Guys. I'm sure most of you have a father that at one point in time said to you these very wise, and always true words: "Nothing in life is free".
This is actually true on so many levels in life. It can be seen in physics, biology, but I want you guys to think of the way this applies in economics.
I've been thinking a bit about some people's bitching about the costs of illegal immigrants. And while I am NOT advocating illegal immigration, I do feel that any argument really should be based in truth, not in emotional catchphrases.
So, lets think about these catchphrase concepts:
"They come into our country and don't pay any taxes!"
It is the rare illegal that pays no taxes. Some may pay fewer than you, but lets look at them.
1) Property taxes. Anyone pays this, whether they are legal or illegal. So, any home-owning illegal is actually paying for their local services.
2) Sales taxes. Again, everyone pays this (if it exists in your state).
3) Income taxes (state and federal). This one is trickier, and depends on how they are employed. If the illegal is paid under the table - cash, then both they AND THEIR EMPLOYER are avoiding paying income taxes. Something to note, this is likely NOT common, for a few reasons: a) requires cash in hand; b) sends up a red flag for any tax audits of the company.
The most common situation is that an illegal immigrant gets a hold of a social security number and uses that be paid based on. This means that their employer is certainly being taxed on their wages and THEY are also being taxed.
"They are taking away all our jobs!"
Yes. Yes they are. But that's capitalism, baby! As long as you, as a shopper buy things based on price, then the manufacurer will buy their labor based on price! Look at it this way, at least this way the manufacturing stays in the country. Otherwise it will just be outsourced to China.
"They are costing us Bajillions of dollars!"
I bet if a smart man were to take all the variables into account, he would find that they aren't costing us anything. Do you know why? Because nothing in life is free. This applies to us and to them.
Money is just being shifted around. Illegals come here and work for barely anything. They DO take resources in the form of local schools, and local hospitals. But what you are forgetting is that they also BRING resources to the table. Dirt cheap labor.
So yes, a small portion of your local taxes is being spent on illegal immigrants. But guess what? Because of the illegal immigrants, a lot of your goods and services are marginally cheaper. Nothing is free.
If we made all the illegal immigrants disappear today, yes, there would be lower burden on the schools and ERs at the border towns, but think of how the labor rate would change for a lot of the goods you purchase. Suddenly, instead of paying illegal immigrants almost nothing, growers/manufacturers have to pay a LOT more, if they even decide to keep the operations in the US. That cost just gets passed on to the consumer. So, instead of higher taxes, your fruit goes up in price, your services go up in price. You're going to pay for it one way or another.
Again, I'm not advocating anything, one way or another. I just want people to think rationally about the arguments before screaming a lot of emotional, inaccurate statements.