MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, August 17, 2007 3:44:00 PM
The NFL's current salary cap structure and collective bargaining agreement do NOT allow for salary cap relief, even if a player dies.

Denver lost 2 players this offseason to tragedies...

Now the Atlanta Falcons are going to be cap-strapped because Vick IS going to jail, and when he comes back, NO NFL team is going to want that public relations nightmare.

My question to you is this: Do you think the NFL should allow for cap relief in cases of death, serious injuries or other unforeseeable situations such as the Vick case??

My thoughts are that they should. Why should the team (and the fans) have to suffer because of stuff like that which just can't be predicted (for the most part).

rfenst
Friday, August 17, 2007 3:48:00 PM
Agreed.
Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, August 17, 2007 3:50:00 PM
So with the deceased players, was the remainder of their contract paid out to the family or other designee?

Will Michael Vick still be recieving his contract salary or are they terminating the contract or suspending it while he serves time?

nine999
Friday, August 17, 2007 3:56:00 PM
let's take it in two parts. first, the death of a player.

no. the players salary should be removed from the teams cap. it's just not something foreseeable. nor is it fair to the team. ESPECIALLY if the player dies off season.

as for vick? well, teams go through some serious research on players to make sure they are nfl caliber (cough cough). take randy moss. everyone knew he had some serious skills, yet dropped to 17th pick. also, teams include clauses in a players contract that keep them from earning some monies if they violate team or nfl rules. so i think this is one that should probably stay.

but while we're on the subject of the cap, i see a few other changes that i believe make sense.

first off. the rookie clause. i don't think ANY rookie should make more than say, 5 mil his rookie year. contracts should state that all bonuses and goals should total 5 mil(post season would be the exception).

as for tenured players, maybe have a system that a player salary with at least 7 years of service should only count for 80% of the cap, 10 years or more, 70%, or something like that. this would keep players on a team as opposed to being tradeded due to cap reasons. joe montana may have retired playing his entire career with the niners.

?

nine

nine999
Friday, August 17, 2007 3:58:00 PM
let me expand just a bit...

"as for tenured players, maybe have a system that a player salary with at least 7 years of service ON THE SAME TEAM should only count for 80% of the cap, 10 years or more, 70%, or something like that"

Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:02:00 PM
^^^

You're really thinking hard about MACS question aren't you?

I can smell the smoke from here.

Oh, no wait, that's a just a car fire, nevermind.

MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:05:00 PM
TG - the YEARLY salaries are not paid out when a player dies or gets cut, or goes to jail, no.

But his signing bonus (which he gets ALL up front) is prorated over the number of remaining years.

To wit: Lets say vick got 36 million in guaranteed money for his ten year contract. He has 3 years left. The Falcons are on the hook for 3.6 million each year for the next 3 years. So essentially, they lose 3.6 million in cap money for 3 years that he ain't even playing.

Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:16:00 PM
Ok.

Then I'd have to say that if they are writing a check for it, no, no relief sorry.

If you start handing out privelages and vouchers for "hardship" you're going to have to define what qualifies and what doesn't, and that is just going to create arguments and legal problems. "NO" is very concise answer that leaves no room for argument or debate. "No, except under the following circumstances..." Now you're going to have someone creating a legal stink because they think their reasons qualify even though the rules say they don't.

Who do you think is going to suck up the legal fees for that? Yup. You, the fan.

If you don't pay it, then you don't count it. If you do, you do. It's that simple.

Oh, and one more thing....

Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:16:00 PM

1001 !!!!!!!!!

donutboy2000
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:22:00 PM
Atlanta owner Arthur Blank likely would not let a felon convicted of dogfighting run his team. The question is how Blank would handle Vick's exodus. Cutting him would be the easy thing to do, but terminating Vick's contract could disqualify the franchise from claiming more than $22 million of signing bonus proration.

Vick has three years left on his contract, including this season. If he is unable to play in any of those seasons because of legal action, the Falcons can make a legal case that he failed to fulfill his contract, then claim the annual $7.5 million of signing bonus proration. Vick signed a 10-year, $130 million contract, and the Falcons can't go back and get money he earned by playing. But it makes good business sense to go after the money he collected in signing bonus even if it means keeping him on the roster while he serves any prison sentence and a possible NFL suspension.

ESPN

blackfoot11
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:47:00 PM
i agree with post #9
MACS
  • MACS
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Friday, August 17, 2007 4:56:00 PM
DB, they may get it back, but it STILL counts against the cap.
teedubbya
Friday, August 17, 2007 5:02:00 PM
death yes, vick no.... unless he is executed
blackfoot11
Friday, August 17, 2007 5:07:00 PM
there are some good points here. i think t.g. summed it up though, with the privelage thing.

i think that if a player dies in the off season, it shouldn't count against the cap. but then what happens if a player offs himself. suicide clause? there's another can of worms opened.

plinytheelder
Friday, August 17, 2007 5:24:00 PM
If the player dies, of natural causes or is murdered like Darrent Williams was, his salary shouldn't count against the cap.

Michael Vick? His salary SHOULD count against the Teams Cap. He appears to have broken the law (Yeah, Yeah, he's not guilty until proven guilty) and if convicted, his should count against.

My reasoning is this. Do you think NO ONE on the team knew what he was doing?

NO ONE?

Someone knew what he was doing, whether it was a player or someone in the Teams management.

If they didn't come forward, and advise him (with the NFL playing a part in it, albeit quietly outside of the media) that it has to stop immediately, then the Team should be penalized his salary cap number.

Who was the RB from Nebraska (Phillips maybe?) that was signed by a team after being charged with domestic violence in School.

When he inevitably goes to jail for committing a crime, do you think the team shouldn't be penalized for drafting him???

There has to be a precedent set SOMEWHERE.

If all it takes is committing a serious crime (I did not have sex with that woman, Miss Lewinsky) and the player has a large salary cap number due to an excessively large signing bonus, the team could rat him out to the Police and get his number absolved.

Just my $.02 (with inflation, now worth a $.05)

burgess_b
Friday, August 17, 2007 9:41:00 PM
i think yes on both counts...tragedies are forgiveable in ALL things, i believe, so a death already hurts a team--mentally and physically (strength of team), so it should not also hurt it financially.

the vick thing is tough, but he is not injured and sitting on the bench, he is an idiot. the team took risks (with MOSS, et al.)--a pick, money, everything...they should not be on the hook for their behavior, as well. bottom line is you cannot CONTROL people!

seaborn
Friday, August 17, 2007 10:59:00 PM
When a team loses, cuts,or trades a player they are pretty much saddled with the signing bonus that has already been awarded to the player. The player may receive all the money up front or get a portion and the rest paid out over the term of his contract, but the money is considered paid and counts against the cap. When a player has been traded, his new team picks up his contract and may pay some of the bonus due the player or renegotiate a new one. The league may review and asign some of prorated b-money to the new team's cap lessening the old teams liability (usually for the large bonuses paid out to top players in big contracts that seldom get traded).

The NFL is a business. Even the players now treat it as such, or most of them, anyway. Losing a player(s) due to injury or in the extreme, a loss of life, is an inherent risk just like a risk in any other business. Some teams are more prudent and try to avoid risks that may end up detrimental to the team by passing on certain individuals in the draft or free agency as Nine stated.

Character issues have been brought front and center by Goodell's new policy on player behavior. IMO the best thing that has happened in sports in a long time. Some teams are going to be punished, ala Titans and Bengals, for not keeping a lid on or dumping their troubled players. Goodell doesn't want the NFL to go the route of the NBA where 25% of the players have become punks. Keep a good but troubled player without helping him solve his problems, he gets suspended, you're still stuck with his cap hit. Either way, the NFL does its own investigations and they are very thorough. Peter Gent's "North Dallas Forty" is a good example based on his own experience and that was a long time ago.

Which brings us to Vick. I haven't heard the talking heads on TV say anything about it in the last couple weeks, but now the D.A. is threatening to bring a indictment for violation of the RICO Act if Vick doesn't cop a plea. They didn't hit him with a gambling or racketeering charge yet, but you know damn will the NFL is fully investigating it and they won't treat it lightly. Even if Vick were to be exhonerated the NFL would slap him with a lengthy suspension, if not a lifetime ban. Just ask Art Schlister. Anything that stinks of gambling is cause for alarm in the NFL. They don't want a scandal like the NBA is going through now.

Enjoy the season, BOTL!

dwalt10048
Saturday, August 18, 2007 4:05:00 AM
I'm not sure how the cap works in football, but you damn sure shouldn't be penalized for guys who violate their contracts. I think that should be the deciding factor. If you viloate your written contract, you're gone, and don't count against the cap. In the Falcon's case, they are screwed, because the timing of this doesn't allow them to go out and get someone to QB their team in time for the season.

Of course I also think that citizens shouldn't be penalized for paying taxes that benefit those that violate their "contract" ie legal citizenship. But that's for another thread.

DrMaddVibe
Saturday, August 18, 2007 5:19:00 AM
Sport vs Business...its almost as much fun as the Heredity vs Environment debate.

The sports world made a deal with the devil to allow the thug/ghetto players into NCAA sports and eventually trickle into the professional arena. Did anyone for one second think that because you gave these poor underprivileged yet skilled athletes more fame and more money that they could "clean up" their gutter upbringing? Now the sports world is fighting in EVERY sport to clean up its act, but its too late. The barn door was left open for too long. Kids look up to those "Jerseys" and want to be them. Even if it means starting an illegal gambling ring, murdering, raping, taking drugs (even steroids!), hanging out in gang affiliated night clubs kids are still wanting to be the "jersey".

Its time for institues of higher learning to take the right moves to remove the thugs from their programs. If it means sacrificing National Titles...tough. Their goal is to have an educated man enter society not promote a punkass gang banger into the professional arena. Its also our job as fans to stand up and not take the crap that they're dishing out. They only listen to the sound of their pocketbooks, so don't give them the money they want and they'll come runnig to fix the problems.

Trust me on this one.

Charlie
Saturday, August 18, 2007 5:24:00 AM
I think all rookie salaries for the first year should be a flat amount...500,000 per yr to 1.5M.....with nominal signing bonuses of between 1 to 4 M depending on draft ranking!

Relief for dead players yes, for Vick NO!

Charlie