cbc812
  • cbc812
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:24:00 AM
I was wondering how the GOP would capitalize on Obama's race and play it to the fullest without revealing its intent to coax as many racist voters to the polls as possible. Looks like we didn't have to wait too long to find out.

The tactic goes something like this, and I'll keep it simple: Accuse any and all Obama supporters of supporting Obama "because he's black" and call it "reverse racism". Then, go on to imply that a vote for McCain is a vote against those voting on the basis of race and is therefore the non-racist thing to do. Consequently, if you are gullible enough to believe this, you will vote against the black man and thus in your mind be able to justify it as casting a vote against racism. Of course, for most (not all) Obama supporters, race has nothing to do with it, with the "reverse racism" being largely manufactured by GOP operatives and pundits. But say something loudly and often enough (page 1, GWB playbook) and the masses will not only believe it, they will forward it in email and defend it vociferously on the internets.

Those guys are really good. It's sad that it's so easy.

MiamiJosh
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:26:00 AM
Yeah, because voting for a lying Freshman senator with no experience makes TOTAL sense.
DrMaddVibe
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:28:00 AM
SNOBama isn't black.

HE'S GREEN!

No experience in the real world and nothing of notable mention from his political side either.

cbc812
  • cbc812
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:34:00 AM
^ #s 2 and 3

Those are valid points and deserve discussion and debate. My point, which you both chose to ignore, is that the accusation that the majority of Obama supporters are voting based on race is a smookescreen and is designed to bring the true racists to the polls in support of the GOP.

teedubbya
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:36:00 AM
he is not black.

he is more like an eskimo pie

cbc812
  • cbc812
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:37:00 AM
^ You just want to lick him, you shameless craven.
VaMtnMan
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:38:00 AM
Isn't that like the Democratic Play Book. You know the one I am talking about. Page 281, paragraph 3, 2nd line down. "Call anyone who does not support Obama a Racist and insist that they are only voting for Hillary or McCain because Obama is Black."

cbc812
  • cbc812
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:41:00 AM
And you have seen/heard people doing this where? When?

Or did you get an email forward about it?

ScottHar
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:45:00 AM
re 1: Thanks for keeping it simple! (Even I could almost understand what you're suggesting here.)

Just to make sure we're clear:

For (most, if not all) Obama supporters, race has nothing to do with their support of him.

Wow.

I'm eager to hear how you gleaned this amazing fact. Although I appreciate the acknowledgment that it may not be every single one. There may be a few (4? 7?) among the millions of supporters for whom race did, in fact, have something to do with the support.

I dunno. Maybe I'm just frustrated and bitter. I can't figure out how that wiley ol' GOP keeps duping me into voting for their puppet. If they'd just stop appealing to the racism I try so hard to hide, it'd be much easier...

ScottHar

Boss
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:48:00 AM
Obama is half black, so that let's the Republicans off the hook, making them only 'half racist'

the problem is, that makes blacks half racist, too

MiamiJosh
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:49:00 AM
cbc,

Your point doesn't fly with me. It's just the same old "every white person is racist BS." I didn't comment because I'm sick of hearing it and because your reasoning is more of a figment of your imaginattion than any real facts.

The fact is whites are MUCH more likely to vote for Obama than blacks are to vote for McCain. So your point just doesn't make sense.

teedubbya
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:54:00 AM
Ebony and Ivoryyyyy

live together in perfect harmony

come together my piano keyboard oh lord

why don't we

VaMtnMan
Thursday, June 5, 2008 8:55:00 AM
Obviously not everyone who is voting for Obama, is voting for him because of his Experience.

It's OK to vote for Obama because he's black

I'm voting for Obama because he's qualified, charismatic and progressive -- but his blackness seals the deal.

By Gary Kamiya

Feb. 26, 2008 | I admit it: I'm voting for Barack Obama because he's black. Yes, I'm voting for him because he's qualified, intelligent, charismatic and competent -- and because unlike Hillary Clinton, he opposed the Iraq war from the beginning. But if he weren't black, and Hillary had opposed the war, I'd probably vote for her because of her greater experience. In any case, it's a moot point, because if Obama weren't black, he would not be the Democratic front-runner.

I believe that most of Obama's supporters are voting for him for the same reason. Like me, they're drawn to his idealism, his youthful energy, his progressive politics. But it's his blackness that seals the deal.

And that's OK. In fact, it's wonderful.

There's a lot of resistance to this idea, and a lot of discomfort about even expressing it. In online discussions, many whites vehemently deny that Obama's race played any role at all in their decision to support him. They insist that his color doesn't matter, that they decided to support him simply because he's the best candidate.

This reaction is understandable. It feels more racially enlightened. To baldly proclaim that you support Obama because he's black seems to diminish his real qualities and achievements -- his stellar academic career, his work in the urban trenches, his liberal voting record, his ability to inspire. Foregrounding Obama's ethnic heritage implies that you're unhealthily obsessed with race, and make artificial decisions based on it. It can be seen as patronizing, as a merely sentimental, pie-in-the-sky gesture.

Unable to directly challenge Democratic voters' race-driven enthusiasm for Obama because that would make her look racially insensitive, Clinton's attacks on Obama as a false messiah covertly echo this theme. "Now I could stand up here and say, 'Let's get everybody together, let's get unified, the sky will open, the light will come down, celestial choirs will be singing,'" she said sarcastically Sunday in Rhode Island. "'And everyone will know we should do the right thing, and the world will be perfect.'"

Neocon pundit Bill Kristol, whose unerringly wrong track record on Iraq earned him a spot on the New York Times' Op-Ed page, joined Clinton in bashing Obama as a bogus messiah (also without mentioning race). In his Monday column, Kristol wrote, "[T]he effectual truth of what Obama is saying is that he is the one we've been waiting for."

Some critics who directly acknowledge the racial nature of Obama's appeal have argued that the wave of white support for Obama bespeaks not a genuine desire to bridge the racial divide but a bad-faith attempt to escape into some post-racial never-never land. David Ehrenstein, who is black, wrote a widely discussed column last year in the L.A. Times in which he argued that Obama's appeal derives from his role as the "Magic Negro," a benign, unthreatening figure who suddenly shows up to offer racial absolution to mildly guilty whites. "The less real he seems, the more desirable he becomes," Ehrenstein writes. "If he were real, white America couldn't project all its fantasies of curative black benevolence on him."

Some conservatives, not surprisingly, have blasted the racial component of Obama's white support, seeing it as a kind of affirmative action for undeserving minorities. A post on the right-wing site Townhall.com excoriated Democrats for treating the campaign like an affirmative action program, handing a "completely unqualified" candidate the nomination "because he's part of a minority."

All of these criticisms, whether they acknowledge it or not, are based on the fact that Obama's blackness is his indispensable asset. Without it, he would not have a snowball's chance in hell of being elected president.

Let me be absolutely clear: This does not mean he's not qualified. He is -- and if he weren't, he wouldn't have a chance to be elected either. I support Obama for a lot of reasons that have nothing to do with his race. I want to take a chance on a younger candidate who is less entrenched with special interests. I've had enough of the Bush/Clinton dynasties. And, above all, I support him because he was opposed to the Iraq war, and will turn decisively away from the disastrous militarism and ideological extremism of the Bush years.

But if Obama were a white junior senator from Illinois with the same impressive personal and professional qualities -- the same intelligence, empathy, speaking skills, legislative tenure and life story -- there'd be no way he'd have the name recognition to mount a major campaign in the first place. And if he did manage to run, it's unlikely he would have inspired such a passionate and widespread following.

Obama's charisma, which is his unique political strength, is real, but it cannot be separated from the fact that he's black. When Obama speaks of change and hope and healing divisions, his words carry an electric charge because of who he is: He embodies his own message, the very definition of charisma. As a black man offering reconciliation, he is making a deeply personal connection with whites, not merely a rhetorical one.

So white enthusiasm for Obama is driven by his race. But there's nothing wrong with that fact. Those who criticize it are simultaneously too idealistic and too cynical: They assume that it's possible to simply ignore Obama's race, while also imputing unsavory motivations to those who are inspired by it. The truth is that whites' race-driven enthusiasm for Obama is an almost unreservedly positive thing -- both because electing a black president is a good thing in its own right, and because of what that enthusiasm says about race relations in America today.

Yes, there can be a touch of bathos and self-congratulation in white Obama-mania. But so what? Great historical shifts are often accompanied by such feelings. Besides, sincerity and sentimentality are not mutually exclusive. Barack is no Magic Negro. The truth is, the more white voters find out about Obama, the more they like him. His story and personality resonate with whites. Obama has been able to bridge the gap between white America and black America because figuratively and literally, he's both black and white. Because of his personality, he's the perfect racial go-between: His nonthreatening demeanor allows him to connect with whites, while the fact that he's black -- and proudly and avowedly so -- makes that connection feel racially redemptive.

As for the right-wing dismissal of Obama as an unqualified recipient of a national affirmative action program, that argument is absurd because Obama is qualified. If he is indeed the beneficiary of a kind of affirmative action, it is one that he earned, and that is given freely -- it isn't mandated or coerced. White Americans have been waiting for a chance to bridge the racial divide, to affirm a universalist ethos. Obama has tapped into that need, and it turned out to be a gusher.

It's true that voting for Obama is in some ways a symbolic gesture, one that won't instantly solve America's race problems. But it will help. Symbolism is powerful. The racial politics that started at the symbolic plane can and will trickle down to real people. Having a black president would give the country a deeper comfort level in talking about racial issues. It would help Americans of all races break out of the sterile guilt/victim dialogue, or the fear of falling into it, that too often inhibits real communication. It could radically change our entire racial landscape, in ways we can't even predict.

And an Obama presidency would have far more than symbolic impact on America's race problems. Who doubts that Obama, a staunch liberal and former Chicago community organizer, will move aggressively and creatively to address the critical problems of black poverty and violence? And that when he appeals to black responsibility and self-empowerment, his words will have a million times more impact than when they come from a white Republican?

Many dismiss the Obama phenomenon as a mere "cult of personality." It is in some ways a cult, but not one of personality -- it's a cult of racial healing, of racial transcendence. For many whites, voting for Obama is a kind of appeal to one's better self, and the better self of the country. It is, in a way, a promise. It could even be seen as a kind of prayer.

Of course, Obama-mania can be accompanied by lightheadedness, irrational euphoria and giddiness. The post-racial sky will not open. There are limits to charismatic politics. And there will no doubt be an Obama hangover if he is elected.

Barack Obama is not a savior. But there's every reason to believe that if elected he will be a good president -- and maybe a great one. And every day that Obama is in office, even the bad ones, we'll be able to tell ourselves: We elected a black man president of this country. That thought, with all that it says about where we came from as a nation and where we hope to be going, will be a light that no one can put out.

-- By Gary Kamiya

http://www.salon.com/opinion/kamiya/2008/02/26/obama/ 

cbc812
  • cbc812
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:03:00 AM
^ #s 9 and 11

I am not accusing either of you of being racist, nor am I saying either of you ascribe to or have been duped by this political maneuvering.

This is simply an observation based on what I have read in the papers and seen here.

Simply put - most people will vote based on the merits of their candidate or party affiliation. You guys, as McCain supporters, are not automatically racist. Neither are Obama supporters. I was simply hoping to point out the uselessness of accusing someone of racism based on their candidate of preference. At the end of the day, I would say that there is probably a relatively equal amount of people voting Obama just because he's black as there is of people voting for McCain simply because he's not.

And yes, there are certainly elements of the left exploiting Obama's race and the specter of racism for political gain. They are just as reprehensible as their counterparts on the right.

I guess my goal is just to try to elevate the discourse here and point out that accusations of racism based solely on candidate preference (as opposed to making racist statements) are crap.

cbc812
  • cbc812
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:04:00 AM
^ #13

Absolutely a valid point.

At the same time, not everybody is voting for him because of his color, either.

ScottHar
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:04:00 AM
re 13: Stop contradicting the original poster! He assures us that for most (if not all) Obama supporters, race has nothing to do with their support.

You posting messages by Obama supporters who acknowledge that race IS a factor is... uh... disrespectful. Or unhelpful. And racist, maybe. Take your pick.

ScottHar

ScottHar
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:06:00 AM
re 14: You being reasonable is undermining my clumsy attempts at comedy.

STOP IT!

Or not. I'm going to get more coffee now.

Peace, brothers--

ScottHar

tdtall70
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:09:00 AM
I give up....
teedubbya
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:13:00 AM
I'm not voting for Obama because he is a homosexual
MiamiJosh
Thursday, June 5, 2008 9:13:00 AM
^#11 Great point, you're a smart guy..