c3s,
There really is no definitive answer to this kind of a problem, it could be any number of things. Some of the more common ones:
Have you installed any new software recently?
When screensavers don't kick in, it's usually because the system isn't actually "idle".
Sometimes it's the automatic anti-virus scan that keeps the screensaver from triggering. Other times it's an automatic defrag program like DiskKeeper or Raxco. Could be something as simple as a poorly written chat client that is supposedly sitting idle in the systray. Could be something like CD/DVD burning software constantly polling the optical drive. The list goes on nearly forever, those are just some examples.
You can try exiting / disabling software that is running from the systray and see what happens. You can also bring up the task manager and see what is running in the background.
Another possiblity is a device driver spazzing out. This sometimes happens with pointing device drivers (mice, touchpads, trackballs, essentially anything that drives the cursor). Rather than the cursor actually sitting still, it "vibrates" or "jitters" in place. The screensaver function interperts this as input and therefore the computer must be in use, so it won't kick the screensaver in.
Lastly, check your power management settings, see if anything has changed there.