Ok, it's looking like Barak (cheese-eating) Hussien (surrender-monkey) Obama, DTB, ES and John McCain are going to be the candidates this year. So, I thought I'd pick a subject, and try to compare the differences between their two stances. This post will be concerning education.
I'm using the candidate stances on their websites to try and make a decent comparison.
Barak (cheese-eating) Hussien (surrender-monkey) Obama, DTB, ES:
http://www.barackobama.com/issues/education/
* Supports No Child Left Behind ("The goal of the law was the right one..."), but feels it is underfunded. he will reform the act and increase funding.
* Will quadruple Early Head Start, increase Head Start funding and improve quality for both (this is a direct quote).
* Provide affordable and high-quality child care to ease the burden on working families (another direct quote).
* Will limit / restrict / improve (?) standardized testing assessments required for federal funding ("Obama believes teachers should not be forced to spend the academic year preparing students to fill in bubbles on standardized tests.")
* Will increase funding for schools who do poorly on the starndardized testing assessments ("Obama will also improve NCLB's accountability system so that we are supporting schools that need improvement, rather than punishing them.")
* Increase funding to education to provide dropout interventions, in an attempt to keep kids in school ("Obama will address the dropout crisis by passing his legislation to provide funding to school districts to invest in intervention strategies…")
* Double the funding for afterschool programs ("Obama will double funding for the main federal support for afterschool programs, the 21st Century Learning Centers program, to serve one million more children.").
* Supports transitional bilingual educational programs (whatever that means – another quote).
* Pour money into a new Teacher Service Scholarship fund (proposed on the website).
* Force public and private schools to become accredited ("Obama will require all schools of education to be accredited.").
* Increase pay for teachers who mentor, work in "undeserved areas" like rural and urban areas (whatever that means), and perhaps merit pay.
* Expand summer schools for disadvantaged children.
* Expand outreach programs for low-income families to get their kids into college.
* Create a Teacher Residency Program. It dies not say whether this will be funded by the fed or the school district (most likely with federal money).
* Expand mentoring programs that pair experienced teachers with new teachers. I know for a fact that a program like this is already implemented in my kid's school district, which makes a federal program redundant.
* Implement a tax credit for sending kids to college.
* Simplifying the student loan application by merging it with your tax-return information.
* No mention of school choice.
* No mention of parental involvement in a child's education.
Final analysis:
Pour more money into the schools. Pour more money into failing schools. Provide federal dollars for child-care services. Give people tax-breaks for sending their kids to college. More federal intervention into state / local schools. Expanded programs for low-income families. No expansion of programs for middle- and upper-class families. The insertion of the federal government into ALL acedemic institutions, including private schools that don't receive federal money at present, and perhaps even home-schoolers. Parental involvement only mentioned in crisis situations (Zero-to-Five program and dropout intervention).
Now McCain:
http://www.johnmccain.com/Informing/Issues/19ce50b5-daa8-4795-b92d-92bd0d985bca.htm
* Supports No Child Left Behind. No mention of additional funding.
* No mention of Early Head Start, or Head Start.
* No mention of child-care.
* Seems to support the current standardized testing assessments for accountability.
* Will use competition and school choice to weed-out under-performing schools. No funding increases to poor performers ("John McCain believes our schools can and should compete to be the most innovative, flexible and student-centered - not safe havens for the uninspired and unaccountable.").
* No dropout retention programs.
* No mention of afterschool programs.
* No mention of "transitional bilingual educational programs".
* No mention of a Teacher Service Scholarship fund (this is an Obama idea).
* No mention of forcing accredidation on schools.
* Prefers merit pay for teachers ("He believes we should let them compete for the most effective, character-building teachers, hire them, and reward them.").
* No mention of expanding summer school programs for disadvantaged children.
* No mention of any college outreach programs for low-income families.
* No mention of a Teacher Residency Program (this, again, is an Obama idea).
* No mention of a teacher mentoring program (which I already think is redundant).
* No mention about tax credits for college.
* No mention of simplifying student loan applications.
* Big supporter for schools of choice / school competition.
* Big supporter in keeping parents the key component in their child's education.
Final Analysis:
Have schools compete for funding. No additional expenditures outlined, but no tax breaks either. No expansion of existing programs, no extending the federal government reach into schools. No class or income-bracket supports. Parental involvement in the child's education is the centerpiece of his agenda.