GJT
  • GJT
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Friday, December 14, 2007 10:02:00 AM
Putting polyurethane on my hardwood floors tomorrow morning and can't decide between oil & water based. I want to keep the floors as light as possible making me lean toward the water based. When looking into things though I have found the water based is "good for low traffic areas". Is the water based polyurethane that much less durable than the oil based?

Please help!

GJT

Goathead50
Friday, December 14, 2007 10:12:00 AM
Use oil based. It will dry harder. Just don't put more than 3 coats on. Be sure to lightly sand in between coats. We installed hardwood flooring in my mom's house and used oil base poly. It looks like a new gym floor.
Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, December 14, 2007 10:14:00 AM
Ping gonesledn
Goathead50
Friday, December 14, 2007 10:49:00 AM
ping TG . He knows everything!
Charlie
Friday, December 14, 2007 10:53:00 AM
I agree with Goat....Oil, way to go!!!!

Charlie

HockeyDad
Friday, December 14, 2007 10:54:00 AM
Ping JPotts....He'll explain it in detail.

I would use oil. I always view oil favorably.

jpotts
Friday, December 14, 2007 11:00:00 AM
Oil-based sealers work best on most Venesuelan hardwoods.
Thunder.Gerbil
Friday, December 14, 2007 11:27:00 AM
RE #4-

No, that's jpotts's job.

porschesales225
Friday, December 14, 2007 11:32:00 AM
having done this before on multiple occasions. Water based has easy clean up and gives the wood a more "natural" look when done. However i would not use it where heavy furniture, pets or children are concerned as it will wear out fairly quickly in comparison to the heavier shinier and more "fluid" looking oil based sealant. Use a very fine paper btw layers just a light buffing will do and oil has a nice way of filling in. also give the wood a Warmer look in my opinion.
jpotts
Friday, December 14, 2007 11:37:00 AM
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that most people use water-based polyurethane to try and keep the "natural" look of the wood. Oil-based tends to yellow over time, which can be good or bad depending on the look you're going for.

I've always used an oil-based poly when finishing wood, especially with oak, cherry and pine. I find that it adds more of an orangeish-cast to the oak and cherry, and really accentuates the color of the pine over time. I've used water-based a couple of times, and wasn't really impressed with the look.

I'm not sure which is more durable, but I'd place my bets on the oil-based.

From everything I've read, the "ideal" look for wood can be found in shellac, which usually incorporates a pigment. Shellac, however, is not very durable and is subject to water damage.

Usually, when finishing wood, you're supposed to put on a thin coat, let it dry, then go over the finished surface with steel wool or a fine-grit sandpaper to knock down the peaks, and provide a roughened surface to let the next layer adhere to. I'm assuming this is the same for wood flooring. I could be wrong.

Once again, this is a perfect question for gonesledn and/or UsaHog.

seaborn
Friday, December 14, 2007 11:46:00 AM
I put down a water based poly on the oak floor of my house 12 yr ago. It looked good. Two years later I put down an oil based poly. Had too. That oil based still looks good today.

Make sure you get the right vicosity to match temp and humidity when you lay it. Makes the job go alot smoother/easier. Just do a couple test apps and thin accordingly.

usahog
Friday, December 14, 2007 12:00:00 PM
IMHO..

http://www.onlinefloorstore.com/store/mfgline/?id=13 

Is one of the best out there.. been using it for years on my products.. both my B-I-L and Nephew who are both commercial floor installers use this when it comes to big jobs like Gymnasiums etc.

good for high traffic area's

Hog

gonesledn
Friday, December 14, 2007 12:07:00 PM
Hog is the man with the plan when it comes to wood. i would take what he says as the truth. i dont work much with unfinished wood floors. i work alot with prefinished, synthetic,vinyl wood plank, among other flooring types.
pacman357
Friday, December 14, 2007 12:28:00 PM
#9 My stepson had hardwood floors put in his living room and dining room. Then he got furniture that keeps sliding around...bad move with three kids, two dogs, etc. I suggested he pick up some non-skid bath mats, cut pieces to fit the legs of the furniture, then glue the pieces on the feet of the legs. Cuts down on sliding furniture in a big way.
porschesales225
Friday, December 14, 2007 12:37:00 PM
ive laid many square feet of unfinished floor both resi and commercial. Go with the oil and like it was said before apply in a warm house sand lightly and clean floor between layers. The good thing about a heavy oilbased finish is you can light sand it again if it looks scuffed up after a while.
GJT
  • GJT
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Friday, December 14, 2007 12:54:00 PM
Thanks guys for all the advice! Wish I had more time to get this done, I'd definitely have gone with the Bona Kemi. I'd have to wait for it to ship to me since there are no distributors near me. Live & learn I guess. Next time I'll have this stuff on the way long before I start.

Thanks again all!

GJT

donutboy2000
Saturday, December 15, 2007 10:30:00 AM
Use the water based. The oil based will yellow more over time. Also the government mandates that in the next few years the oil based materials will be phased out due to VOCs. You will be able to top coat a water based installation every four to five years as needed. If you use oil, it will not be available in four to five years and you will have to strip the floor and use the water based product.
puskarich
Saturday, December 15, 2007 11:05:00 AM
I've put both oil and water on my wood and......

nah...too easy.