swimbladder
Friday, August 4, 2006 12:54:00 PM
>>My comment about using positive arguments in reverse applies to using the conclusion of post #134 to bolster the statement in post #131; where you propose a negative argument.

You missed the main point of #134. I was trying to point out the difference between "not guilty" vs "innocent". It is this part that bolsters the statement in #131.

Dr Pepperhill
Friday, August 4, 2006 2:37:00 PM
Sorry, but we learned from the Salem witch trials that using spectral evidence in a court of law is incompatible. Your analogy, which I will clarify for you, is the comparison of "not guilty" with "uncertainty over the existence of god," and "innocence" with "there is no god;" which is a false analogy because you are using legal arguments as a premise to come to metaphysical conclusions: which is a type of circular reasoning.

In order to make any progress with this type of argument, one must A. bracket their belief regarding deities or lack of deities, and B. proceed with creation on its own merits.

Simply arguing whether or not there is a god is like endlessly debating how many angels can fit on the head of a pin, where any number will suffice, and no constructive purpose is ever arrived at.

swimbladder
Friday, August 4, 2006 2:56:00 PM
so you agree?
Dr Pepperhill
Friday, August 4, 2006 3:02:00 PM
Yes and no. I agree you can't prove or disprove that invisible blue smurfs will fly out of the Pope's ass next Saturday. I do not agree that such arguments are rational, but are rather circular, and therefore useless for any known purpose.

Now, arguing about faith, cosmology, good vs evil, etc., is where the beef's at.