Hog,
Something just occured to me while I was writing that last post about how the output drives work in the older video chipsets.
Check your "Refresh Rate".
You can find it under "Display Properties", "Settings", "Advanced" and it will be in there on one of the tabs somewhere (it varies by chipset software).
Change it either up or down one "notch", see what happens.
Here comes the science...
Basically, in a lot of cases of the older chipsets, certain refresh rates would cause a signal voltage drop on the output. Your monitor interperts these lower voltages as a darker picture. Setting the refresh rate to something less buggy, causes your signal to go back to 1V where it belongs.