It's just XP on steroids with fancy Mac-like graphics. I don't see how it's worth the $200-$400 for an upgrade. Apparently, a lot of others don't either judging by the first day turnout.
I beta tested Vista from Beta 2 to RC2 and while it looks pretty, there was quite a few annoying quirks.
1. It asks permission from everything like opening a browser to plugging in a flash drive. XP does this automatically.
2. The Start Menu is horrid, it seems like a step backward from XP.
3. Driver support is still very limited to the latest and greatest hardware.
It seems that if you have XP with the latest service packs and updates then it should do everything you'd want it to do and more. I have a free upgrade version coming from Dell since I just bought a laptop but I won't be installing it until I absolutely have to.
I know this sounds a lot like when XP came out and everyone said Windows 2000 was perfect at the time, but there were some huge differences between 2000 and XP. The only major change for Vista besides the UI is DirectX 10. But if you're not a gamer then that won't matter to you.
Just like every release of Windows, people should wait until a new Windows version proves itself before pulling the trigger on upgrade or installation and driver support becomes readily available.