jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Wednesday, April 30, 2008 7:53:00 PM
Anyone ever used this? I'm thinking of replacing my upright electric smoker with a charcoal smoker, mainly to get better flavor. I want more room, but a barrel-type grill with an offset firebox takes up a lot of room on my patio. Looking around, I came across The Smokenator, which fits in a 22.5" Webber kettle grill - a perfect compromise between space on the patio and space in the cooker.

All the reviews I've read on it make it sound like a good device. But I was wondering, has anyone here had tried it? If so, what did you think?

vegasryan777
Wednesday, April 30, 2008 7:54:00 PM
3 words

BIG GREEN EGG!!!

andytv
Thursday, May 1, 2008 5:36:00 AM
^troo dat.........but pricey.

I'd get the Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker.

andytv
Thursday, May 1, 2008 5:53:00 AM
jpotts......

I briefly reviewed the Smokenator website, and I don;t think I'd get one of those things.

First of all, there is misinformation on the page......the water does NOT keep food moist. Fat in the meat does. The water is solely a heat sink to help control temperature.

Secondly, I HAVE used my Weber kettle as a smoker. I constructed a setup somewhat like this one; in addition I used a microprocessor driven temp controller (monitors temp and supplies/restricts airflow as required). Even with all of this, it was very difficult to maintain constant temperatures suitable for BBQ. I was either burning too hot or two cool and had to add quite a bit of charcoal over the cooking cycle. I only did all of this to see if it could be easily done.......it could not.

Thirdly, I don't think you would be happy with the amount of space left in the grill. If you are going to BBQ something for 12 hours (i.e. pork shoulder), you might as well do as much as you can....it freezes well. Plus the six hours of charcoal will not support such a long cooking cycle.

Bottom line.....it might work, but it would be a hassle. Knowing what I know now, I would not settle for anything less than the WSM with a bbqguru controller.

00camper
Thursday, May 1, 2008 7:34:00 AM
/////This is a test./////
jjohnson28
Thursday, May 1, 2008 7:42:00 AM
^****!

Just get the WSM. With or without the BBG Guru, you too can make great BBQ!

JJ

jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 1, 2008 9:49:00 AM
andytv:

I've done a little reserach about this Smokenator thing. Almost all of the reviews I've seen about it have been positive, which is the reason why I've even bothered considering it. I'm aware of that humidity issue, and I've seen this guy post on a couple of BBQ websites something to the same effect. He also admits that his website kinda sucks.

Appearently, if you do a little reserach, this guy has done his homework to the point where I think you'd even be impressed. The instuction manual, from what I've read, is pretty complete including charts and graphs, and a lot of technical information. In fact, I'm beginning to wonder if this guy who made this is some sort of engineer.

The guy who makes this device also details the smoking procedure for wet or dry smoking (indicating no water in the pan). So I believe that the intention of the resivour (sp:?) is for temperature control.

I'm also not ruling out getting a Smokey Mountain Cooker either.

teedubbya
Thursday, May 1, 2008 9:51:00 AM
wsm will have 30 pounds of beef in it this weekend.

potts.... don't even

teedubbya
Thursday, May 1, 2008 9:59:00 AM
may as well just get one of those cheap smoke boxes and throw it in... or foil and chips....

****

dkeage
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:00:00 AM
I gots @#2 AND #3........

Use one for grillin, and one for smokin......

Go for the WSM!!!!

NINE!

jjohnson28
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:02:00 AM
I gots to get to work.

Smokenator This! Looking for finger or rabit chingas...LOL

andytv
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:20:00 AM
#7......

It sure seems like people like these; maybe it CAN control the temperature.

The big problem, for me anyway, would be capacity......both food and fuel.

A reasonably sized butt, brisket, or chuck roll is gonna take at least twelve hours......usually meaning an overnight BBQ session if you want it done in time for the game. This means at least once you will have to recharge the fuel (maybe in the middle of the night).

Also, the anxiety from not being able to monitor the process is going to keep you from your sleep.

Using the "Minion Method" (or a variant thereof) and the WSM......I can smoke for longer than 12hrs without ever having to open the smoker. The bbq guru makes it even more efficient.

Set it, forget it, eat it.

jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:24:00 AM
Ok, doing a little more research (and not doing work):

The DigiQ II adapts for both a Weber kettle and the Smokey Mountain Cooker. It appears to use the same door adaptor, and on the The BBQ Guru website, it has pictures of a full setup for a standard Weber kettle.

So I guess my next question is: with The BBQ Guru, do you need the fan, or is this optional? Secondly, do you need to use water with The BBQ Guru (DigiQ II)?

Here's the thing...my wife will *freak* if I suggest spending $250.00 on a new smoker at this point. In fact, with the kind of money we're laying out for resolving my older son's school issues, repairs on the hous, and so on it ain't going to happen.

I can, however, get her to budge on maybe $150.00. That's enough for a Weber kettle, and a Smokenator. Plus, it makes logical sense to me that having a heat-shield / heat radiator to contain the fuel and wood minimizes scortching, and can control heat to some extent.

Later on (maybe next year) I can invest the money into The BBQ Guru.

Either way, the electric smoker is gonna go. I'm not getting the results I want because I'm missing the flavor from the charcoal / briquettes.

teedubbya
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:24:00 AM
I'm planning on 17 to 18 hours this weekend.... may come in less than that but if I was a betting man.....
jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:26:00 AM
By the way, while the BBQGuru looks like a great idea, the website sucks when it comes to trying to figure out what configuration you need.
teedubbya
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:27:00 AM
if you go that route drop me a line

hat andy... did you get the competitor? If I had it to do again I might just do the pitminder cause I rarely use the meat probe (true in more ways than I'd like to admit)

teedubbya
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:28:00 AM
hat = hey

christ

Goathead50
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:28:00 AM
Get a pit smoker and use real wood.
teedubbya
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:30:00 AM
I don't know who you are talking about... I do not use trex or anything like that..... only real wood

dork

jpotts
  • jpotts
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, May 1, 2008 10:32:00 AM
If I buy one and get it to work, maybe I can get a "maverick" title?