I bought a new phone a few months ago. When I talked to the sales guy (who had just transfered to sales from a few years in the repair department) I mentioned my interest in the Razr. He showed me the model and, in a low voice, explained to me how many repairs he saw with the original model. I told him I had heard they had improved this newer version and he said, "Well, I've looked it over and it doesn't seem like they improved it that much. Can't really recommend it."
I ended up with another LG, the EnV. Best damn phone I've had yet. Better camera (love being able to get photos from my teenage daughter when she is out with her friends and the ability to get a shot of local wildlife, show the wife something in a store to see if it's what she's looking for, etc., the uses are endless), I actually enjoy getting texts from my wife or daughter, love the full keyboard when it opens, and best of all the reception and sound quality are awesome. Oh yeah, it's stereo enabled so it doubles as a somewhat limited Ipod.
While I agree that these things are getting ridiculously complex, to me - a guy who loves toys - more is more.