1. Lighter. Your biggest problem is it's frackin' cold. First order of bidness would be to get a fire going using whatever available materials. If you've ever tried to start one rubbing sticks together, you'd know the lighter is a godsend. You probably also have injured people, and if shock is a concern, you want to get them warm ASAP. Once they go into shock, especially in that cold, you can lose them in a hurry.
2. Steel wool. It actually burns, and the sparks created by the flint (oh nos, you didn't bring a torch style, did you) will help ignite the SW.
3. Clothes. Can be used to keep survivors warm, and extra strips can also be used to help start the fire. Steel wook burns, but not for long. Plus the clothes will be necessary at that low temp unless your fire is the size of a small home.
4. Crisco. Can help start the fire, protect your skin against the cold, can be used to help make metal shiny and signal (assuming you didn't bring your Boy Scout survival kit which should also have a signal mirror, D'oh!). It can also be used to make a small candle or heat source if someone can't be close to the fire, and can be used in cooking if you catch or trap anything. Finally, the empty can can be used in many ways, not the least of which is melting water to drink (you pound down fistfuls of snow at that temp, and you'll freeze from the inside and that outside).
5. Canvas. Can be used to help construct a tent or lean-to, cover people, protect against the outside elements if you have a partial shelter such as a plane wreck, fuel for the fire if necessary, and if you douse it with the crisco, you could make a nice smokey signal fire if search and rescue flies overhead.
6. Axe. Let me axe you dis. How you gonna cut firewood wit out it? You can also use it to help construct a shelter with the canvas, cutting branches for poles.
7. Chocolate. Any good Boy Scout knows these are a decent source of calories and energy. Not great, but better than nothing. You'll need that to find someo protein and carbos to survive.
8. Newspapers. Fuel for the fire, and insulation to wrap or protect persons from the ground. Can also be wrapped around your feet to try to keep them from freezing. Extremeties are the first area to suffer frostbite, and once you get it, you begin dying of hypothermia if you can't stop the process soon.
9. The .45. You can use it to signal aircraft, searchers on foot, and hopefully something to kill and eat that doesn't go by the name "Bob" since you really don't want to eat the pilot, who is starting to look a little frozen and he'd be tough to cut up.
10. Whiskey. Fuel to help start the fire if need be, plus it does keep a person warm to a point so long as you don't get so drunk you go wandering out in the cold, away from your fire and shelter.
11. Compass. It may help to know where you are at as far as sunrise, where searches might be coming from, etc. Probably marginal help if someone is stupid enough to try to walk that far in that cold, however. Also, if you can work out some line out of the clothes or vines, you can break it open and fish, chopping a hole in whatever body of water you are near, and use the compass needle as a hook. Might be a good idea to do that soon so no one gets the idea to try to walk for help.
12. Plastic Map. May also encourage foolish bravery. You could at least try to use it to cover ground, wrap a foot or help start the fire.
There, now raise your hand if YOU are an Eagle Scout!
Troop 853, 1981.
BTW, I have a tougher survival test.
Find my ex. Marry her. Knowing you don't want to go to prison, and believing suicide is a sin that will condemn you to Hell, last a year without killing either of you.