Our company uses Six Sigma it can work in the right situation. However where I work we are in partnership with other companies and their management philosophies are in a word, different. That said, I had an old manager that came to town for a seminar. During dinner, we were discussing old times and he asked if I had heard about the company adopting Six Sigma. I said I had, so he asked what I thought about it. I told him in the past when we adopted such programs as Quality Teams, Employee Empowerment, Team Building, etcetera, I was always in the front row thinking this is great stuff. However, there was always an older guy in the back arms folded over his chest muttering, “This is BS, just another management flavor of the month. It will all blow over when they figure out they don’t need as many managers.” Then I said, and now… I AM that guy, little did I know he was here for Six Sigma Black Belt training. Well, that ended the conversation for the evening.
Dilbert had a series of cartoons that about sum it up. Quality teams, participative management, employee empowerment, team building the list of ‘revolutionary’ programs goes on and on. They are almost all good to one degree or another.
You will know when the sun is setting on such a program when some management report requires you to credit the new program. Saving money even though it had minimal or no impact on the actual savings or you really didn’t save anything but must show the program is working because management is expecting it.