pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 6:53:00 AM
As the toll of Americans killed in Iraq topped 4,000 this week, President Bush publicly vowed "to make sure that those lives were not lost in vain"—that the war's outcome "will merit the sacrifice" and that "our strategy going forward" will be to "achieve victory."

We all wish that this were so. But what does he mean by "victory"?

The definition has evolved, or devolved, in the five years that this war has been raging. Originally, victory was conceived in grandiose terms. The defeat of Saddam Hussein's army and the toppling of his regime would spawn a new democratic Iraq, the example of which would ignite the flames of freedom across the Middle East

Bush scaled back the standard in a November 2005 speech at the U.S. Naval Academy titled "A Strategy for Victory." This victory will come, he said, "when the terrorists and Saddamists can no longer threaten Iraq's democracy, when the Iraqi security forces can provide for the safety of their own citizens, and when Iraq is not a safe-haven for terrorists to plot new attacks on our nation."

In January 2007, the National Security Council formalized the concept in a document titled "The Iraq Strategy Review," which stated that the "strategic goal" was "a unified democratic federal Iraq that can govern itself, defend itself, and sustain itself, and is an ally in the War on Terror."

Bush and others have heralded much progress in the past year, as the troop surge went into effect and as Gen. David Petraeus devised new tactics based on counterinsurgency principles. Casualties have gone down, in some areas dramatically. The Iraqi army and police have grown in size.

However, by the Bush administration's own standards of success, laid out in the president's speech and the NSC's strategy review, we are no closer to victory now than we were when those documents were drafted. Iraq is not unified, it is only superficially democratic, it cannot govern itself, its security forces cannot provide for the safety of its citizens, and it remains more of a haven for terrorists than an ally in the war against them.

Gen. Petraeus has said many times that there is no strictly military victory to be had in Iraq. The goal of the surge—and, at this point, of the U.S. military presence generally—is to provide enough security, especially in Baghdad, to let the Iraqi factions settle their sectarian disputes and form a unified government. If this political goal isn't achieved, then the surge will have been for naught. And lately, Petraeus has expressed disappointment that the Iraqis have made so little progress on that path.

The instances of progress, especially the reduced casualties (among American soldiers and Iraqi civilians), are valuable for their own sake. But body counts have never proved much. When Americans killed more guerrillas in Vietnam, it didn't mean that we were closer to winning that war. And when insurgents are killing fewer Americans in Iraq today, it doesn't mean that we're closer to winning this war, either. (If you think that it does, you would have to conclude that we're closer to losing the war this month than we were last month because casualties have gone back up.)

The troop surge has been one of several factors that have made life a little less treacherous in Iraq this past year. Another is the "Sunni Awakening," the alliances of convenience between U.S. forces and Sunni insurgents against the common enemy of al-Qaida in Iraq—alliances that were initiated by the Sunnis before the surge began. Still another is the moratorium on violence called by the leading Shiite militia leader, Muqtada Sadr.

But look at what is happening. First, the surge is ending this July, not because it has been successful (as Bush has sometimes claimed) but because of simple math. The five extra combat brigades, which were deployed to Iraq with the surge, each have 15-month tours of duty; the 15 months will be up in July; the final brigade will go home; and the U.S. Army and Marines have no combat brigades ready to replace them. To the extent that the surge has improved life in Baghdad, the end of the surge (the timing of which is inexorable) may make life worse.

Second, the Sunni Awakening is showing its frays. Some of these militias haven't been paid for months, and they're going on strike, refusing to man their checkpoints and battle stations. They are also frustrated by the Shiite-led government's refusal, despite earlier promises, to let them join the Iraqi national army and police force. This is another consequence of the sectarian leaders' failure to settle their disputes and form a unified government.

Finally, the Shiite militias have resumed attacks in southern Iraq, a sign either that Sadr is losing control over his men or that he himself is backing away from the moratorium. In either case, it's unlikely that many Sunni militias—especially given the training and reinforcements they've received from U.S. armed forces—will stand by as the Shiite militias start fighting again.

the administration's own measures, then, victory in Iraq is not in sight, nor is there much evidence that the road we are treading will lead us toward that destiny.

A wartime president who has no real allies and whose own military is too small to achieve such lofty goals should begin to scale back his rhetoric so that it has at least a patina of plausibility. By defining victory in Iraq as an outcome that lays “the foundations for peace for generations to come,” George W. Bush ensures that defeat is nearly inevitable.

The above was taken either directly or indirectly from Slate.

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 7:03:00 AM
pmn1,

There are actually two events of war going on.. can you name these two?

Hog

pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 7:06:00 AM
HOG

I sorry I don't understand your question. That being said lets assume that I don't know what the events are.

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 7:26:00 AM
well with two events of war going on... lets assume their would have to be two victory's NO?

I mean in all honesty, the only thing I see you and others who are disgruntled about their wallets and or watching/feeding to much mainstream media into your bloodstream(s) is this "War" in Iraq...

and then we all get to read a copy and paste that was found somewhere on the internet? with no discussion of this other event of war and how many soldiers we've lost in that conflict?

These two events to get you and others current pmn1 are

1. OEF "Operation Enduring Freedom" which was the initial and still is the Main Priority or WAR we are in and will be in Until "Victory" weather your wallet says so or not!

2. OIF "Operation Iraqi Freedom" which is a major part of the OEF. because we're using their playing fields in Iraq and drawing out terrorists in their neck of the woods rather then your back yard... in which I still think is the right thing to do.. I could just imagin how you would respond if you had an F-16 do an air strike in your neighbors back yard while your trying to read the paper and have your morning coffee...

Something to think about...

Oh and if you see a Soldier today... Thank Him/Her!

Hog

pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 7:47:00 AM
Ok lets discuss the 2 "events" of the " war".

First whats wrong with being Disgruntled because my wallet is being affected by this occupation?

Secondly can you identify the objectives for the misinformed like myself of OEF. I honestly don't know what they are which may lead to some of my frustration as to OEF.

Next to mention OIF and seem to rationalize that as long as we have this conflict in the Middle East that fact alone justifies the entire conflict - which by the way I am unaware of the objectives for "victory" are. Your position assumes that the Iraqis had or have the ability to conduct this "war" on our Land. Yet I know you are aware that they don't and not since the revolution has a war been fought on American soil with a foreign country. With all due respect to infer that F16s flying overhead to fight this conflict - is pure paranoia.

so lets discuss it

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:06:00 AM
First whats wrong with being Disgruntled because my wallet is being affected by this occupation?

Because that is showing just about how much you really give a **** about this situation WE are all in, and really truely are being inconsiderate of your fellow Americans and Especially our men and women who are sacrificing a hell of allot more then just their Wallets on "both" these conflicts.

Basically your running with Blinders on and the media is feeding your frenzy...

_________________________________

Secondly can you identify the objectives for the misinformed like myself of OEF. I honestly don't know what they are which may lead to some of my frustration as to OEF.

The Objectives of OEF are the same as they were right after 911... We're taking this fight to them (extremist/terrorists) or whatever you want to call them.. the one's who started this **** by attacking we Americans on American soil and spilling innocent blood... It's been pretty clear and to the point since (not positive on the date?) October ? 2001...

I know on Sept. 12th 2001 We were and possibly still are doing a Mission known as "Nobel Eagle" I'd bet a dollar to a donut that one is still going on and you don't/wont hear much about it...unless you ever hear of another hijacking situation... but because of OEF and OIF.. I don't think you'll ever see that happen again?

So when you post something like Bush is asking for $$$80 Billion more to support the war in Iraq... a good part of that money's is also going to support the OEF as well... course the media and left wingers don't want the American people to honestly know that... they want the focus to remain on Iraq Especially with a Death Count of American lives Lost... this discredits our Soldiers who've lost their lives in Afghanistan and elsewhere's in these War Efforts.. and quite frankly that is BULLSH!T...

Hog

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:07:00 AM
Oh and one more thing...

"by this occupation"

Think real Hard....

Would you rather have Occupation Here in the USA.. or keep it abroad where it is today???

Hog

HockeyDad
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:23:00 AM
Technoically, nobody's wallet is being affected by OIF or OEF because all the funding has come from borrowing and we have not instituted a "War Tax". If someone invested wisely, it is quite possible that their wallet has been enhanced by the wars.

The reality is that the immediate war debt and long term veterans care costs will eventually come due. We might not be able to just keep refinancing the debt and leave it for our children so at some point we may have to recognize that all personal income tax brackets will need to be raised by 10% for many years just to pay the war costs. To ease the increased tax burden, we do still have the option of slashing veterans benefits.

When the tax bill comes due, we all need to recognize that it is a small price to have to pay for our freedom.

cbc812
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:26:00 AM
^ I agree - can you put a price tag on our liberation from Saddam's tyrannical rule?

Things in my town are much better since the war started.

HockeyDad
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:27:00 AM
A 10% tax increase across all income taxes should be enough to pay off the war debt in 15 years and then we can drop tax rates again.

Unless we spend a little more and nail Venezuela.

pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:33:00 AM
Because that is showing just about how much you really give a **** about this situation WE are all in, and really truely are being inconsiderate of your fellow Americans and Especially our men and women who are sacrificing a hell of allot more then just their Wallets on "both" these conflicts

Lets not confuse my or any-body's questioning of taxpayers money with support of the troops. - NOT the same and Hog I'm sorry its a Cheap argument in defending the administration spending outrageous amounts to keep this war going. If you can't separate that fact then in your black and white world anything anyone says to question our position in Iraq is not only wrong but treason. Well I Strongly disagree and further discussion would not only be pointless but antagonistic which was not my intent.

Lizardo
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:35:00 AM
"First whats wrong with being Disgruntled because my wallet is being affected by this occupation?"

It would make that person a greedy, selfish twit.

And we are not "occupying" any country, please look up the definition of that word.

Victory means a more peaceful middle east, less terrorism across the globe, and no more whining coming from liberal Americas cigar BB's, Latte shops, or Von Maur's, while American solders are in a far off country doing a job they were asked to do.

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:41:00 AM
"its a Cheap argument in defending the administration spending outrageous amounts to keep this war going."

Which War pmn1?

now I'm getting confused...

Hog

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:44:00 AM
and BTW I'm not defending this administration in any way shape or form Pal! They are on their own...

I'm defending Our Soldiers and their War Efforts.. don't confuse the two!

Hog

BTW... F*ck your Wallet... you should have been wise and invested like HD pointed out above..

pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:50:00 AM
"Victory means a more peaceful middle east, less terrorism across the globe,"

What Victory ? against who? Iraq? terrorists? who?

There has been conflict in the middle east for over 2000 years - thats a Fact. Your "Victory" will not stop it because its not entirely based on borders or economics or power. Its based on religion therefore it will have no end. Until we recognise that we have no control of when it will end we will try to impose western logic and totally miss the boat - continue to spend lives and money for no solution.

teedubbya
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:50:00 AM
interesting perspective by Henry Rollins.... the shorter version

Q Now, when you do these USO events, I'm curious, how do you find a balance between disagreement with policy and support for the troops?

A Well, I just tell the truth. I know the soldiers don't set the policy. Well, in a way they do. When they're going house to house, they might be the first American person that the guy whose door they kick down will meet. So hopefully it's as good as that is ever going to be and they don't make more enemies instead of making friends and win hearts and minds. But the Army did not come up with the invasion and occupation of Iraq. That was done somewhere else. So my beef is not with the military. I think a lot of people share that attitude. And the right tends to highjack the idea that they are the only ones supporting the troops, and if you're somehow in favor of kids not coming home with their legs blown off, you are in fact anti-troop, which is a talking point when you're immature and have no game.

Q So it's simply a question of being yourself, saying what you want to say and letting the chips fall where they may?

A No, not necessarily, in that the war that these guys are fighting day to day is not the same war that we are watching at home in the luxury of our living rooms. If you say to a solider, "Intelligence was manipulated prewar, cherry-picked to facilitate this invasion and occupation of a sovereign nation," et cetera, he just will say, "I'm 23. I go out for 12 hours a day, and my mission is don't get blown up, keep my buddies safe, get back to base. Hope the piece of garbage I'm driving by does not blow my Humvee up. Please keep your diatribes against the administration to yourself because it's really not anything that has to do with me today at noon when I go out on patrol." So it's my opinion that that kind of talk on what they're doing is not appropriate at that time.

You can have your little disagreement with the Iraq war, and boy, I've got them, with those guys, sure, when they're home, safe, in the parking lot of your show in the safety of Minneapolis. But when you're out there in it, in the middle of it with these people, I think what they need to hear from me is, "I've got you covered. Thanks for doing what you do. Get home safe." Because this kind of stuff could be somehow deleterious to morale or be distracting. You don't want these guys thinking about, "Remember what Henry was saying?" You want these guys looking around and getting home safe, and that's all there is. It's very clear.

They just want to hear about the time you were a Jackass. They want to laugh because when you see what they do for a living, you provide distraction. Crack them up, tell them a story. That's what these trips are all about. It's not about you; it's about them. It's not a hard thing to wrap one's head around, and you just do it.

Q What were your impressions of Iraq?

A It's very frightening and awe-inspiring. At the same time it's very sad, because people are being blown up on both sides. It's just incredibly infantile. It's like the 8-year-olds in the sandbox, but now they're 20, and it's all for keeps now. But they're throwing bullets and bombs, not sand and dog doo. I just don't see any upside to Iraq. I don't think we're wanted there. Almost every base we were at, someone had been killed in the last couple of days. But I like the troops and that's why I go.

Q Did going to a war zone change how you saw war and the military?

A What hit me was the infantile nature of the whole thing. A bunker-buster bomb? Who made that up? It's just ghastly, the maimings and injuries coming back from this thing that you never read about. It's like jaw missing, balls gone, leg gone. These guys are coming back hamburger to a Veterans Administration that doesn't have the funds or the time to deal. It's a **** tragedy.

pmn1
  • pmn1
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:57:00 AM
So Hog you agree with HD - "at some point we may have to recognize that all personal income tax brackets will need to be raised by 10% for many years just to pay the war costs. To ease the increased tax burden, we do still have the option of slashing veterans benefits".

Ok I'm fine with that if you are.

usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:57:00 AM
#15,

There has been conflict in America for over 200 yrs based on Religion, Race and Ignorance...

Your trying to turn this discussion and focus back to narrowmindedness Only Iraq...

you asked, I enlightened you on the total picture.. your focus.. Wallet and Iraq and squeal like a pig until somebody listens and agree's...

no need for further discussion on this topic... your boats been sunk pal...

Hog

HockeyDad
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 8:57:00 AM
The HockeyDad denies any allegations or war profiteering.
usahog
Wednesday, March 26, 2008 9:02:00 AM
#17,

Yes I do agree with HD.. on many issue's he's very sharp..

I'd rather be paying more then seeing what I am seeing our future heading into...

China Owning US Soil?