jpotts
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 8:31:00 PM
"I'm not so sure that the facts will exonerate Bush"

They have thus far.

victor808
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 8:50:00 PM
Jpotts,

""Is there ever an appropriate time to criticize a wartime president then?"

After the war, or after his term in office is over. "

That's not appropriate. What would we do then if things go really bad before either of these things happen? For example (another exaggeration for impact), what would be appropriate if Bush decides to simply set up Hitleresque death camps in Iraq, killing all males between the age of 16 and 35 because they may be terrorists at some time? Should we criticize him then? Or should we support him and save our criticism for the end of his term two years later?

Again, just an exaggeration to point out that a line has to be drawn somewhere.

jpotts
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 9:07:00 PM
First, the United States of America is not Nazi Germany or Stalinist Russia. In order for the extremes that you cited to exist, that would mean:

1) The population of the United States would allow such things. As you can see, no one in the government these days can keep a secret, it seems.

2) All of Congress would have to be in the bag for the president. That hasn't happened...ever.

3) The people in the military, who have sworn an oath to protect this country, and abide by the conventions of war would have to turn their backs on that oath.

4) The Vice-president, the executive staff, the director of the FBI, CIA, and thr Joint Chiefs of Staff would have to be in on this type of ploy.

5) Everyone involved, including the citizenry of the United States, would have to have lost their soul.

Last time I checked, your average American citizen had a conscience.

The power of a strong representitive government lies within the hands of the voters, which is why, up until now, the country has been relatively stable.

jpotts
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 9:08:00 PM
So, in short, I reject the argument.
rugrunner
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 9:40:00 PM
Victor, you don't like discussing things with me because I make you feel stupid.

I said if you support the candidates that are all about gay marriage they are the same candidates that are stabbing the troops in the back. Therefore when you pat yourself on the back for supporting your gay friends remember that you are helping the same people stab our troops and the country in the back.

I thought I made that clear (several times) so that even you could grasp it.

victor808
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 9:54:00 PM
Rug, I don't like arguing with you because you never have a leg to stand on. Do I need to bring up our last argument? I'm still waiting for your fact checking. Here, I'll even post the link so you can go back to the thread and get me the info to back up your wild rants.

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/forum/forum.cfm?action=list&forumID=9&messageDisplay=0000000068818  If you could please sort that one out for me, the I'd be glad to entertain your next wild rant.

victor808
Tuesday, September 26, 2006 10:06:00 PM
Jpotts,

I agree that its a farfetched extreme. But that was the entire point. If the government goes out of control (assuming that your points 2 & 4 actually did occur) and the military follows their lead (again, for example only), then it would be up to the citizenry to cry foul.

I'm not saying that any of this would occur, but note that you did include points 1 and 5 in your reasons why it wouldn't. Under your argument, 1 and 5 should not be allowed to occur until the end of the president's term. So, lets say for argument's sake (since you did include them in reasons why this extreme example wouldn't occur), that the citizenry do stop this make-believe atrocity. If that is appropriate, wouldn't it also be appropriate for them to voice concern on a slightly lesser atrocity? What about a much lesser? What if it isn't an atrocity, but just a dumb move?

What I'm getting at is that even within your refutation of my extreme example, you pointed out that there is a time when the citizens are allowed to stop a war gone hideously wrong. The question just becomes where do we draw that line? And has that line been crossed already in some people's mind?

I'm cashin in. g'night jpotts.