8 per cigar. Some of those early blends were pretty decent like the Maduro, Xtreme, and the Brasilia and to gain a foothold in that crowded price point range, they marketed, hyped, marketed, hyped and even lifestyle marketed (which I believe equates to 3.2X regular marketing.) A number of their staffers even posted here quite frequently and used places like this for word-of-mouth advertising.

They did things like run promotions where if you sent in 5 of their cigar bands, they would send you a free CAO hat. If you sent in a picture of yourself in a CAO hat smoking a CAO for their website, they would send you a sampler of cigars. All good marketing ideas to promote the CAO in a crowded market space.

Any a rock star or celebrity as much as looked at a CAO cigar, there was a press release. They went full press on the rock star mindset. They made sure they had a new cigar every year for the trade shows and they had a big booth presence. Eventually this began to take its toll.

.....Next on VH1's Behind the Music.....Trying to Reach the Big Time

Producing a new release every year took its toll. Many will claim that the first year releases from CAO were very good and got the ratings and acclaim but follow-up years dropped in quality. Were they too successful and couldn't ramp up to demand....was the tobacco supply chain not there....was it that they didn't have their own factories and really were just a label and marketing dept....

To meet the new release every year expectation, they started just combining pieces and parts of existing cigars. The LX2, CX2, MX2, heck they even packed Brasilias and Italias together and made Bratalias. Limited editions began sprinkling the lineup. Odyssey, Palms, 65th annie, and others...special boxes for existing cigars.

....and then in the shark jumping moment, they cracked open the seal on the vault and released the Escaparates.

Inside CAO International's world headquarters in Nashville, lies the exclusive Escaparate (Spanish for “Showcase”) humidor which houses very rare and unique CAO cigar blends that will never see regular production. The reason is that these exceptional, prototype cigar blends that contain tobaccos that are so rare, that the cigar factory would never be able to procure enough of these special tobaccos to produce a cigar for national distribution.

All the while the marketing stayed absolutely A+. The brand was big. The name was big. Somebody even showed up one day to a meeting with some Powerpoint presentation explaining how the marketing budget for free hats could now be reduced and the hats and other merchandise could be sold. They were big enough now they didn't need this freebie advertising. It could now be monetized into a revenue stream with 5 year projections and stuff.

All the while underneath there still was that burning question as to how good the cigars were, especially after the first year release. Could CAO make a good release, up production, and maintain the quality.

Next the company got bought out and merged. People showed up with Powerpoints talking about synergies, combined efficiencies, marketing power and how wonderful it would be. Offices started moving around. Production started moving around. Slowly the old CAO people vanished into the sunset bringing about a bright new day under General Cigar.

The next chapter is not written. Will it be cigars that maintain where CAO was? Will it be better cigars than they were? Can General get these cigars back to how good they originally were? Will there just be more Powerpoints?

Ed is now in charge of CAO. Let's see what you got.

HockeyDad
Friday, September 2, 2011 5:34:27 PM
There are two other labels out there today that pretty much are following the CAO method. I would identify them but I don't have time because I need to google what their next limited edition release is. I'm expecting one on Monday because it is a month ending in "R".
engletl
  • engletl
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, September 2, 2011 5:36:04 PM

As I said in post #11, the brand was on the downhill slide long before General got involved. The "powers that be" cashed at the perfect time.

There once...they originally were? Will there just be more Powerpoints?

Ed is now in charge of CAO. Let's see what you got.

HockeyDad wrote:

Well said

rwilly
Friday, September 2, 2011 5:57:36 PM
Can't we all just get along?????
DBIII
Friday, September 2, 2011 6:23:31 PM
Great posts Hockey....I learned something new today and I thank you for that.
lou2row
Friday, September 2, 2011 6:36:52 PM
Ed, a couple things on just my opinion:

-I agree with the guys about the "make a good cigar, hype the crap out if it, then make a second run a shadow of the original and see who notices". For me, the CAO black VR was the biggy. But I have noticed the same from Italia, Brazilia, Sopranos. Why try something, like it, then buy a box and be stuck.

-The Vision box was a huge joke. I really enjoyed the cigar, but to be stuck buying that box where the humistat didn't work from the start. The cigar was worth $5-6 a stick, not the ten everyone had to charge due to the box cost.

-Using a meth addict-looking nobody as the face of the company was a turnoff to me. A lot of people around here thought Jon was some kind of rockstar, I didn't.

I know these are all prior to General, but they are what my opinion of the brand are based on. I have no bones with a big company and will try some to see what you guys do, but realize you will be on a pretty short leash from the bulk of previous buyers. whether you are like the original runs or the crappy late models will decide.

One comment on what I seen from your posts on here that is a bit telling. Someone posts of his contact with one of your (Generals) own reps. You make excuses for the guy, instead of finding out about the situation and looking into it. Makes me think you have no issue with your reps being "douches". At least that is how it appears to me. As I said, telling.

I do enjoy Hoyo de Monterrays, especially long aged. The new Hoyo de Tradtionne I smoked was one of the worst cigars I've had this year.

tj2001cobra
Saturday, September 3, 2011 2:46:42 AM
While not a CAO fan, I find it pretty crappy the way some of you are treating this guy. He is getting blasted and I think it is unfair.

I just bought a new business, and thankfully, the respnse has been positive when I ask about how customers have been treated and the way we do things. If we suck at something, I dont mind hearing about it as long as I feel there is something I can do to change it. At least give the guy a chance. It was obvious he was some sort of rep when he posted.

While most of General's line-up aren't my thing, I'm not going to call the guy a piece of shit just for coming on here and asking what people dont like about the brand. Give him criticism if you want, but at least tell him what to fix or what you dont like rather than making the guy leave.

Have other General reps ever logged on here?

tj2001cobra
Saturday, September 3, 2011 2:48:14 AM
And as for TG, I think he is just trying to deflect some of the heat for this guy. It's human nature to come to the defense of someone who is getting unfairly treated. List your problems and move forward. Dont be mean to the person asking the questions.
BuckyB93
Saturday, September 3, 2011 9:42:18 AM

Rick and I absolutely love working on CAO now - we're able to do whatever we want on packaging, tobacco, blends, rollers, processing.

edmckenna wrote:

I have a novel idea for you. I hope you're sitting down because this will blow your mind.

A RECTANGULAR CEDAR BOX

Make a good product and it will sell itself. I smoke the cigars not the packaging. I never understood the need to have all the flashy, gaudy, bling bling packaging. It just adds unnecessary costs to the product. The Vision and Soprano's are prime examples. To me they just scream "Crappy cigars inside" much like a glass top humi containing some fine Cohibas.

That's just my knee jerk reaction to things all flashy,fancy, "look at me" things.

When the Vision first came out and I saw the box they came in my first thought was "WTF?" My second thought was "Where's the catch?" If a company needs these gimmicks to sell their product, any product, then they probably have a crappy product. Not saying one way or another if CAO makes a crappy product just giving my opinion: tone down the hype and focus that energy and resources into the product.

Unless, of course, the packaging is the product {shrug}

I will also resonate on what tj said. I find it refreshing to see a company rep asking for honest and open advice here on the forum. Provide your input and suggestions (positive or negative) without the need to flame.