RICKAMAVEN
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 12:14:00 PM
hell with C&P, i can describe it myself.

a man is on trial for rape. the defense lawyer has convinced the judge that the use of the word rape is not to be used in this case as it is prejudicial.

it follows that a murderer can be tried for murder, as long as the word is not used.

are you kidding me.

if i were the prosecution, i would say the man is accused of sticking his **** in her vagina, without permission, and probably used his **** in her mouth as a toothbrush, or perhaps using his **** to check her prostate.

jpotts
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 12:34:00 PM
What are they going to call it? Unintentional, forcible penile penetration?
ScottHar
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 1:11:00 PM
Genital trespassing?

ScottHar

Mrs.Tank
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 1:14:00 PM
violation.

He violated her.

Of course, that word is awful close to violence.

Mrs.Tank
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 1:18:00 PM
The da should define the word according to the dictionary. If that is the crime that was allegedly committed, then the word should be allowed.

pacman357
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 1:54:00 PM
Some things that seem odd in daily life or common dialogue can carry heavy connotations and problems in court, and especially a trial.

For example, I routinely object during a trial to the use of the term "victim". Victim means that someone has already proven a crime has been committed. "Complaining witness" or at least "alleged victim" is much better, except in the case of a homicide, where the decedent isn't doing much "complaining".

To understand whether the judge's ruling makes sense, you not only have to know the facts of the case and the context in which the motion and ruling arose, but you also have to know something about trial practice. We try to clean up trials a little bit, since some errors can result in reversal on appeal.

You and I all pay for these mistakes in court costs, attorney costs, etc. So, in a sense, trying to be a little careful in trial is about prudent use of resources to conduct court matters. And what some times seems silly to people not involved in the process and not in on the particulars of the trial may make perfect sense to those participating in the trial.

I realize that this particular instance appears to defy common sense. And for all I know, the ruling could be completely absurd. It could also be brilliant. I don't know enough of the trial and the case to know one way or the other. The bottom line is that judging an action from outside of the case, trial and system based upon common language use and everyday logic is to judge the action without the salient facts.

nine999
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 2:31:00 PM
^friggin lawyerspeak....

nine

EI
  • EI
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 2:45:00 PM

For example, I routinely object during a trial to the use of the term "victim". Victim means that someone has already proven a crime has been committed. "Complaining witness" or at least "alleged victim" is much better, except in the case of a homicide, where the decedent isn't doing much "complaining".

Ok you come upon a scene in a city park and see someone with a gunshot wound and you would not call them a victim because you didn't see someone shoot the gun.

now you know a crime was committed because it is unlawful to discharge a weapon in city park and it is apparent that this person did not shoot himself

you may not know who the criminal is but you do know who the victim is.. the one that is bleeding from a gunshot wound. I would call that person a victim unless it was a lawyer than I would call him and alledged human

pacman357
Tuesday, July 17, 2007 2:45:00 PM
^My point exactly.