Hog,
I don't see your arguements as problems with the school system. I see them as problems with parenting. I am assuming from your posts that you support corporal punishment in schools. I do not. I attended a school that was heavy handed with the spankings, yet still well within the law. I complained for 2 months to my parents. It wasn't until I dropped my pencil during a lecture and said, "Oops, Crap!", and got smacked swiftly across the face for talking while the teacher was talking(in 3rd grade) that my parents finally pulled me out.
I'm not comfortable with school disciplinarians judging what is appropriate use of force. In other schools, school disciplinary actions never scared me. My parents did. I behaved because I knew what the consequences would be. A call from the principle was a cardinal sin in my house hold.
And, I don't think it's fair for the teachers to put this expectation on them. If a student is telling them to "F*** OFF", chances are this same student would respond to violence with more violence themselves. Parents are already being replaced by the internet and television. I don't think replacing parents with teachers will help anything.
So, perhaps the blame falls squarely on the shoulders of mom and dad instead of Mrs. Smith Teacher. Oh wait, I forgot, it's never the parents fault. If it's not music, movies, and/or video games, then their just a product of their environment.
So, if a student is repeatedly causing disturbances and the parents are not responding with proper discipline, what should happen? Simple, remove the student. Tell the parent that schools are educational institutes, not babysitters.
I whole heartily believe that a 'Christian Nation' would make the world a better place. In fact, I think a 'Spiritual Nation' would be Utopia. But, educational institutes are not responsible for the up-bringing of youth.
Hog, I have got to make my way over to the Land of Lincoln. We must discuss things over some smokes.