Worst cigar ever made · Page 3

Free Fall
Auctions

Specials
Auctions

QuickBuy
Auctions

Newly Added
Auctions

Ending Soon
Auctions

Welcome Guest

Forum Terms & Conditions | My Topics

ZRX1200
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#41

Lone Wolf
Bad Frog

eleltea
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#42

Q forgot to mention Professor Sila.

tonygraz wrote:

times ten

QMPASH
Aficionado Topic Starter

10 years ago

#43

Worst cigar I've ever had hands down is a T****sons house blend. I've told the ladies of CBID that ACTUALLY mentioning their name ISN'T a competitor reference because they suck more balls than the Backstreet boys on extasy at a ball sucking contest.

ZRX1200 wrote:

They have a house cigar named after a reptile. That should have served as a waarning.

Edited by user 10 years ago | Reason: Not specified

jjanecka
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#44

Good post noob.

In complete honesty, the late 90s Puros Indios was my absolute favorite cigar.
Something changed since then. Maybe the old man letting junior roll a few. Maybe my taste buds evolved. Maybe production moved to a septic dump.
But the PI of today are not at all similar to the gems from 15 years ago.

tailgater wrote:

Well in my defense, I smoked these back in 2008 when I had about $20 a month to spend on cigars because I was jobless and decided to go back to college for the third time. So it was the best of all the dog rockets. I remember them being not too terrible, perhaps I was just fortunate.

tonygraz
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#45

A friend of mine used to like the old ones, but said the new ones just suck. I smoked a couple of different newer ones and they were not the worst cigars, but certainly nothing I would buy again.

zody
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#46

Blood Moon from a 5er on CBid, I gambled on them for a short smoke it took hours to get the frakkin aftertaste to go away. It smelled like puss and grass clippings.

QMPASH
Aficionado Topic Starter

10 years ago

#47

It appears that The Nasty, Gurkha and Rocky Patel R4 are the winners.

carrite
Enthusiast

10 years ago

#48

Anything by Gurkha is bad — or, more properly, if they make a good cigar, I've never had one and I'm not gonna spend any more time or money looking to see.

I actually ended up tossing an Oliva V yesterday that had an improperly fermented leaf in it — bitter, alkali yuck... I guess it happens to the best every once in a while, I love Vs.

I think the worst non-defective cigar I've had this year is a Graycliff G2. God, that was a flavorless piece of crap...

t

delta1
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#49

Reminds me that a Graycliff with a dark blue label I tried smoking a few years ago was the first unsmokeable cigar I had. Then some Bahias with a plain blue cloth band...those were bad...

Edited by user 10 years ago | Reason: Not specified

bgz
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#50

Last bad cigar I had was the Montecristo Media Noche (was a while ago).

I know some people like them, but it just didn't hit my pallet right at all, I trashed it pretty quickly then grabbed something I like.

It could have been the person I got it from just didn't keep them right, I don't know... it was a bad enough experience I never looked at obtaining more.

I've been pretty picky lately though (especially from hanging out on this board with you guys)... guess it could be that.

Bryan T
Enthusiast

10 years ago

#51

Gurkha Evil. It tunneled badly and tasted like hay and tar.

sd72
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#52

shocking. I can't find the 'mind blown' emoji anywhere, but trust me, poof. Mind blown.

corey sellers
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#53

😣

dharbolt
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#54

Tierra volcan. 'Nuf said

Gaga
Rookie

10 years ago

#55

Brocatus. Nuff said

ZRX1200
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#56

bgz, the only Monte Media Noche that's decent is the robusto, the rest aren't good IMO.

cameroon
Aficionado

10 years ago

#57

bgz, the only Monte Media Noche that's decent is the robusto, the rest aren't good IMO.

ZRX1200 wrote:

1. Your Inbox is full, FWIW

2. Where does your current avatar (Asian lady) come from? A reverse google search reveals nothing. 🙂

madspackler
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#58

The OR Puros Indios was a decent cigar. The current one is dreck. They had a special reserve that was wrapped in burlap. I think it was actually wet burlap. The cigar was bland and slightly acrid, but the stench and flavor imparted by the burlap made the cigar repulsive. If that was the first cigar I had ever smoked, I would have stopped cold in my tracks. Disgusting. Never tried another PI. Ever

QMPASH
Aficionado Topic Starter

10 years ago

#59

madspackler wrote:

About 10 years ago this was a pretty decent cigar.

tonygraz
Herf-A-Holic

10 years ago

#60

Gurkha Evil. It tunneled badly and tasted like hay and tar.

Bryan T wrote:

Had to dig one out that was 2-3 years old and smoked it today. I have noted changes in Gurkha blends in the past and have heard of licensing remakes, so there's no guarantee this is the same cigar. No major problems, not great, not bad. I smoked a couple a couple of years ago and found a post elsewhere where I was undecided about the cigar and the aging hasn't change it any. In all fairness, it was around freezing while I smoked it. Still have 2 more that I'll try under better weather conditions. If I had to make a call today- it would be mediocre.

65

Edited by user 10 years ago | Reason: Not specified

Users browsing this topic

Important Information: