victor808
Saturday, November 3, 2007 1:00:00 PM
Guys. I'm sure most of you have a father that at one point in time said to you these very wise, and always true words: "Nothing in life is free".

This is actually true on so many levels in life. It can be seen in physics, biology, but I want you guys to think of the way this applies in economics.

I've been thinking a bit about some people's bitching about the costs of illegal immigrants. And while I am NOT advocating illegal immigration, I do feel that any argument really should be based in truth, not in emotional catchphrases.

So, lets think about these catchphrase concepts:

"They come into our country and don't pay any taxes!"

It is the rare illegal that pays no taxes. Some may pay fewer than you, but lets look at them.

1) Property taxes. Anyone pays this, whether they are legal or illegal. So, any home-owning illegal is actually paying for their local services.

2) Sales taxes. Again, everyone pays this (if it exists in your state).

3) Income taxes (state and federal). This one is trickier, and depends on how they are employed. If the illegal is paid under the table - cash, then both they AND THEIR EMPLOYER are avoiding paying income taxes. Something to note, this is likely NOT common, for a few reasons: a) requires cash in hand; b) sends up a red flag for any tax audits of the company.

The most common situation is that an illegal immigrant gets a hold of a social security number and uses that be paid based on. This means that their employer is certainly being taxed on their wages and THEY are also being taxed.

"They are taking away all our jobs!"

Yes. Yes they are. But that's capitalism, baby! As long as you, as a shopper buy things based on price, then the manufacurer will buy their labor based on price! Look at it this way, at least this way the manufacturing stays in the country. Otherwise it will just be outsourced to China.

"They are costing us Bajillions of dollars!"

I bet if a smart man were to take all the variables into account, he would find that they aren't costing us anything. Do you know why? Because nothing in life is free. This applies to us and to them.

Money is just being shifted around. Illegals come here and work for barely anything. They DO take resources in the form of local schools, and local hospitals. But what you are forgetting is that they also BRING resources to the table. Dirt cheap labor.

So yes, a small portion of your local taxes is being spent on illegal immigrants. But guess what? Because of the illegal immigrants, a lot of your goods and services are marginally cheaper. Nothing is free.

If we made all the illegal immigrants disappear today, yes, there would be lower burden on the schools and ERs at the border towns, but think of how the labor rate would change for a lot of the goods you purchase. Suddenly, instead of paying illegal immigrants almost nothing, growers/manufacturers have to pay a LOT more, if they even decide to keep the operations in the US. That cost just gets passed on to the consumer. So, instead of higher taxes, your fruit goes up in price, your services go up in price. You're going to pay for it one way or another.

Again, I'm not advocating anything, one way or another. I just want people to think rationally about the arguments before screaming a lot of emotional, inaccurate statements.

RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, November 3, 2007 1:13:00 PM
1. Author: victor808

you are appealing for rational judgment to a group of people who want to "stay the course," bomb iran, stop any increase in funding for child care, and believe bush is sane.

you must be as loony as i am.

Gene363
Saturday, November 3, 2007 1:19:00 PM
Re 2

Don't forget that ahats that turn every reasonable conversation into an anti Bush rant.

HockeyDad
Saturday, November 3, 2007 1:22:00 PM
THEY TOOK OUR JOBS!
Gene363
Saturday, November 3, 2007 1:43:00 PM
Re 1

A reasonable request.

Whatever the reasoning, they are here illegally and the idea that they have any ‘right’ to be here is a total insult to all the legal immigrants that we are so luckily to have in this country.

I suspect you do not live in a border state. The costs are real and it illegal immigrants take jobs and services intended to take care of our own poor. The lesion the ability of our own workers to find a living wage by diluting the labor market with no questions asked workers.

The idea that they only work sub minimum wage jobs is a myth. They are taking more than ditch digging jobs, in our area many construction dump truck drivers cannot speak a word of English and that is not a minimum wage job. Yes, they may work for less, and because they are illegal the contractor is not carrying insurance on them or the trucks they drive. No problem, you can pay for more for uninsured motorist insurance in case they hit you and return to Mexico. The crooked contractor that hires them undermines the ability of an honest contractor to get work.

Now if an illegal worker uses your SS number be ready to pay income taxes on his wages, at your tax rate. Good luck getting the IRS to believe it was not you earning that pay.

Illegal immigrants break our laws by coming here that makes them criminals. The idea that my next apple may cost more does not change that fact. I would gladly pay the difference if I knew that some guy working to feed his family can get to the local hospital emergency room if he has an accident and not have to wait for 200 illegals to get their regular health care for free.

victor808
Saturday, November 3, 2007 1:50:00 PM
"I would gladly pay the difference if I knew that some guy working to feed his family can get to the local hospital emergency room if he has an accident "

And that is the important distinction. I have no problem with either side of the argument really. And I really don't know what a good solution is. I'm just always pissed off when people choose a side based off alarmist and incorrect statements.

My whole point is that it's essentially a zero-sum game. The money goes out one way or another. Now, I see no problem with a person saying that they'd rather pay the money to a legal worker. As long as they recognize that they'll pay that money one way or another. 🙂

HockeyDad
Saturday, November 3, 2007 2:10:00 PM
We just need to make them all legal immediately by supporting President George W Bush's amnesty plan. It is time for Congress to get off it butt.

With over 320 million illegals currently in the U.S. we need to go ahead and get them all documented as z-visa holders so we can begin the process of flushing out the 100 million that are actually convicted felons in their home countries and ship those home.

Homebrew
Saturday, November 3, 2007 2:14:00 PM
^ Good response Gene363,

and I agree with you.

They do dilute the labor market, and as a small buisness owner I probably benefit from it, in being able to hire LEGAL employees, at a lower rate because they have to compete with illegal laborers for jobs. It is particulary tough for folks in a more rural area, as there are fewer jobs to begin with.

I think the illegal immigration problem is fixable. The answer lies in ridged standards of identification, and criminal charges against those who hire illegal labor. I have laid this argument out before, and don't feel like describing my arguement in detail once again, but you get the gist of where I am going with this. Quit blaming the illegals, and start blaming those who hire them. If you were in the shoes of the illegal alien, and had to break the law to support your family, you would do it too. Especially if there were plenty of jobs available, and very lax enforcement of immigration laws.

But would you be willing to hire an illegal alien, if you faced a felony rap, which included losing the right to vote, own firearms, and other things most citizens take for granted???

I'll get off my rant.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

donutboy2000
Saturday, November 3, 2007 6:42:00 PM
When will Kalifornia go bankrupt?
RICKAMAVEN
Saturday, November 3, 2007 6:43:00 PM
3. Author: Gene363

every one had an opinion about the topic except you.

your contribution was to call me an asshat. what do you think, assuming you do, that your thought provoking post added to the topic?

it added nothing.

penzt8
Saturday, November 3, 2007 7:16:00 PM
How about the crime factor of illegals? Here's some old stats. I'm sure the numbers have risen. This is just the ones that got caught and served time.

At the local level, in fiscal year 2002, SCAAP reimbursed about 750 local governments for incarcerating about 138,000 criminal aliens.

At the state level, the 50 states received reimbursement for incarcerating about 77,000 criminal aliens in fiscal year 2002 and 47 states received reimbursement for incarcerating about 74,000 in fiscal year 2003.

At the federal level, the number of criminal aliens incarcerated increased from about 42,000 at the end of calendar year 2001 to about 49,000 at the end of calendar year 2004

The majority of criminal aliens incarcerated at the end of calendar year 2004 were identified as citizens of Mexico

We estimate the federal cost of incarcerating criminal aliens— BOP’s cost to incarcerate criminals and reimbursements to state and local governments under SCAAP—totaled approximately $5.8 billion for calendar years 2001 through 2004. (State and local cost were not provided)

5 state prison systems incarcerated about 80 percent of these criminal aliens in fiscal year 2003—Arizona, California, Florida, New York, and Texas.

http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05337r.pdf 

penzt8
Saturday, November 3, 2007 7:25:00 PM
How about the intangible cost to society? Gang activity, drugs, street violence, burglaries, stolen identities. Sure there's enough of that from our own citizens but in the cities most affected by illegal aliens it adds to the problem as indicated by the prison stats.

Over crowding in schools, over crowding in prisons, strain on the medical system, strain on police departments, strain on the social welfare system. It all adds to the cost.

penzt8
Saturday, November 3, 2007 7:33:00 PM
As I said in another post it's a matter of proximity. If cruise ships full of undocumented people started showing up from Africa and Asia wouldn't our government do everything it could to stop them from reaching a US port? Why should Mexicans and Cubans for that matter, get a pass just because they live close?

GreenWolf70
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:12:00 PM
CHEAP LABOR? Isn't that what the whole immigration issue is about?

* Business doesn't want to pay a decent wage.

* Consumers don't want expensive produce.

* Government will tell you Americans don't want the jobs.

But the bottom line is cheap labor. The phrase "cheap labor" is a myth, a farce, and a lie. there is no such thing as "cheap labor." Take, for example, an illegal alien with a wife and five children. He takes a job for $5.00 or $6.00/hour. At that wage, with six dependents, he pays no income tax, yet at the end of the year, if he

files an Income Tax Return, he gets an "earned income credit" of up to $3,200 free.

* He qualifies for Section 8 housing and subsidized rent

* He qualifies for food stamps

* He qualifies for free (no deductible, no co-pay) health care

* His children get free breakfasts and lunches at school

* He requires BI lingual teachers and books

* He qualifies for relief from high energy bills.

* If they are or become, aged, blind or disabled, they qualify for SSI. Once qualified for SSI they can qualify for Medicare.

* All of this is at (our) taxpayer's expense

* He doesn't worry about car insurance, life insurance, or homeowners insurance.

* Taxpayers provide Spanish language signs, bulletins and printed material.

* He and his family receive the equivalent of $20.00 to

$30.00/hour in benefits. Working Americans are lucky to have $5.00 or $6.00/hour left after paying their bills and his.

The American taxpayers also pay for increased crime, graffiti and trash cleanup.

Think IA's are only taking jobs that no Americans want? Visit a construction site and see how many brick masons you see. They have been almost completely wiped out by IA's. Carpenters are another skilled labor class that is quickly disappearing. Illegal Aliens are taking jobs Americans can not afford to take, eroding the wages of those who do have jobs, and stealing resources needed to teach our children the skills to succeed in the workplace.

andytv
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:14:00 PM
The graffiti and trash cleanup is really the worst part!
manko
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:26:00 PM
Greenwolf,

For your example, you use an illegal alien with FIVE children? Why not eight children? It would make your figures even MORE grandiose.

andytv
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:29:00 PM
This whole scenario looks so appealing I am thinking of renouncing my citizenship and having a bunch of kids!!!!!

Before I do this...............Greenwolf......this is all true right??

donutboy2000
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:36:00 PM
Do you ever trade in kind?
manko
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:41:00 PM
Only if you can read it on the internets.
Big Dick Cheney
Saturday, November 3, 2007 9:42:00 PM
I never pay for it., but mabye if it was Valerie Bertinelli...