I've used both Dish & DTV for years. Dish for the past 4, 2 of those have been with the HD package (and HD/DVR).
Their HDDVR is currently the best on the market. The dual room version is actually a tri-receiver, because you can plug in an antenna for OTA-HD, and it counts as a third line. So we can record 2 at a time over the satellite, and one of the network channels on OTA. Hugely helpful if you watch the junk-tv on the networks. 🙂
The Center Ice package is great, as you get broadcast options from both Home and Away (in most cases).
The downside is no Sunday Ticket. But, if you want that in HD, you're looking at $350 a season... so, it would have to be Really worth it to you. (I miss seeing my Eagles, but couldn't add that kind of yearly bill for football).
Years ago when DTV told me I had to buy all new equipment because they were charging cards (again), I told them I already had $700 worth of receivers that I wanted to use. They told me no. I told them that I'd just switch to Dish and get free equipment. They said "go ahead". So I did.