drksdbubba
Wednesday, February 13, 2008 7:16:00 PM

The Backlash Against Berkeley

Military.com | By Kelly Johnson | February 08, 2008

If the Marines are no longer welcome in Berkeley, then the city will lose millions in federal funding.

That's the message that Marine Corps supporters are sending Berkeley's city council members if the push to close the Marines' Shattuck Avenue recruiting office continues.

The backlash against Berkeley intensified when an anti-war measure supported by the group Code Pink was approved by the city last week. The measure urged Marine recruiters to leave Berkeley's downtown office.

"Our goal is to have clear zoning regulations for military recruiting and to put citizen pressure to shut down the existing recruiting station that is just blocks from Berkeley College, UC Berkeley, and Berkeley High School," according to Code Pink's website.

If city council members don't rescind this resolution, lawmakers including Assemblyman Guy Houston (R-San Ramon) will introduce legislation that will strip more than $3.3 million in transportation funding away from Berkeley.

Houston's proposed measure is similar to the Semper Fi Act of 2008 -- authored by several Republican senators -- that proposes that more than $2 million dollars in federal funding for the city be rescinded and transferred to the Marine Corps.

"I cannot stand by and do nothing while the City of Berkeley declares war on the United States Marine Corps," said Houston in a press release.

"The Marines, and all of our branches of the military, deserve the honor of our elected officials, not their scorn," he added.

In an effort to calm tensions between Republican lawmakers and the city, Berkeley Mayor Tom Bates released a statement that attempted to clarify the city's position on the Marines recruiting center.

"Let me be absolutely clear that this is not about the men and women who are serving our country in our armed forces. I am a retired U.S. Army captain and I respect the choice of those who are serving our country.

"I also understand that the language proposed to the council did not adequately differentiate our respect and support for those serving in the armed forces and our opposition to the Iraq war policy. I will be working with the council to clarify that language at our next meeting."

Code Pink and other anti-war protestors plan to continue to push for the relocation of the Marine Recruiting center, by collecting 5,000 signatures from Berkeley voters to show the Marines that they are "not welcome in the city."

However, a Marine Corps spokesman told CNN that there are no plans to relocate the Marines' recruiting office.

(If you support the Semper Fi Act and want your state representative to take action, visit Military.com's Legislative center.)

TBWCW
Wednesday, February 13, 2008 7:24:00 PM
http://apnews.myway.com/article/20080213/D8UPDU5G0.html 

Feb 13, 7:11 AM (ET)

By MICHELLE LOCKE

BERKELEY, Calif. (AP) - City council members who were criticized for telling Marine recruiters they don't belong here have moderated their position, saying they oppose the Iraq war but support the troops.

The Berkeley City Council voted two weeks ago to send a letter to a downtown recruitment station advising the Marines they were not welcome.

After a marathon session that stretched into early Wednesday, the council decided against sending the letter, saying it recognizes recruiters' right to be in Berkeley. The council members say they still strongly oppose the war and the recruitment of young people, but "deeply respect and support" the men and women of the armed forces.

Some on the council had pushed for issuing an apology. Others rejected that, saying they just wanted to clarify their position.

Councilwoman Linda Maio said the council opposes recruitment, not the military. "It's behavior that we oppose, not the people," she said.

The meeting drew hundreds of people on both sides of the issue who rallied outside City Hall from dawn until well into the night.

Inside the chamber, scores of speakers addressed the council, some decrying its earlier action.

"You owe our military an apology," said Kevin Graves, a San Francisco Bay area resident who said his son died serving in Iraq.

Others applauded the council's stand.

Medea Benjamin, co-founder of the anti-war group Code Pink, said her group supports the troops - "we support them so much that we're desperate to get them back home."

In rallies outside, pro-troop group Move America Forward sponsored one protest, holding signs that said "Stop Bashing Our Boys." On the other side, anti-war group Code Pink held bouquets of flowers and waved signs saying "Peace Now" and "Bring Our Troops Home."

Police estimated the crowd at about 2,000 at its height. A handful of people were arrested for scuffles between protesters, police spokeswoman Sgt. Mary Kusmiss said.

The recruiting office opened in Berkeley in late 2006. It operated quietly until four months ago, when Code Pink began holding regular protests.

anewday
Wednesday, February 13, 2008 11:19:00 PM
Yesterday on Fox News, they kept referring to the City Council members and those that supported the anti-war agenda, and the anti-recruiting agenda as "those people that are against the troops."

I found it pretty fair and balanced.

JonR
Wednesday, February 13, 2008 11:31:00 PM
Fox news is always fair and balanced!

JonR

neopuritan
Thursday, February 14, 2008 4:06:00 AM
Gotta love Fox
andytv
Thursday, February 14, 2008 4:33:00 AM
This whole thing is really stupid and is giving BOTH sides a chance to spew misleading propaganda and spin it out of control.

To me it is simple....

1) The Berkeley community is protesting the war; and in doing so, they have decided that they don't want to feed the machine by providing local recruits. The ethics of military recruiting tactics have been questionable for decades, so this is no surprise.

2) The conservative govt thinks that Berkeley should forfeit federal aid because of their position.

I'm not so sure that this the right move.

MY town doesn't have a recruiting station......should we also forfeit federal aide???

Maybe the amount of federal aide granted to a community should be determined by how many troops they recruit.

It is doubtful that Berkeley could FORCE the office to close, so if I were in charge, I'd just say......."Thanks for the suggestion, but we are staying......if you have a problem with that, take it up with Congress.....now get these cameras out of here."

tailgater
Thursday, February 14, 2008 7:45:00 AM
Berkeley has a right to refuse the recruiting station, and the federal government has a right to refuse them funding.

How could we possibly argue that one has a right and the other does not? Nobody is looking to bomb the city or to even fine them.

But please tell me why it's not fair and balanced to call those opposed to recruiting as being "against the troops".

That is a direct action intended to hurt the armed forces, thereby hurting the troops themselves. Intentional or not, they ARE hurting the troops.

How much more "against" them can they be?

By the way, does Berkeley still prohibit the displaying of the American Flag on their firetrucks and police cars?

But allah forbid we call them un-American...

JonR
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:02:00 AM
"Nobody is looking to bomb the city or to even fine them."

Damn what a shame, somebody has to step up and do their duty!

JonR

porschesales225
Thursday, February 14, 2008 8:11:00 AM
with holding tax dollars based upon a city councils belief that the recruiters a lieing to the youth in order to promote a war that they do not agree with.

Does that not seem wrong to you guys. The problem here is it sets a precedent.

Why cant a city openly state that they do not like something especially a federal law or statuet. Id like to so more places stand up for what the local people believe as I dont feel that the current government really reflects the people and it may have gotten a little to big for my tastes.

Supporting the troops and agreeing with the recruitment process are seperate issues for me. While i support the men and women who are over there doing what they said they would I do not whole heartedly agree with why they are there and the pretenses that got them sent there. But I respect them for doing their jobs. I am not a fan of some of the tactics i have heard recruiters using to get people to enlist but that does not mean i do not support the armed forces and the people who are serving our country. You can disagree with something and not be against it.

Take a deep breath and really look at the situation before you get all love it or leave it with people. There are shades of gray in the world not everything is black and white.

JDELLLL
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:35:00 AM
Quit making excuses for these **** with a lot of articulate bull*hit. What they're doing borders on treason.
jetblasted
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:39:00 AM
Finally . . .

A Voice of Reason . . .

andytv
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:42:00 AM
YES!!!!!!

Bash their skulls!!!!

HockeyDad
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:45:00 AM
City, county, and state governments need to learn their place and realize that theirs is only to serve the Federal government.

We already fought a war to crush states's rights and cities and counties should not think they hold some sort of exemption from the same thing happening to them.

jetblasted
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:47:00 AM
Old Times There are Not Forgotton . . .
Charlie
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:47:00 AM
Uh, James, (anewday) I thought you supported the troops......where did I go wrong in that belief.

Charlie

Charlie
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:51:00 AM
Simple and peaceful solution to the problem....stop all their Federal monies that are earmarked for Berkeley and then let them see how much they would love the military.

Charlie

daveincincy
Thursday, February 14, 2008 9:57:00 AM
Is there even anybody within the Berkeley area that would even consider enlisting in the military? Sounds rather counter-productive. Seems about as productive as the KKK setting up recruiting stations on the campuses of Grambling, Florida A&M, or Morehouse.
CWFoster
Thursday, February 14, 2008 11:43:00 AM
Let's see, these were the people who a year or so ago were saying "we support the troops, just not the war!"

HORSEHOCKEY!

CWFoster
Thursday, February 14, 2008 12:12:00 PM
"Yesterday on Fox News, they kept referring to the City Council members and those that supported the anti-war agenda, and the anti-recruiting agenda as "those people that are against the troops."

I found it pretty fair and balanced."

They SAID "The Marines are not welcome in Berkley" that sounds pretty 'support the troops not the war' to me!

jpotts
Thursday, February 14, 2008 12:15:00 PM
I kinda like andytv's "skullbashing" idea.