MiamiJosh
Saturday, December 8, 2007 11:19:00 PM
Anyone have them? Are they any good? I've had DirectTV for @7 years and recently bought a HD TV. I called to ask about the HD/DVR and the best they could do is $300 for one. Dish offered me four rooms (I have two now with Direct TV) with two of them being HD/DVR for free, plus a few months of HBO/SHOWTIME for free. It almost seems like a no brainer but I hate to give up the football Packages. I told DirectTV about the other offer and they basically said "How nice, $300 please." Any input would be appreciated.
315press
Saturday, December 8, 2007 11:24:00 PM
i had it but switched to cable for the internet package so i could snipe bids at the last second
thatguyisbrett
Sunday, December 9, 2007 12:31:00 AM
drop the satelite and get cable. if its got to be satelite stick with direct tv. dish is garbage as far as hd goes. also dish doesnt have "on demand"
thatguyisbrett
Sunday, December 9, 2007 12:34:00 AM
right now i have hd/dvr from time warner cable in two rooms with hd and hbo and broadband internet for about 150 a month. i think its around $80 just for hd/dvr
MiamiJosh
Sunday, December 9, 2007 1:11:00 AM
We have comcast down here, and it's definetly another option..
neopuritan
Sunday, December 9, 2007 2:20:00 AM
I'm here in SFL... Just dropped Dish Network and went with Directv. DN sucked on several levels--service, channel lineup, infrastructure, complexity. DT is much better. Comcast is good, but didn't seem to have a comparable channel lineup. More bang for the buck DT. Also, intro offers are sweet, but EXPIRE. If you want HD, get it now on a switch--best value.
Gene363
Sunday, December 9, 2007 4:19:00 AM
We had Dish for many years, we left them and went with Comcast. We got a package deal for TV and telephone service since we already had them for Internet. It is nice to have TV during heavy clouds and thunderstorms.

The only thing I miss about Dish is their DVR had a button that would jump ahead 15 seconds for every press. Our current Comcast DVR (DCR3416)has a button that will jump back but not forward. You have to fast forward.

A J
  • A J
  • Enthusiast
Sunday, December 9, 2007 4:45:00 AM
HAD DISH FOR 5 YEARS LIMITED SPORTS. THE COMPANY OFFERS GOOD SERVICE, BUT YOU MUST ! WATCH ! THEM AS THEY ARE ALWAYS TRYING TO TAKE YOU OVER.

A J

Ram27
Sunday, December 9, 2007 5:04:00 AM
Had for years, had no choice because of location.

Expect loss of signal with DN & DT when it rains hard.

If Verizon FIOS is avaible go with it and go with the package deal and now offering free HD TV.

Good luck.

pgje51
Sunday, December 9, 2007 5:18:00 AM

Have had dishnet since '97 for a mountain cabin we had. Still have here

in the foothill boonies too. No cable out here. Have eyed the direct TV 'package dea'l a few times but just can't pull the trigger NOT knowing the real outcome of differences.

Everyone has a story or supports one or the other based on their own experiences.

andytv
Sunday, December 9, 2007 6:04:00 AM
I had directTV for several years (can't get cable here).........the signal **** the bed every time it rained.

Their service dept didn't seem to think it was an issue so I switched to Dish Network and the signal seems a LOT better during foul weather.

Charlie
Sunday, December 9, 2007 6:14:00 AM
Have been on Time Warner forever, and I keep threatening to leave, but I have all the movie channels, actually everything you can have, HD, etc along with phone and Roadrunner (high speed internet) and my bill for 3 set ups is $230 per month.

My biggest complaint is not enough HDTV channels....

Charlie

8trackdisco
Sunday, December 9, 2007 6:40:00 AM
^

The other good thing is threatening Time Warner with leaving for satellite. Their reps get paid to save accounts.

With little work, I was able to get Time Warner to knock $20a month off of their rate.

MACS
Sunday, December 9, 2007 6:47:00 AM
^Maybe I'll try that.

I have the package deal of phone, internet and cable but I sure would like the NFL mother effing Network.

gonesledn
Sunday, December 9, 2007 7:29:00 AM
pro sand cons of each service provider.

to me i prefer direct tv because they have the most HD programming, and more sports programming.

i have to say that i only rarely lose my sat signal.

dkeage
Sunday, December 9, 2007 7:32:00 AM
^Me too Wes, if your losing your signal during light rain, then the dish is either old, or not installed correctly,,,,,, When Hurricanes Katrina and Rita came around, the cable went out, but not DirecTV

AND, I can watch any NFL game I want......in about 30mins!

gonesledn
Sunday, December 9, 2007 7:47:00 AM
i agree, if you lose signal alot, have it prfessionaly readjusted.

within a year or so, a tree that had no effect on your signal could have grown enough to hinder your signal.

a neighbor could have built an addition that gets in the way... lots of reasons.

guyute
Sunday, December 9, 2007 10:55:00 AM
I've used both Dish & DTV for years. Dish for the past 4, 2 of those have been with the HD package (and HD/DVR).

Their HDDVR is currently the best on the market. The dual room version is actually a tri-receiver, because you can plug in an antenna for OTA-HD, and it counts as a third line. So we can record 2 at a time over the satellite, and one of the network channels on OTA. Hugely helpful if you watch the junk-tv on the networks. 🙂

The Center Ice package is great, as you get broadcast options from both Home and Away (in most cases).

The downside is no Sunday Ticket. But, if you want that in HD, you're looking at $350 a season... so, it would have to be Really worth it to you. (I miss seeing my Eagles, but couldn't add that kind of yearly bill for football).

Years ago when DTV told me I had to buy all new equipment because they were charging cards (again), I told them I already had $700 worth of receivers that I wanted to use. They told me no. I told them that I'd just switch to Dish and get free equipment. They said "go ahead". So I did.

MiamiJosh
Sunday, December 9, 2007 11:22:00 AM
Yeah DirectTV doesn't seem too concerned that I may leave, and that bothers me. After seven years of being a good customer you'd think they would want to keep me somewhat happy. Thanks for all the input.
Ram27
Sunday, December 9, 2007 11:26:00 AM
Verizon " FIOS " ~~~