This Edwards-Coulter thing pissed me off this morning.
So, if you haven't heard, Mrs. Edwards called in to an interview with Coulter to publicly request that she stop making personal attacks on politicians, Edwards and his family in specific.
Now, I dislike Coulter. But in all fairness, this seemed to be a pretty straightforward move by Mrs. Edwards. If someone is doing something that you don't like, you ask them to stop.
Here's a partial transcript:
E: I’m calling — you know, in the south, when someone does something that displeases us, we want to ask them politely to stop doing it. I would like to ask Ann Coulter to — if she wants to debate on issues, on positions — we certainly disagree with nearly everything she said on your show today — but it is quite another matter for these personal attacks. The things that she has said over the years, not just about John but about other candidates, lowers our political dialogue precisely at the time that we need to raise it. So I want to use the opportunity, which I don’t get much because Ann and I don’t hang out with the same people…
C: I don’t have enough money.
E: …to ask her politely stop the personal attacks.
C: Okay, so I made a joke, let’s see, six months ago, and as you point out, they have been raising money off of it for six months since then.
M: But this is yesterday morning, what you said about him.
C: I didn’t say anything about him, actually, either time.
E: But that — Ann, Ann, you know that’s not true, and once more, this has been going on for some time.
C: And I don’t mind you trying to raise money. It’s better this than giving $50,000 speeches to the poor just to use my name on the webpages. But as for a debate with me, yeah, sure. Yeah, we’ll have a debate.
E: I’m asking you politely to stop, to stop personal attacks –
C: How about you stop raising money on your web page then? No, you don’t have to because I don’t mind.
E: I did not start with that. You had a column a number of years ago where you suggested — wait till I finish talking please…
C: Okay, the wife of a presidential candidate is calling in asking me to stop speaking.
M: Let her finish the point. Let her finish the point.
C: You’re asking me to stop speaking? “Stop writing your columns. Stop writing your books.”
M: Ann, please.
E: You had a column several years ago which made fun of the moment of Charlie Dean’s death and suggested that my husband had a bumper sticker on the back of his car saying, “Ask me about my dead son.” This is not legitimate political dialogue.
C: This is now three years ago.
E: It debases political dialogue. It drives people away from the process. We can’t have a debate about the issues.
C: Yeah, why isn’t John Edwards making this call?
M: Well, do you want to respond? We’ll end the conversation.
E: I haven’t talked to John about this call. I’m making the call as a mother. I’m the mother of that boy who died. My children participate — these young people behind you are the age of my children. You’re asking them to participate in a dialogue that is based on hatefulness and ugliness instead of on the issues, and I don’t think that’s serving them or this country very well.
[Applause]
M: Thank you very much Elizabeth. You wanna respond? You have all the time in the world to respond.
C: I think we heard all we need to hear. The wife of a presidential candidate is asking me to stop speaking. No.
M: No, she asked you to stop being so negative to people individually.
...............................................
So. A request was made, and she deflected it. She did NOT address the request, but simply attacked those who made the request. Here is a partial list of appropriate responses:
"Your husband is a public figure, running for public office. As such, his personal life is open to attack"
"I am not trying to raise the level of debate in this country, my job is to entertain people by saying obnoxious things"
"Your request has been noted, but for my own personal reasons, I am going to continue with my current methods"
But instead, coulter essentially changes the question. She first says :"you're making money off my personal attacks", which is irrelevant to the request; then moves on to "at least I'm not a shyster charging huge amounts to speak", also irrelevant to the request; then she settles on "she's asking me to stop speaking, stop writing columns" which, while relevant, is a gross alteration of the request.
Fine. Coulter is an idiot. I can accept that. Watching anyone argue with her feels like watching high school kids argue (or those girls on Charm School). But what REALLY REALLY REALLY irritated me was the commentary about this on the news.
When asked what he thought about everything Pat Robertson said something to the extent of: "Well, as we can see here, Coulter is clearly an intelligent woman, and a great debater. She obviously is able to hold her own in these situations.."
What is our world coming to when diversionary tactics and irrelevant arguments count as "good debate".