[quote=gmdrews]The onlyone i smoked was a PSD4 and i thought it was great but thats all i know and im a noob so...[/quote]


GM, you are spot on! my fav cuban too!!!

[quote=kombat96]good to hear, just ordered a box of them.

Ray whats ur input on the aging of the Bolivar petite corona and punch punch. id like to get a box of each, ive smoked 1 of each & enjoyed it, did not know the aging of them though. [/quote]




Haven't been into them long enough to know. Both of those are mentioned in this thread though.

thats sorta why i bought some. figured u azzhats knew something about cigars LOL

that and a couple other ppl said they are worth the $$

kombat96
User Profile See other posts by kombat96 Send a Private Message Add to buddy list Hide User Posts #7 Posted: Sun, Feb 19 2012, 12:07 AM Favorites |
Add this topic as a favorite Add this post as a favorite
Quote
Joined: 04-12-2010
Posts: 3,063
cc arent worth the hassle
](*,)

Thats sarcasm, dont want all those cc's bought up now LOL

I love Boli PC's with some age(couple yrs at least).............but they are really hard to keep around that long. Need another cab to put away.

I've really been looking into #2's lately, besides the Monte, what's your fav and why?

[quote=DBIII]I love Boli PC's with some age(couple yrs at least).............but they are really hard to keep around that long. Need another cab to put away.

I've really been looking into #2's lately, besides the Monte, what's your fav and why?[/quote]

H. Upmann and VR Unicos, but I never told you that...

[quote=kombat96]good to hear, just ordered a box of them.

Ray whats ur input on the aging of the Bolivar petite corona and punch punch. id like to get a box of each, ive smoked 1 of each & enjoyed it, did not know the aging of them though. [/quote]

The Punch Punch are nice when young,but as always get better with age.

The Boli PC,as with all Boli's they need a good bit of age..

if you want a smoke that is pretty good when young go with JL#2.

wheel,

[quote=APBTMarcel]H. Upmann and VR Unicos, but I never told you that...[/quote]

Thanks Matt, I'm gonna put away a box of PSP2 first, but have heard a lot of good about the VR Unicos.............there will be a box in the tower someday for sure.

Wheel, I've also heard a ton of good about the JL 2 as well.......and what a good price point lately huh!

🍺 🍺 🍺

[quote=DBIII]

Wheel, I've also heard a ton of good about the JL 2 as well.......and what a good price point lately huh!

🍺 🍺 🍺 [/quote]

For sure,,,=p~

[quote=wheelrite]For sure,,,=p~ [/quote]

JL2 Aug '10 are smoking great!

Read elsewhere that JL1 '11 are smoking well too. Credible reviewers rated it in the low 90-point range with great expectation with age...

Anyone had JL1? Is the profile very different from JL2?

[quote=rfenst]JL2 Aug '10 are smoking great!

Read elsewhere that JL1 '11 are smoking well too. Credible reviewers rated it in the low 90-point range with great expectation with age...

Anyone had JL1? Is the profile very different from JL2?[/quote]

Robert,
I like the #1 better.



Category: Juan López Cigars


The Seleccion No. 1 and No. 2 are undeniably the best in the Juan Lopez range and their quality is first class. The No. 2 is a dramatic robusto with a wonderful flavour, combining rich creamy coffee with cedar and earth. Excellent aging potential.


The PCs are great too

[quote=wheelrite]Robert,
I like the #1 better.



Category: Juan López Cigars


The Seleccion No. 1 and No. 2 are undeniably the best in the Juan Lopez range and their quality is first class. The No. 2 is a dramatic robusto with a wonderful flavour, combining rich creamy coffee with cedar and earth. Excellent aging potential.


The PCs are great too[/quote]

I just read that too. but, I don't trust vendor descriptions.

[quote=rfenst]I just read that too. but, I don't trust vendor descriptions.[/quote]

I've bought 3 or 4 boxes of them over the last 4 yrs and have loved them all...

JL No.2 2011 box code was reported to be exceptionally good right out of the box.

You cannot go wrong with either vitola.

Ageing? What's that? 😂 Most of the CC's I've had were relatively young (i.e. purchased and smoked OTT). Can't say I've had a bad one yet for the exception of an ocassional burn issue more than anything...which I guess they could be even better with age. :shrug: Actually, I do have a few brands still sitting around that I picked up 3+ years ago, but that's because I got the full box. Any splits I've done are ALL GONE! 😣 I don't know what it is, but I can't keep 'em around long enough. My box of SCdlH El Principes are getting dangerously low (from a full box 4 years ago). 🤦 JL#2, RASS, Monte #2, PSD4, Boli RC, Boli Gold...ones I've had OTT that were good to exceptional. And those brands in another size would probably be just as delicious.

This has turned out to be quite helpful...

Trinidad Reyes or Monte #5




YOUR opinion?

Monte #2 is very good if that helps any.

[quote=fishinguitarman]Trinidad Reyes or Monte #5




YOUR opinion?[/quote]

Aren;t you a both boy?