Tuckersdad
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 7:34:00 PM
How many believe -

- That the whole Global Warming claim is real, and should be taken very seriously, very soon.

- That the whole Global Warming claim is a bunch of hooey by self serving fruits and nuts . . . the world has gone through periods of cooling and warming since the beginning.

Your thoughts?

blackfoot11
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 7:35:00 PM
bush's fault.............
ScottHar
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 7:54:00 PM
Is there a third option where rational adults can calmly discuss the degree to which human activity may or may not be contributing to climate change?

Didn't think so. "The debate is over!"

ScottHar

usahog
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:00:00 PM
Al Gore sure has made a ton of cash off of it...

why not, we're all gulable (well some are anyways)

Bible says the entire earth will be heating up some day... I do think that some day is coming sooner then later? might see it in my lifetime?

Kids ask me, Dad, when you gunna quit smokin? I say, when my ashes go out?

Sure been seeing allot of global changes recently (past couple years) it snowed in Baghdad this past December.. kinda cool eh? Hows that for global warming? a city so close to hell you can see it from there.. and they get snowballs..

Hog

jetblasted
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:01:00 PM
It snowed yesterday in Atlanta . . .

Just flurries, but all over the metro area . . .

jpotts
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:03:00 PM
Most of the accurate climate data only goes back about a century, or so. After that it's ice cores, tree rings, and rock samples that can often have more than one explanation. And even with that, the analysis of these things is always in a state of flux.

I've heard it all: it being hot in the summer is "proof" of global warming (as if it's supposed to snow). My favorite was that because we had tornados in Michigan last year, that was more evidence of Global Warming. As if we've NEVER had tornados in the past...

Also given that Al Gore has glomed onto climate change as his guiding principle - and the fact that the man is a drooling moron - I don't think it's too much of a stretch to call it bunk.

It was something like 38 deg F here today. Yep, still waiting for that whole Global Warming thing to kick in...

victor808
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:06:00 PM
risk analysis.

Is it worth being wrong? Are you willing to risk your children's future on it? What are the costs to you in acting in a more responsible manner on the off chance that we do have an impact on the environment?

Another way of looking at it, what do you really think the odds are that our unprecedented population growth and consumption DOESN'T have an impact on the environment (whether it's global warming or whatever).

Now, I'm personally willing to bet your children's future on anything. I don't give a rats ass about your children (or your grandchildren). So I'm fine with torching to environment in a controlled 50 year burn. I would personally like to ensure that the planet dies when I do. But that's me.

cbc812
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:09:00 PM
My take is that the bulk of the truly independent science has shown definitively that our emissions are at the very least contributing to an acceleration of the earth's normal cycles of heating and cooling. Just because it was a warm winter in your town this year doesn't mean that climate change is bunk. With the amount of scientific data available, and the amount of true experts weighing in, I think that global warming is certainly more than a crackpot conspiracy/end of days story hatched by environmental whackos.

A funny coincidence is that our reliance on petroleum products is considered to be the primary driver of said emissions. Our reliance on petroleum products is also makes us slaves to - and victims of - the dwindling supplies of oil and the people who control it. Want proof? How about four dollar gas and jihadis that live in caves but can still afford flight school and a hell of a lot of IEDs? That's proof enough for me.

The solution is fairly simple in theory, if not in practice - what we need is a serious investment in alternative energy sources, and a paradigm shift in how we look at and approach energy sources and consumption. Making this a national priority would help the U.S. in three different areas: It would help us stave off the potential disastrous consequences of a major shift in the global climate; It would give comsumers, at some point, relief from the pinch on their wallets from perpetually rising oil and gas prices; and finally it would stop the flow of our dollars......AMERICAN dollars, to people who seek to hurt our country and its interests.

But this will not happen. The debate has been framed as tree hugging flakes vs. heartless realists, and once again we're left to fight with each other while the $$ that put our officials in office dictates what really happens.

And I think that sucks.

jpotts
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:17:00 PM
"My take is that the bulk of the truly independent science has shown definitively that our emissions are at the very least contributing to an acceleration of the earth's normal cycles of heating and cooling."

That's the problem, there is no "definitive" conclusions.

At one time it was said that saccarine was a "definitive" cancer-causing agent. Now it's off the list.

As far as "risk" is concerned, there are any number of variables that go into the environment that are not taken into account. The earth has been warmer than it is now, and it has been colder than it is now, and none of this has had anything to do with man-made emissions. And in another ten years, the same scientists (or the same types of scientists) will be saying the exact opposite of what they're saying now.

If you need proof, all you need to is look at news reports over the last 100 years. It's all there.

What I find amusing is that there are saps who actually believe this garbage.

cbc812
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:27:00 PM
^ jpotts -

Seriously, dude.

I would refer you to victor's post (#9) - is it really worth the risk, waiting for something you consider to be "definitive"? What would that be? Our major ports underwater? Phoenix buried under 4 feet of snow?

Your post also ignores the fact that addressing global warming would by definition address the effect of oil prices on our economy and the funding of radical terrorist organizations. Are you fighting the fight just to be a good soldier and make the folks you voted for happy that you are too busy ranting to make them do anything? Now THAT's dedication.

AS a side note, I do want you to know that I am still practicing my groveling....you remain the golden god of cigar elitists, no matter how lame your political posts are.

cbc812
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:56:00 PM
Also.....since I can't help poking the bear:

"saps who actually believe this garbage"

Gosh - you mean the world renowned scientists? The climatological, physics geniuses?

Please inform the forum what, exactly, qualifies you to label these people as "saps".

I know you can do it, Sparky.

jpotts
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 8:58:00 PM
Seriously.

I've been hearing about "ports under water" now for about 5 years. Nothing has happened. Secondly, people seem to forget that additional heat in the planet causes additional evaporation, putting more water into the air.

By the way, these "eminant" scientists openly admit that percipitation - a huge factor in the cooling of the planet - is not even considered in their various models. They don't include it because no one knows exactly how it fits into the environment. Yet with so many unknown factors, they can "definitively" predict what's going to happen 20 years out.

Bull.

By the way, it was more than 10 years ago when Ted Dansen - quoting a recognized scientist - said that in 10 years the oceans would be dead. When called on it, he muttered something about hyperbole, and "attracting attention" to the plight of the oceans. In the end, the prediction was still completely bogus.

They also make predictions about how many animal species will go extinct, when they're discovering more animal species each year then they say go exitinct. So without an accurate accounting of the various varieties of animals that exist on the planet, they make doomsday predictions that are literally pulled out of their a**.

And people still believe this nonsense.

I remember the predictions of how this year or that year was going to be a terrible year for hurricanes, and then none even showed up.

But I think most importantly, they cannot even predict with a fair measure of certainty what the weather will be like from one day to the next, however, they can make all sorts of outragous predictions 20 years down the pike.

They can make these extended predictions knowing that after 20 years, most people will have forgotten the utterly stupid things said by "accredited" scientists with a personal or political agenda.

P.T. Barnum was right. There is a sucker born every minute.

jackconrad
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:01:00 PM
We need top hurry up the warming so it happens before we run outta oil.
jpotts
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:07:00 PM
"Gosh - you mean the world renowned scientists? The climatological, physics geniuses?"

No, the people who actually take what a lot of these people say without a healthy measure of skepticism.

I would ask you to wake up from the little dream world you're in, and join us in the land of Reality. Those reports that the IPCC (I beleive that's what it's called) are compiled by a large number of scientists, but edited by a select few. These are typically the politicos, who have specific political agendas and / or personal ulterior motives. And there is a lot more money to make in preaching doom with some accreditation, than there is to say that nothing is wrong.

I've heard scientists who contributed to the IPCC reports dispute the findings. So, this whole unity thing amongst the scientific community belief is complete crap.

"Please inform the forum what, exactly, qualifies you to label these people as 'saps'."

I'll tell you what, we'll wait ten years and see if New York is under water. Then I'll give you my qualifications.

Outside of that, it's called "reading", "listening", and using your head.

By the way, I've interviewed numerous people who used to work on the various U of M climate models (University of Michigan in Ann Arbor). I wouldn't let these people wash my car, nevermind write working, production software for me.

Where there's smoke, there's fire.

But hey, you keep "the faith" with this stuff. I'm patient.

cbc812
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:12:00 PM
"P.T. Barnum was right. There is a sucker born every minute."

Dude - you use that WAY too much. It might lead one to believe that you rely on tired, predictable crap. But we all know that's not the case.

Your problem here, jpotts, is twofold - first, you insist that since our cities aren't awash in seawater at this moment, global climate change is a fantasy. The sheer desperation of this argument makes me feel bad for you, big guy. You decide to cite the words of the much quoted, extensively peer-reviewed climatologist Ted Danson as proof that the specter of global warming is merely something cooked up by kooks for fun. You might not realize this, given the desperation you must be feeling at having been stretched to the outer limits of your talking points here, but the sheer silliness of your post is almost too much to bear.

Plus, once again, you failed to address the fact that dealing with the "phantom" threat of global warming would also serve to address two of the other grave issues facing our country.

But that's okay. Keep up the good fight. You've almost made me forget that the real problem in this country is a disfunctional, corrupt government and not "people liek you" ("people that disagree with me"). Keep scrapping - your elected officials, and especially their sponsors, are grateful.

cbc812
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 9:18:00 PM
"I'll tell you what, we'll wait ten years and see if New York is under water. Then I'll give you my qualifications... By the way, I've interviewed numerous people who used to work on the various U of M climate models"

Well gosh, that sure is a ringing endorsement of your ability to size up the intellectual and scientific aptitude of these people. Why don't you do to the UN and TELL them you've INTERVIEWED NUMEROUS PEOPLE WHO USED TO WORK ON THE VARIOUS U OF M CLIMATE MODELS??!???!!?!??! I would never have disputed your assertions about climate change if I had known the depth of your background and the extent of your investigation into this subject. Yikes. You are, like, the MAN.

Sorry to remind you - bet there's still that pesky issue of the resolution of the climate change issue being vitally important to the country's other national interests.

Those talking points are hard to give up, aren't they?

They must be when they're all you've got.

Nutttttttttty
Tuesday, March 25, 2008 11:31:00 PM
No I think Humans have really thrown things out of the natural balance. It really suprises me that it can be a question at all.

WE ARE FU%KIN IT ALL UP. WE POLLUTE OUR AIR AND OUR OCEANS AND ANIMALS AND PLANTS DIE AND SOME HAVE TO ASK IF WE ARE MAKING MISTAKES ON A GLOBAL LEVEL. LOL

Lowman
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 3:23:00 AM
We're still coming out of our ice age and the Earth is getting back to its normal tempature...