Okay. HockeyDad et al:
Poligamy IS NOT ILLEGAL under US federal law. It may be illegal under one or more state laws, but the US federal government does not prohibit it.
What is illegal is to be married to more than one person UNDER THE LAW. I know that doesn't make any sense, so I'll use an example.
John and Cynthia apply for a marriage license and marry. Their pastor does the ceremony and signs the license. So far so good. That's one CIVIL marriage and one CHURCH marriage.
John and Cynthia agree that one woman isn't enough for John. John wants to marry Elaine as well. Their pastor agrees and they are married in a RELIGIOUS ceremony. As far as they are concerned they're married. As far as the government is concerned they are merely cohabiting.
This kind of thing can continue as long as people agree to do so. John, Cynthia and Elaine think of themselves as a family. John thinks he's married to two women. Voila! Polygamy. Not illegal as things stand right now.