andytv
  • andytv
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 11:46:00 AM
Can you describe for me, in detail, the advantages that your Weber smoker has over, say.....and electric type (like a Bradley Smoker) or an offset box charcoal type.

I am keen on replacing my smoker within a year or two.

I really want to discuss this with someone who has used one extensively.

jpotts
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 11:49:00 AM
I'm sorry.
MACS
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 11:58:00 AM
^Yes, you are pretty sorry, but what does that have to do with smokers?
teedubbya
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 12:07:00 PM
That would be tough for me because I've never used anything but, and to be honest I would get a Big Green Egg if I had the cash.

http://www.virtualweberbullet.com/ 

It is my bible. I printed every page of every cookbook and bound them into three volumes. It literally not only tells you some recipe ideas etc, but gives you an idea of times/temperatures etc.

Ok back to your quesiton.....

I bought the WSM after doing a cost benefit analysis. I got mine under $200. If I had a lot to spend I would definitely do the big green egg.

The WSM is amazing at holding constant heat and extremely efficient. If you use the minion method you can get well over 12 hours of constant heat without adding more coal (assuming right conditions). I actually have gone as long as 17 hours without adding fuel.

The minion method consists of loading hardwood charcoal and your hardwood of choice into the ring and adding one chimney of lit charcoal on top or in the middle, then closing everything up. It keeps lighting the rest of the way. This is not the way Wever tells you to use it.

Some get concearned about funky tastes from the coal continually lighting but everyone at that site has declared that nonsens and Jim Minion has won tons of contests using the method.

From the virtual bullet:

"The cooker is comprised of three sections--a charcoal bowl, where the charcoal briquettes and smoke wood reside; a cooking section containing a water pan, two cooking grates, and an access door; and a classic Weber domed lid.

Two cooking grates (17-1/2" and 17") provide plenty of space to cook large quantities of barbecue--for example, two large briskets, or four Boston butts, or six whole chickens, or eight slabs of baby back ribs--and are triple chrome plated for easy cleanup and durability. The water pan shields the meat from the coals, creating an indirect heat source that's essential when cooking barbecue. The water in the pan also moderates the cooker temperature and provides a moist cooking environment which benefits certain cuts of meat.

Temperature control is one of the most important aspects of creating great barbecue, and the near air-tight design of the WSM allows you to maintain the perfect 225-275°F temperature for eight to ten hours or longer with minimal effort. Three adjustable vents in the charcoal bowl and one adjustable vent in the lid give precise control over fuel combustion. With other competitive products, poor fitting parts and leaky designs have you constantly "babysitting" the fire to make sure it's not too hot or too cold. With the WSM, you can cook for many hours without making any adjustments at all.

I added a draft control unit because I am an asshat who wants sleep. It is awsome. I used furnace tape to tape up all the vents and the access door. You do not use water with the draft system you simply foil the pan. Water is a temperature control (heat sink) thing not a meat moistener like some think.

I have a 2 pit thermometers (one conrolls the draft unit the other is remote and will ring an alarm when the pit goes out of my parameters) and 4 remote meat thermometers.

It looks and sounds like Darth Vader but I can literally set it up at midnight, smoke and drink til I want to go to bed, sleep in and have brisket and pulled pork for dinner the next evening.

The draft control is not necessary but its fun.

I guess the short answert is it is simple, inexpensive, consistent, and bullet proof. The Big Green egg is even more so (except the inexpensive part).

As for off sets, electrics etc..... I would love a nice (expensive) offest. The problem is you really need a decent one which prices it out of the Weber range. If I was going to do it I would have to spend a lot of $$ or make one myself.

My buddy has an electri pellet fed machine that he uses. He loves it. My food taste better, even he admitts that.

Hows that for a pottsian reply?

jpotts
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 1:11:00 PM
MACS(SW):

"Yes, you are pretty sorry, but what does that have to do with smokers?"

That was actually read meat for teedubbya. However, because he's been huffing gluesticks as of late, he was not fast enough on the draw as you were.

jpotts
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 1:24:00 PM
teedubbya:

Actually, at Lowes, they have a decent charcoal grill that you can buy an offset box for. It's actually quite solid, and the whole rig - including the offset - will run you less than $200.00.

http://www.lowes.com/lowes/lkn?action=productDetail&productId=44754-000001646-2121&lpage=none 

My question is, with the entire thing sealed up, how do you get any smoke flavor out of it? The smoke needs to circulate somehow, and that requires an air outlet of some sort.

And you're somewhat right about the water pan, although for the electrics it is strictly used for moisture. But it doesn't work well - stuff will dry out if I let the waterpan try and moistureize the meat.

By the way - simply because I want to show-off - here's the link to my new grill:

http://www.lowes.com/lowes/lkn?action=productDetail&productId=242267-82210-463268107&lpage=none 

Thunder.Gerbil
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 4:19:00 PM
Oh great, a grill-waving contest...
teedubbya
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 4:32:00 PM
One of the vent holes contains a fan controlled by temp. It stokes the coals/hardwood

Enough smoke escapes to keep the wood lit and to smoke properly but not enough to waste fuel.

I will put my WSM up against that offset smoker at lowes any day. Seriously..... if you go to the american royal you will see lots of green eggs and wsms, lots of high end smokers, but not too many cheapo off sets. Not sure why.

Thunder.Gerbil
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 4:56:00 PM
"if you go to the american royal you will see lots of green eggs and wsms, lots of high end smokers, but not too many cheapo off sets. Not sure why."

Someone I used to know got really into the BBQ competitions and he was saying that it was exactly like you said - the offsets aren't bad, but they use a lot of fuel and when you start smoking the food Saturday evening to be judged Sunday afternoon, having to get up every two hours to add wood to the BBQ to complete an 18-hour roast is a MF.

Thunder.Gerbil
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 4:57:00 PM

TEN!!!!!!!!!

andytv
  • andytv
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 5:24:00 PM
good info.........lemme digest this.

for me it is a conflict......the offset box is a great smoker but requires a lot of attention, with less than nominal temp control, but a good time drinking for the duration.

If I upgrade, I am trading the magic of spending a day tending the grill for a more hands off approach.

I don't know if i am prepared to do that......to take the drunken soul out of the equation.