Was the 'Lights Out' you were listening to from the the Wyllis Cooper era ... or the Arch Oboler era ???
I had and old viynl record of the some of the broadcasts from when I was a kid ... and lent it to a friend who never returned it.
Some of my favorites that gave me nightmares when little was his legendary 'Chicken Heart' and the simple but effective "thump-thump" of an ever-growing, ever-beating chicken heart which, thanks to a scientific experiment gone wrong, threatens to engulf the entire world ...
... and that 'slimy smoke' thing that would turn people inside out.
True radio horror classics ... that really took your imagination for a ride.