Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:39:00 PM
You taking bathroom pictures of him too? yikes
erkwgz
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:44:00 PM
He is gettin his nip tweaked.

No bathroom shots for me.

But I will be glad to top one for you Stefan.

pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:44:00 PM
don't do it... white owls
Sfraun04
Saturday, February 3, 2007 10:50:00 PM
PLEASE don't do it...swisher sweets
pabloescabar
Saturday, February 3, 2007 11:06:00 PM
he went and done it again the sick bastid
erkwgz
Saturday, February 3, 2007 11:07:00 PM
Youy know it.
dwalt10048
Saturday, February 3, 2007 11:50:00 PM
Wow, I watch a little reality tv and this is what I get...LOL by the way, I may post a pic someday, I'm prettier than all you Beotches!

Wanna see my pic, go to the Cfest website. Year 2 I'm the guy holding 2 boxes of my winning gars.

jpotts
Sunday, February 4, 2007 6:41:00 AM
My take?

As with all reality shows, they want someone that brings tension into the environment. It's not good TV unless they're conflict. Marcel was a whiny, catty little suck-up. The producers probably pegged him from the get-go, and the word was that he was to make it through the entire season, strictly for entertainment value.

Don't forget, you only see what the editors WANT you to see. The whole point is to lead you in one direction, and then "shock" you with a different outcome - moreso in some episodes then in others.

It was the same way with the last season when what's-her-name got picked over the one guy who only made two dishes instead of three on the next-to-last episode (it sucks when you can't remember the names) - the one where the last three contestants went to Vegas and cooked for Cirque du Souile (sp:?). I went to the TopChef web site and saw a couple of the judges posting their rationalizations for the judgement. Appearently, they took a whole bunch of flack over the decision. The blogs were filled with a bunch of befuddled posters, unable to believe that the "b*tch" got picked for the final round (paraphrasing to some extent here).

All-in-all it made for good TV, and great viewer response. Bravo got what they wanted.

I think Marcel was a pretty good chef (not that I'd be any judge of that), I thought Sam (the tall guy with black hair) was better. He got screwed on the Hawaiin episode. The whole notion that "he didn't cook" a raw fish recipie was just frankly a cop-out, and a way to edge Marcel into the last episode. Of any of those contestants, Marcel would be close to the last when it came to people I'd have to work with (I worked with a guy similar to him in a job once already).

Betty had racked up more wins - some four in all, if I remember correctly - then any of them. Her being dumped, I think, had little to do with her cooking skill. I missed that episode, so take my comments for what they are.

Cigarick
Sunday, February 4, 2007 7:19:00 AM
At first I was rooting for Sam and Elia to make it to the final, but she was a little too whiny and immature (still just a kid despite her education), and Sam turned out to be an arrogant back-stabber. Marcel was by far the most creative--I wanted to taste every one of his dishes. I think his biggest problem was a case of little-guy syndrome, and his cooking skills make it easy for him to over-compensate. I am, however, looking forward to bipping up to L.A. to sample spice-rack Betty's goods. Ahem.
Sfraun04
Sunday, February 4, 2007 8:22:00 AM
There's a big rule with Top Chef behind the scenes, and it's that the producers have no say in who gets eliminated. It's actually in Tom's contract as it was his big demand. You don't ask a respected individual to be a judge on a show if, in the end, only those with "tv personalities" are gonna go on.

The Sam not cooking thing was not the big deal. He used the technique of "maceration" which is exactly how you make ceviche; the acid "cooks" the raw product. It's considered a cooking technique by definition. Still, Marcel and Ilan best interpreted the competition. Elia completely screwed it up by masking any Hawaiian influence, and Sam did nothing dynamic. Betty was never going to make it far enough.

Cigarick, everyone has that kind of attitude and what not. Due to the way they edited the episodes, some didn't seem like it til later (Ilan was more quiet until the final 6, then they put him in the spotlight).

Gotta give credit to Michael!!!!